Questions to Ask a New Coach
Questions to ask a prospective life coach, career coach or executive coach on the consultation call, and a new coach in the first few sessions. The page is about paid one-to-one coaching, not a sports team, and assumes you are the one paying. The 52 questions run in the order the decision does: the coach's background and training, how sessions work, how results are judged, boundaries and confidentiality, then cost and contract terms. The last group is for after you have hired them, when it still feels too early to question how things are run.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
Background
What kind of clients do you work with most?
Why ask it
Life coaching can mean a career change, a divorce, confidence or retirement, so this shows whether you are their usual case or an experiment. Coaches who name a narrow group tend to have real patterns to draw on, while a list covering everyone often means a thin practice.
What training did you do, and how long was it?
Why ask it
Coaching is unregulated in most places, so anyone can use the title. Ask about hours of training and assessed practice rather than the name of a certificate, since a course can be one weekend or run for a year or more.
Do you have a supervisor or mentor coach you take your own cases to?
Why ask it
Supervision means another experienced coach regularly looks at how they handle their clients. Someone with nobody reviewing their work has no outside check on habits that have stopped being useful.
What did you do before you became a coach?
Why ask it
A former manager, nurse, teacher or athlete each brings a different instinct to the same problem. The earlier career also shows what they know first hand and what they have only heard about from clients.
Why do you think you would be a good fit for what I have described?
Why ask it
This is the one to put to every prospective coach when you are comparing two or three, because each has to answer from what you actually said. A reply that would suit any caller means they were not listening closely.
Do you do this full time, and how many clients do you carry?
Why ask it
Part-time is no mark against them, and plenty of coaches keep a foot in the field they coach in. What matters is when they can actually meet, and how much thought your sessions get outside the hour when the roster is long.
Do you belong to a professional body, and which code of ethics do you follow?
Why ask it
The badge matters less than what sits behind it: a written code and somewhere to take a complaint. Ask which body, then look the coach up in its public directory yourself, since these bodies and their standards differ from country to country.
Have you been coached yourself, and what did you get from it?
Why ask it
Someone who has sat in the client's chair knows how exposed the opening weeks can feel. A coach who has never paid for coaching is selling something they have not bought.
What did you get wrong early in your career that you handle differently now?
Why ask it
They will be asking you to look hard at your own mistakes, so see whether they can do it first. A real answer has a client in it and a change in how they work. A strength dressed up as a flaw is marketing.
Sessions
What actually happens in a session? Walk me through the last one you ran.
Why ask it
Turns a philosophy question into a description you can picture. Listen for the balance between them talking and you talking, because some practices are closer to consulting or teaching than to coaching.
What would we be working on in the first month?
Why ask it
Write the answer down and read it back after four weeks; it is the nearest thing to a plan you will get on a consultation call. If all you hear is clarity and goal setting, ask what that looks like in week two.
Do you follow a set programme, or build the work around each client?
Why ask it
Neither is wrong. A fixed curriculum suits a common, well-defined goal and a tailored approach suits a messy one. The point is to hear which they sell before you assume the other.
When I ask what you would do in my place, will you tell me?
Why ask it
Some coaches hold that the answer has to come from you and will turn the question back every time. Others say what they think and let you argue with it. Knowing which you are hiring saves a frustrating third session.
How long is each session, how often do we meet, and is it video, phone or in person?
Why ask it
Dull, and worth settling early. An hour by video every fortnight and half an hour by phone every week are different amounts of work for both of you, and the rhythm ought to follow the change you are after, not only the coach's calendar.
Will I always work with you, or with another coach on your team?
Why ask it
Larger practices and online platforms sometimes sell on the founder's name and deliver through associates. That can be fine, provided you meet the person who will be on your calls and put these same questions to them.
What will you ask me to do between sessions?
Why ask it
Most of the change happens in the days between calls, in the conversation you finally have or the habit you try out. Get a rough number of hours a week and hold it against the time you really have.
Do you use assessments or questionnaires, and what do you do with the results?
Why ask it
Personality and strengths questionnaires can give you words for things you half knew. Check whether they cost extra, and whether the results shape the sessions or sit in a folder after week one.
How direct are you when you think a client is fooling themselves?
Why ask it
You are paying for an outside view, and a coach who only encourages is an expensive friend. Ask for something hard they said to a client recently, and how they put it.
What do you expect from me, and what would make you decline to work with someone?
Why ask it
Coaches with standards turn people away, and hearing the criteria tells you whether you have been assessed or simply sold to. It also sets out the effort involved before you have paid for it.
Results
How do we tell whether this is working?
Why ask it
Push for something observable rather than how you feel after a session, since talking about your problems is enjoyable regardless of progress. Agreeing a check-in point now makes it easier to stop later if nothing has moved.
Can you describe a client who started where I am, and what changed for them?
Why ask it
Ask for the whole arc: the starting point, what the person did differently, and how long it took. A story with no setbacks in it is an advert. Expect the details to be disguised, which is the coach protecting someone's privacy and a good sign for yours.
How long do clients usually work with you, and what makes them stop?
Why ask it
You want to hear that people leave because they got what they came for. Vagueness here, or a suggestion that everyone stays indefinitely, points at a model designed around retention rather than results.
What happens if I keep not doing what we agreed?
Why ask it
Stalling on agreed actions is ordinary, so the answer describes a large part of what you are buying. Watch for whether they treat it as information to work with or as a lack of commitment on your part.
Have you had a client relationship that did not work? What did you do?
Why ask it
A coach who can describe a specific mismatch and how they ended it well is describing professional judgment. Claiming it has never happened is either inexperience or unwillingness to admit it.
Could I talk to a past client or two, ideally someone who finished a while ago?
Why ask it
Testimonials are usually written in the middle of the work, when enthusiasm is highest. Someone a year out can tell you whether anything stuck. Expect the coach to ask their permission first, and take a no on confidentiality grounds as a fair answer.
Do you promise any particular outcome?
Why ask it
The honest answer is no, because the result depends on what you do between sessions. What a coach can commit to is their own side: turning up prepared, telling you the truth, and saying so when it is not working.
When would you tell me we should stop?
Why ask it
Listen for a concrete trigger, such as the goal being met or two reviews in a row with nothing moved. A general assurance that they would say something, with no example of having said it, is only a promise.
Boundaries
Where do you draw the line between coaching and therapy?
Why ask it
The most important safety question on the page. Coach training is not clinical training, so a careful coach will say which subjects they stop at and who they point people to instead. One who is happy to take on anything is a reason to keep looking.
Have you ever paused coaching and sent a client to a therapist or a doctor?
Why ask it
A yes, with a rough account of how it went, shows the boundary is something they act on. Never having done it is plausible in a young practice, so ask what would prompt it.
What is confidential, and are there exceptions?
Why ask it
Coaching conversations generally do not have the legal protection that talking to a lawyer or a doctor has, and the rules differ by country, so ask how it works where you live. Much of your privacy then rests on the written agreement. Read what it says about notes and about when the coach would break confidence.
Do you record sessions or use an AI note-taker, and where are the files kept?
Why ask it
Video platforms make recordings and automatic transcripts a one-click habit. Find out who can open them, how long they are kept, and whether you can say no and still be coached.
If my employer is paying, who is the client?
Why ask it
Skip this one if you are paying yourself. A company that pays usually expects to hear something back, so ask what the sponsor is told, in what detail, and whether you see it first.
Will you ever use my story in your marketing, a talk or a book?
Why ask it
Coaches build a reputation on client stories, usually with the names changed. Decide now whether you are comfortable with that, and ask that anything drawn from your sessions needs your written yes first.
Do you earn commission on anything you recommend to me?
Why ask it
Courses, retreats, apps and other coaches' programmes are sometimes recommended with a referral fee attached. A fee does not rule the suggestion out, but you should hear about it before the recommendation and not after.
What do you do if we turn out to know people in common?
Why ask it
Small towns, single industries and church or sports circles make this likely. You are listening for two things: that they never confirm who their clients are, and that they would raise an overlap with you instead of quietly managing it.
Cost and terms
What is the total cost, and what is the minimum commitment?
Why ask it
Ask for the full figure over the term rather than the per-session price, and check whether a package must be paid up front. A long lock-in is hard to leave if the fit turns out to be wrong, so learn the way out along with the price.
Can we do a single paid session before I commit to a package?
Why ask it
Their answer is informative regardless. Willingness suggests confidence in the work; a refusal on the grounds that coaching only works over months may be true but is also convenient.
Is there a written agreement, and can I read it before we speak again?
Why ask it
A contract protects you as much as the coach: it fixes the price, the number of sessions and what happens if either of you ends things early. Ask for it by email and read it somewhere quiet, not while they wait on the call.
What are the cancellation, rescheduling and refund terms?
Why ask it
Find out how much notice moves a session without losing it, and what comes back if you stop halfway through a package. Refund rights also vary with where you live and how you paid, so check how it works there before sending money.
Do unused sessions expire?
Why ask it
Packages often carry an end date, and sessions not taken by then are simply lost. If your work or family life is unpredictable, ask for a longer window or the right to pause before you agree.
How much contact is included between sessions, and how quickly do you reply?
Why ask it
Unlimited support can mean a voice note answered within the hour or an email answered on Thursday. Get the channel and the usual reply time, and ask whether it lasts the whole package or tails off after month one.
Is the price different if I decide today?
Why ask it
A discount that ends with the call is pressure, and several months of your money deserves a couple of days' thought. Ask whether the same price stands on Friday. How they take the question tells you a good deal.
What happens to my sessions if you are ill, away or stop coaching?
Why ask it
Many coaches work alone, with no colleague to step in. Ask whether missed sessions are rescheduled or refunded, and what the agreement says if the practice closes partway through a package you have paid for.
First sessions
What should I prepare before our first session?
Why ask it
Some coaches send a questionnaire, others want a page in your own words about what you want changed. Done properly, it means the first paid hour starts on the problem and not on your biography.
Now that you have heard more, what do you think we should tackle first?
Why ask it
For the first or second session, once a new coach knows more than the consultation call gave them. One starting point with a reason attached is the job being done. A long list handed back to you is not.
What have you noticed about me that I might not see?
Why ask it
By the second or third meeting a new coach has heard you describe the same situation several times. The pattern in how you tell it is often plainer to them than to you, so ask for that view early instead of waiting for it to be offered.
What happens if the thing I came for turns out not to be the real problem?
Why ask it
Goals move once the talking starts: someone arrives wanting a promotion and by the third session the subject is whether they want the job at all. Ask how a change of direction is handled, and whether a fixed programme or a paid package has room for it.
How do you want me to tell you when something is not landing?
Why ask it
Agree the route while everything is still friendly: a word at the end of a session, a message afterwards, a standing review. Feedback that has a slot gets given, and feedback that needs courage mostly does not.
Can we end each session by agreeing what I will do before the next one?
Why ask it
A session that finishes on a named action and a date is far easier to judge than one that finishes on a good feeling. Write it down in the last five minutes and open with it next time.
What is the most common way new clients waste their first few sessions?
Why ask it
They will have seen it often: turning up with nothing in mind, retelling the week, or saying what they imagine the coach wants to hear. Knowing the list in advance lets you skip the slow start.
When will we first review whether to carry on?
Why ask it
Put a date on it, around the fourth session or the end of the first month. A review you both expected is an ordinary conversation, while one you have to call out of the blue feels like a complaint.
Once we finish, can I book a single session if something comes up?
Why ask it
A one-off top-up months later is a common thing to want, and coaches differ: some keep a single-session rate for past clients, others only sell packages. Knowing the door stays open also makes it easier to finish on time.
Choosing a coach
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
Before you commit
Talk to three, not one
Almost any competent coach sounds impressive in isolation, because the consultation is designed to feel useful. Three conversations give you a basis for comparison on price, structure and how much they listen.
Write down what you want changed, in observable terms
Bring something you could point at in six months: a conversation you keep avoiding, a decision you have deferred twice, a working pattern you want to break. Vague aims are why coaching often ends without either side able to say whether it worked.
Read the contract before you pay
Check the notice period, the refund position and whether unused sessions expire. Reluctance to send terms in advance is the clearest single warning you will get.
Notice how the consultation is run
A coach who spends most of it asking you questions is showing you the product. One who spends it describing their method, or applying time pressure on a discounted package, is showing you something else.
Coaching, therapy and consulting
What coaching is suited to
Forward-looking work where you know roughly what you want and struggle to act: decisions, habits, difficult conversations, taking on a bigger role. It relies on you being well enough to act between sessions.
When you want a therapist instead
Persistent low mood, anxiety that interferes with daily life, trauma, disordered eating and substance problems are work for someone clinically trained, and a doctor or licensed therapist is the person to ask about them. A coach who readily agrees to take these on alone is a reason to stop.
When you actually want a consultant
If the gap is knowledge rather than action, someone who has done the specific thing will help more than a coach asking what you think. Coaching does not supply expertise it does not have.
The first sessions with a new coach
Bring one live situation each time
A real conversation you are dreading this week gives a coach more to work with than a general wish to be more confident. Pick it before the call and say it in the first two minutes.
Keep your own notes
Straight after each session, write down what you agreed to do and one thing that surprised you. A month in, those few lines are what you check against the measure you set under Results.
Ask the First sessions questions out loud
The last group in the list is meant for sessions one to four. Asking what they have noticed about you, or how to tell them something is not landing, feels forward that early, and a new coach who welcomes it will be easier to be honest with later.
Hold the review you agreed
When the date arrives, go through what you are doing differently, not how the sessions felt. Carrying on, changing the plan and stopping are all reasonable ways for that conversation to end.
Common mistakes
Buying a long package on the first call
A twelve-month commitment paid up front is hard to exit. A month or a few sessions is enough to learn whether the relationship works, and a coach confident in their work can usually live with that.
Confusing feeling understood with progress
Being listened to attentively for an hour is pleasant and can continue for a year without anything changing. Set a review point and check it against what you are actually doing differently.
Skipping the credentials because you liked them
Getting on well makes you likely to keep booking, which is not the same as being helped. Ask about training, supervision and boundaries even when the conversation is going well.
Not saying when it is not working
Coaches cannot correct what they do not know about, and most would rather hear it than lose you quietly. Raising it in a session is also a reasonable test of how they handle challenge.