Questions to Ask an NCSA Recruiter
Questions to ask before paying a college recruiting service such as NCSA: what it costs, what the contract commits you to, who you actually work with, how coaches see your profile, and what you could do yourself for nothing. Written for athletes and the parent holding the card.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
What does the service do that I cannot do myself?
Why ask it
The honest answer is usually a profile, some exposure, and guidance on process. Any claim of access that coaches do not already have deserves a follow-up you should not skip.
What does it cost in total, and over how long?
Why ask it
Ask for the price of every tier, what is billed monthly, and what happens at renewal. Get the numbers before the conversation about outcomes, not after.
Who will I be working with after today, and how often?
Why ask it
Ask for a name, a role, and a contact frequency. The person selling and the person assigned are usually different, and only the second one matters to you.
What is the cancellation and refund policy?
Why ask it
Find out what happens if you are injured, change sports, or commit early. Ask to read the clause rather than accepting a summary of it.
Which tier are you recommending for me, and why that one?
Why ask it
A recommendation tied to your sport, year, and level is credible. An upsell with no reasoning attached tells you what the meeting is actually for.
How many athletes does my adviser work with at once?
Why ask it
Caseload decides how much attention you get. A high number is not disqualifying, but it should change what you expect and what you keep doing yourself.
Which programs at my level have you placed athletes with in the last two years?
Why ask it
Ask for schools and years you can verify. Claims about thousands of coaches in the network say nothing about your division, your position, or your region.
Can I speak to two families in my sport who signed up last year?
Why ask it
Recent, same-sport references are the strongest check available to you. Hesitation on this question is worth more than any page of testimonials.
How do coaches actually receive my profile?
Why ask it
Ask whether coaches search a database, receive bulk email, or get contacted individually. Coaches ignore mass mail, so which of these it is decides whether the fee buys anything.
What are you basing your assessment of my level on?
Why ask it
Film, times, and a stated scale should all be named. An assessment that only flatters you has not been made by anyone who watched you play.
Which divisions should I realistically be targeting?
Why ask it
You want a narrow answer even if it disappoints you. Being told every division is open is a sign nobody has looked at the film properly.
What does my film need before it goes anywhere?
Why ask it
Length, what happens in the first clip, jersey identification, and how much unedited game footage sits behind the highlights. Sport-specific answers here show real knowledge.
What is the contact calendar for my sport and graduation year?
Why ask it
Recruiting rules differ by sport and division and they change. Anyone advising you should be able to state the current dates for your exact situation without looking them up later.
Where do I stand on academic eligibility?
Why ask it
Core course requirements, registration with the relevant eligibility center, and transcripts are gating items. Ask what is still missing rather than whether you are fine.
Who writes the emails to coaches, you or me?
Why ask it
Coaches recognize a template instantly. Ask to see an email that actually went out for another athlete in your sport, with the name removed.
What do I do when a coach replies?
Why ask it
Ask for the concrete next steps: what to say, what to ask about roster spots and money, and how fast to answer. This is where most families are least prepared.
What does an offer at my level usually consist of?
Why ask it
Athletic money, academic money, and a roster spot with no money attached are all described as offers. Ask how each one is put in writing and when it becomes binding.
What happens if I get no interest in the first year?
Why ask it
The answer shows how the service handles a poor outcome: a reassessment, new film, wider targets, or silence and a renewal invoice.
What do families most often regret spending money on?
Why ask it
Asked plainly, a candid adviser will name something, often an extra tier, a camp, or a video package that did not lead anywhere.
If I only emailed coaches myself, what would I be missing?
Why ask it
The most useful question in the meeting. A confident answer names something concrete, and a defensive one answers the question by itself.
What is your role: do you work with athletes day to day, or is your job signing families up?
Why ask it
Recruiting services use different people for selling and for coaching, and the person on this call may not be the one you would work with. Knowing which you have changes how much weight to give everything else they say.
Will the same person stay with us throughout, and what happens if they leave?
Why ask it
Turnover is common in this business, and a relationship with one helpful adviser is often what families are really paying for. Ask what the handover looks like and whether you get any say in the replacement.
Can you show me a message you would send a coach on our behalf?
Why ask it
Ask to see the real thing, and ask whether it comes from the athlete's address or the company's. Coaches learn to recognize bulk messages, and an email from a service can carry less weight than a short one from the athlete.
How do you define success, and what counts in the numbers you quote?
Why ask it
Percentages depend entirely on definitions. Ask whether a success means a scholarship, a roster spot, any college contact, or committing anywhere at all, including places the family could have reached alone.
Do college coaches pay you, or have any commercial relationship with you?
Why ask it
How a service earns money determines whose interests it serves. Ask who pays whom and whether any program has a paid arrangement, and treat any suggestion that a coach owes them a favor with caution.
What will you need from us in time, video and travel?
Why ask it
The fee is rarely the largest cost. Camps, showcases, travel and filming add up faster, and some plans assume attendance at paid events. Ask what the year actually costs including all of it.
What happens to our profile and video if we stop paying?
Why ask it
Ask whether the video and the contact list are yours to keep and export, or whether they live inside the platform. Losing three years of material at cancellation is a real cost that never appears in the sales conversation.
If we do nothing today, what do we lose?
Why ask it
This tests the urgency directly. Real deadlines exist in recruiting; discounts expiring at the end of the call are not among them. A pitch that collapses when you ask for a week is telling you what it was worth.
Can I have all of this in writing, including the price, before we decide?
Why ask it
Ask for the terms, the itemized services and the cancellation policy by email. Anything that cannot be put in writing is not part of what you are buying, and reading it away from the call is where the real decision gets made.
Deciding whether to pay for recruiting help
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
Before the sales call
Know what free looks like first
Coaches at most levels respond to a direct email with film attached, a schedule, and academic numbers. Try that for a month before paying anyone, so you can judge what the service adds rather than guessing.
Get your own numbers straight
Verified times, measurements, transcript, and test scores where they still matter. A service cannot assess you honestly without them, and neither can a coach.
Decide your budget before you hear the tiers
Pricing conversations in this industry are built around moving you up a level. Naming a figure to yourself in advance, and to the parent paying, makes the meeting much shorter.
Signals worth weighing
- A specific, slightly disappointing assessment of your level is a better sign than an enthusiastic one.
- Named placements in your sport and division within the last two years, which you can check yourself.
- A stated caseload for your adviser, given without hesitation.
- Willingness to put you in touch with a family from last season.
- Pressure to decide today, a discount that expires, or a claim that spots in your class are filling.
- Any suggestion that coaches can only be reached through them.
If you do sign up
- Keep emailing coaches yourself. Nothing about paying a service replaces direct contact, and coaches remember the athlete who wrote, not the platform.
- Ask for a written plan with dates for the next six months, and hold the review meeting when those dates arrive.
- Check what is going out in your name and rewrite anything templated.
- Track every reply in one place: school, coach, date, and what was said.
- Set a decision point in advance for whether you renew, and what would have to have happened by then.