Questions to Ask a Reader
Questions to ask a reader: a friend whose shelves you keep eyeing, a date, a book club, or your own readers if you write a newsletter, a blog or books. They open with what is on the nightstand now, then move through the reading life, quick this-or-that picks, favorites and opinions. The last group is for writers: questions to ask your blog readers or newsletter subscribers about what they remember, what they skip and what they are stuck on, which is where blog post ideas tend to come from.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
Openers
What are you reading right now?
Why ask it
The book in hand is far less curated than a favorite, and the answer often arrives with a confession attached: a reread, something for work, a novel stalled at page forty. If they are between books, ask what they are circling.
What is the best book you have read so far this year?
Why ask it
A year is short enough to search properly, so you get a real title instead of the one they have been naming since college. If nothing from this year comes to mind, ask about last year without making it sound like a mark against them.
What is your favorite book of all time?
Why ask it
Readers dread this one and answer it anyway, usually after protesting that it cannot be done. Let them name three if they need to. The book that survives every version of the list is the one to ask about.
Which genre do you reach for most?
Why ask it
What people reach for and what they say they admire are often different shelves. Follow up with the last title in that genre they loved, because 'fantasy' or 'crime' covers too much ground to tell you much alone.
What made you fall in love with reading?
Why ask it
Many readers can point to a person, a library card, or one book at nine or ten that did it. Some came to it as adults, through audiobooks or a long commute, and those stories are often the better ones.
What was the last book you finished, and would you recommend it?
Why ask it
Finished is a different list from started. The recommendation half forces a verdict, and a quick 'it was fine' usually means the book has already begun to fade.
What is next on your to-be-read pile?
Why ask it
Every reader has a queue, whether it lives on a nightstand, a library hold list, or a phone. What sits at the top shows where their attention is heading, and it hands you an easy reason to ask in a month how it went.
Who is your favorite author, and which of their books should someone start with?
Why ask it
The starting point is the half worth having. A reader who knows an author well will often steer you away from the famous one, and the reason they give shows what they love about the writing.
What is the last book you stayed up too late to finish?
Why ask it
It asks for a real night with a real cost the next morning, which is a better test of a gripping book than any review. If nothing comes to mind, try the last one that made them miss a stop or let dinner go cold.
Reading Life
Do you prefer paper, an e-reader, or audiobooks, or does it depend on the book?
Why ask it
Format loyalty is usually practical rather than principled: commutes, eyesight, shelf space, a partner who wants the light off. Anyone who insists audio does not count will say so here, which is worth knowing before you recommend one.
Where do you usually end up reading?
Why ask it
Expect a very particular answer: one end of the sofa, the bus, the bath, a parked car before going into the house. 'Wherever I can' is an answer too, and the follow-up is where they last managed an uninterrupted hour.
When in the day do you get most of your reading done?
Why ask it
Bedtime readers will admit, usually cheerfully, how many pages they lose to sleep. Lunch breaks and waiting rooms count as well, and someone reading in ten-minute snatches will thank you for a book with short chapters.
Do you read one book at a time, or do you have several going?
Why ask it
With several on the go there is usually a system, such as a novel for bed, something factual for daytime and an audiobook for the car. Find out which one is winning. A strict one-at-a-time reader is the person to ask before you lend anything long.
How do you decide what to read next?
Why ask it
Listen for the actual source: one friend, a podcast, the library display, an app's suggestions, pure mood. If one trusted person keeps coming up, ask what that person got right most recently.
Do you push through a book you are not enjoying, or put it down?
Why ask it
Plenty of readers have a rule of their own, such as fifty pages or the end of the third chapter. The better follow-up is the last book they abandoned and what did it: slow pacing and a narrator they could not stand are very different complaints.
Roughly how many books do you get through in a month?
Why ask it
Ask out of curiosity, never as a scoreboard. One long history and eight short thrillers are both a good month, and a reader who sounds apologetic about their number has probably been made to feel slow by somebody.
Do you buy most of your books, borrow them, or a bit of both?
Why ask it
Most people are a mix, with firm ideas about which books earn a place on the shelf: borrowed first and bought only if loved, or bought secondhand and passed on. With a library user, the length of the hold list is a story in itself.
How do you organize your bookshelves?
Why ask it
By author, by color, by size, by read and unread, or in piles on the floor with a logic only the owner can follow. People defend their system with surprising heat, so ask what happens when a new book has no obvious place.
When you walk into a bookstore or library with no plan, where do you go first?
Why ask it
The answer is concrete: the new releases table, staff picks, one shelf at the back, the secondhand cart by the door. It leads naturally to the last thing they walked out with that they had never heard of an hour before.
Do you keep track of what you read anywhere?
Why ask it
An app, a notebook, a spreadsheet with star ratings, or nothing at all. If they do keep a record, ask what it has shown them that they did not expect, like a year with almost no fiction in it.
Do you set yourself a reading goal for the year?
Why ask it
Many people set a number once, found it turned reading into homework, and quietly dropped it. For those who kept one, the thing to find out is whether it ever changed what they chose, such as reaching for slim books in December.
What gets you out of a reading slump?
Why ask it
Nearly every reader has stretches when nothing holds, and most have a private cure: an old favorite, a short thriller, a different format, a week off. Collect these, since you will want one yourself sooner or later.
Do you write in your books, or keep them clean?
Why ask it
A real dividing line. Margin writers treat a book as a conversation and clean-copy people treat it as an object, and each finds the other faintly alarming. Check before you lend either of them anything.
Are you in a book club, or have you ever been in one?
Why ask it
Former members usually have a story about why it ended, and it is rarely about the books. Current members can name the pick that split the room, which makes a better recommendation than one everybody politely liked.
Who do you talk about books with?
Why ask it
Some readers have a sister, a group chat or a colleague they trade titles with, and some read entirely alone with nobody to tell. If it is the second, you have just volunteered, so be ready to listen.
What would be missing from your life if you stopped reading?
Why ask it
A more answerable way of asking why they read. Quiet, company, escape, somewhere to think that is not a screen: whatever they name is what reading is for in their life, and it explains their shelves better than a list of titles would.
This or That
Fiction or nonfiction, if you could read only one for a year?
Why ask it
The one-year limit stops the answer from being both. Listen to what they say they would miss from the other shelf, because that is usually the part they talk about longest.
Hardback or paperback?
Why ask it
Hardbacks look good and hurt your wrists in bed. Paperbacks travel and crack. Add the price and the wait for the cheaper edition, and most readers turn out to hold a firm position they have never said out loud.
Bookmark, dog-ear, or whatever scrap of paper is nearest?
Why ask it
Put this to a room of readers and an argument starts within a minute, which is why it suits the start of a club meeting or a post to your own readers. Receipts, train tickets and other books all turn up as answers.
Series or standalone?
Why ask it
A commitment question in disguise. Series readers like going back to people they already know, and standalone readers want the whole thing settled by the last page. It also tells you whether lending them book one is a kindness or a trap.
One long book you can live in, or three short ones?
Why ask it
Page count is one of the first things many readers check and one of the last they admit to caring about. The answer often moves with the season, long on holiday and short when life is busy, so ask what they would pick this month.
Cliffhanger or everything tied up?
Why ask it
A loose thread feels like a cheat to some readers, and a neat bow feels like being talked down to by others. Whichever they choose, ask for one book that got the balance right, and keep the details vague if one of you has not read it.
Book first or screen first?
Why ask it
Purists read before they watch and will tell you so. Arriving through a film or a series and going back for the book afterwards has led plenty of people to something they would never have picked up cold, so ask which adaptation sent them to the shelf.
Peek at the last page, or never?
Why ask it
People who peek tend to confess it in a lowered voice, and they often have a reason, such as checking that a favorite character survives. It is also a polite way to learn how they feel about spoilers before you say too much about a book.
Brand-new release, or a book that has been out for years?
Why ask it
Reading a book the week it comes out means joining the conversation while it is loud. Waiting means the fuss has settled and the paperback is cheaper. If they wait, find out how many years behind their pile is running.
Silence, music, or a noisy cafe?
Why ask it
Lyrics are the usual breaking point: many people can read through an instrumental or a train carriage but not through a song with words. Readers who can tune out anything usually have a story about where they learned to.
Tea, coffee, or something to snack on while you read?
Why ask it
Small, friendly and answerable by anyone, which makes it a good one for a quiet table or a slow day on a book account. The details people add are the fun part: the specific mug, the rule about crumbs.
Favorites
What is your comfort read, the book you go back to when you need something familiar?
Why ask it
A comfort read is seldom the book someone would call their best. It is one where they know how it ends and want the company anyway. Ask how many times they have been through it, and whether it is always the same worn copy.
Who is your favorite character in any book?
Why ask it
People choose characters they would want as company or characters they recognize themselves in, and it is worth asking which this one is. If they name a side character over the lead, ask what the book would have been like told from that seat.
Which villain did you enjoy more than the hero?
Why ask it
A well-written villain gets the best lines and a logic of their own, and readers remember them long after they forget who won. For someone who cannot enjoy a villain at all, the one they hated most works just as well.
If you could spend a week inside one book's world, which would you choose?
Why ask it
The week is the safeguard, since plenty of beloved fictional worlds would be miserable to live in for good. Notice whether they pick somewhere cozy or somewhere dangerous, and ask what they would do on the first morning.
Which series have you been most hooked on?
Why ask it
Series loyalty is its own kind of reading: years of waiting, release-day queues, arguments about the final book. Ask whether the ending paid off, because that is where the strong feelings are.
What book from childhood do you still think about?
Why ask it
Answers here are unguarded, since nobody performs taste with a book they read at eight. The detail they remember, an illustration, a smell, one scene, is often sharper than anything they can recall from last year.
What book has actually made you laugh out loud?
Why ask it
Funny on the page is rare and highly specific, so expect a short list of titles and not a genre. Where they were at the time is worth hearing, because laughing alone on a train is a story of its own.
Has a book ever made you cry, and what got you?
Why ask it
Ask for the moment rather than the title. It is usually something small, a minor character, a last line, rather than the tragedy the book was built around, and that detail shows what they are alert to.
Which book do you wish you could read again for the first time?
Why ask it
This names a book whose surprise mattered, usually a twist or a slow reveal they cannot have back. It is one of the more reliable recommendations you will get, so write the title down and stop them before they explain why.
What book do you keep pressing on people?
Why ask it
Almost everyone has one, and they often own spare copies. Ask who they give it to as well, since the pairing shows how they think about matching a book to a particular person.
What is a book you wish more people knew about?
Why ask it
Expect something small: out of print, translated, from a tiny press, or simply never fashionable. How they came across it is half the answer, because books like this tend to travel from one reader's hand to the next.
If you had to keep only five books, which ones survive?
Why ask it
A small number produces a truer list than favorites, because sentiment, rereading, and physical objects all compete for the slots. Expect at least one choice they feel slightly sheepish about.
Is there a line from a book you know by heart?
Why ask it
Plenty of devoted readers have none and are no worse for it, so keep it light. When someone does have one, ask when it comes to mind. A line people carry around is usually attached to a particular kind of day.
If you could talk to one author for an hour, who would it be and what would you ask?
Why ask it
Let them pick anyone, living or dead. Their question is where the fun is: some want to know how a particular scene was written, and some only want to hear what happens to a character after the last page.
Which book changed your mind about something?
Why ask it
Ask what they thought before and what they think now. A book that 'opened my eyes' with no before and after has usually confirmed something the reader already believed, which is a pleasure too, only a different one.
Has a book ever reached you at exactly the right moment?
Why ask it
Timing does much of the work in reading. The same novel can pass unnoticed one year and feel written for you the next. Expect an answer tied to a move, a breakup or a first job, and give it room.
Opinions
What is a book everyone raves about that did not work for you?
Why ask it
Gives permission to dissent, which readers enjoy and are rarely offered. Notice whether they criticize the book or the people who liked it, because the second tells you about them rather than about the book.
What is an adaptation you thought did the book justice?
Why ask it
Splits readers who want fidelity from readers who want a good film. Their reasoning reveals what they think a book actually is: the plot, the voice, or the experience of reading it.
Is there a genre you avoid but suspect you might be wrong about?
Why ask it
Most people have a shelf they walk past, often because of one bad book years ago. The suspicion is your opening: if they think they may be wrong, a single well-chosen title from you might actually get read.
Is there a genre you used to love and have drifted away from?
Why ask it
This is where reading history shows: the fantasy years, thrillers during a hard stretch, poetry that stopped after a class. Find out what took its place, and whether they ever go back for a visit.
What is the hardest book you have finished, and was it worth it?
Why ask it
The second half is the useful part, because the honest answer is sometimes no. Readers who admit that tend to be more trustworthy about recommendations than those for whom every difficult book was a triumph.
What is the book you keep meaning to read and never start?
Why ask it
Nearly everyone has one, often bought with good intentions and carried from one home to the next. What is stopping them is the interesting part: the length, the reputation, or a first attempt that died around page thirty.
Is there a book you let people assume you have read?
Why ask it
Usually a classic, and usually one they know well enough from films and school to nod along about. Offer yours first and it becomes a trade of confessions instead of a test.
Have you ever bought a book purely for its cover?
Why ask it
Most readers have, and the honest ones will tell you how it turned out. It leads easily to which edition of a favorite they own, and whether a film tie-in cover is a dealbreaker.
Which trope will you pick up every time, and which one makes you put a book down?
Why ask it
Found family, enemies to lovers, the unreliable narrator, the chosen one: readers know their weaknesses precisely. The trope they refuse is often the better half, since it tends to come with one specific book that ruined it for them.
Do you need to like the main character to enjoy a book?
Why ask it
Readers split cleanly here. Those who say yes want someone to root for, and those who say no are usually reading for voice or ideas. Knowing the side they are on saves you from recommending a brilliant book about someone unbearable.
Which ending are you still annoyed about?
Why ask it
Grudges against endings last for decades and people enjoy airing them. Make sure nobody within earshot is halfway through the book, then ask how they would have ended it.
What matters more to you, the writing or the story?
Why ask it
Almost everyone says both and then shows a lean within a sentence or two. A prose reader forgives a thin plot, a story reader forgives clumsy sentences, and each has trouble recommending to the other.
Which classic lived up to its reputation for you, and which did not?
Why ask it
School assigns classics before most people are ready for them, so a lot of these opinions are really memories of a classroom. Someone who went back as an adult and changed their verdict has the more interesting answer.
What did you read as a teenager that you would still defend?
Why ask it
Teenage reading is formative and slightly embarrassing, which makes it good conversation. Let them make the full case before you offer yours, and do not be surprised if they still own the copy.
Is there a book you loved once that did not hold up when you went back to it?
Why ask it
The pages are the same, so whatever changed is the reader, and most people can say exactly what they could no longer overlook. Some refuse to reread an old favorite for fear of this, and that is a good answer as well.
Is there a book you read too young, or too late?
Why ask it
Too young usually means it frightened them or went over their head, and some went back years later to find a different book waiting. Too late is the wistful one: a book they can tell would have mattered more at sixteen.
What would you hand someone who says they do not really read?
Why ask it
It takes real thought about length, pace and the point where a reluctant reader gives up. The best answers begin with a question back: who is this person, and what do they like to watch?
Your Readers
How did you first find my writing?
Why ask it
For anyone with readers of their own: a newsletter, a blog, a book account, books. The answers rarely match what you assumed, such as a friend forwarding one piece or a search for something unrelated. Whatever comes up most is where new readers are arriving from.
Which piece or book of mine do you remember best?
Why ask it
What readers remember is often not the thing you were proudest of. Ask what they remember about it, because a single image or line that stuck is more use to you than 'I liked it'.
Have you ever passed something of mine on to someone, and what was it?
Why ask it
A forwarded post or a lent copy is about the strongest compliment a reader pays, and people remember which piece they sent and to whom. That piece is a sensible first thing to show somebody new.
Is there anything I write that you usually skip?
Why ask it
Hard to ask and worth it. Make it easy to answer honestly by naming a candidate yourself, such as the long introductions or the links at the end, and thank whoever tells you.
When and where do you usually read what I send?
Why ask it
A reader on a phone in a queue and a reader with coffee on a Sunday morning want different lengths. If most replies describe snatched minutes, that is an argument for shorter pieces, or for putting the one thing that matters at the top.
Who else do you read that I should know about?
Why ask it
Readers like recommending, and the names show the company your work keeps in their heads. If the same two or three keep appearing, go and read them, because that is the shelf you are on.
What would you like me to write about next?
Why ask it
The staple, and it works better with two or three options attached, since an open field often gets silence. Treat the replies as a show of interest and not as a promise you have made.
What is one question you wish I would answer?
Why ask it
A question is easier to send than a critique, so this draws replies from readers who would never write in otherwise. Any question that arrives more than once is a piece waiting to be written.
What are you stuck on at the moment that I might be able to help with?
Why ask it
This is how to ask your readers for blog post ideas without using those words. People describe a problem far more readily than they suggest a topic, and each description is a post with its headline half written.
What did you last look up on this subject without finding a decent answer?
Why ask it
A gap somebody else left is the easiest post to justify writing. Ask for the words they typed into the search box, since those are closer to a working title than anything you would come up with at your desk.
What do you wish someone had told you when you were starting out?
Why ask it
Long-time readers answer with the mistake that cost them most, which makes this a ready source of beginner posts. Put it to a blog's regulars when new people are arriving and the replies double as a welcome.
Which post of mine deserves a part two?
Why ask it
Readers notice where you stopped short, often at the exact point their own situation got complicated. Have them say what the sequel should cover, or all you will get back is a title.
Is there anything I explained that still does not make sense to you?
Why ask it
Nobody enjoys admitting confusion in a comment thread, so offer a private way to reply, such as email or a form. When two people are lost in the same paragraph the fault is usually in the paragraph, and the repair can be a post of its own.
Have you tried anything I wrote about, and how did it go?
Why ask it
Results from readers are material you cannot produce alone: the recipe that failed in a smaller oven, the routine that lasted four days. Get permission before quoting anyone, and you have a roundup post built from other people's experience.
Where do you think I have got something wrong?
Why ask it
Invite the disagreement before it turns up in the comments unasked. A reader who objects in detail has handed you either a correction to make or a reply post to write, and the rest of the audience sees that you listen.
What would you like me to try so that you do not have to?
Why ask it
Readers are curious about plenty of things they will never spend their own money or weekend on. An experiment post has an ending built in, since you report back on whether it worked, and the person who suggested it will be watching for it.
Do you want more how-to posts, more personal stories, or more lists of recommendations?
Why ask it
Format is as much a decision as topic, and readers find it easier to choose from three than to describe what they like. Name only the kinds you actually publish, then compare the replies with what people open.
Which of my characters would you like to see more of?
Why ask it
One for fiction and serials. Readers often attach to a side character the author thought of as furniture, and their reasons say what the story is doing for them. Only people who have finished can answer, so label it for spoilers.
Would you rather hear from me more often, or less?
Why ask it
Ask only if you are prepared to act on the answer. Bear in mind that the people who reply are the keen ones, so 'more' from them is not the whole audience speaking.
Talking About Books Without Running Dry
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
Keeping the conversation moving
Ask about the latest book before the best one
Favorites are rehearsed answers that people have given before. What someone read most recently is unpolished and leads straight to the reasons behind it: a recommendation, a slump, a long flight.
Follow the reason, not the title
A title you have not read is a dead end. Ask what the book did, whether that was the pacing, the narrator, the ending, and the conversation keeps going even between two people with no overlap in what they read.
Admit what you have not read
Bluffing collapses within two questions and readers can hear it. Saying you have not read something invites a summary, which is usually the part the other person most enjoys giving.
Give the abandoned pile equal time
What someone put down at page fifty, and why, is often a better story than what they finished. It is also a rarer question, so it tends to get a fresh answer and not a stock one.
Asking a group, or your own readers
Match the section to the room
Openers and This or That suit a table of people or a comment thread, because anyone can answer in a line and nobody needs to have read the same book. Reading Life, Favorites and Opinions want more time, and the ones about childhood or a book that arrived at the right moment are best kept for one person and an unhurried hour.
If you write for an audience
The Your Readers group is worded for a writer to ask directly, so change 'my writing' to whatever you make: a newsletter, a blog, a book account, a series. The other groups work on an audience too, since readers of nearly anything like being asked what is on their nightstand.
Asking your readers for blog post ideas
The run in Your Readers that starts with what to write next is there to fill a list of posts. Keep each reply in the reader's exact wording, because the way one person phrases a problem is often how the next will type it into a search box. One reply is an anecdote, and the same problem from three people is a post.
One question at a time
If you are putting these to readers of your blog, newsletter or book account, post a single question and answer it yourself first. A question with your own answer attached reads as an invitation. A bare list of five reads as a survey, and people scroll past surveys.
In a book club, go around once
Give each person the same question before anyone responds to anyone else. The quiet members get a turn without having to fight for it, and the answers stay honest because nobody has heard the confident person's view yet.
Read the replies and answer them
A reader who names a book and hears nothing back will not name another. A short follow-up, such as what made them pick it up, does more to keep people answering next time than a cleverer question would.
When an answer needs a follow-up
- 'I do not have time to read' is rarely the end of it. Ask what they read last, however long ago, or what they listen to, and go from there.
- If the answer is a title you have never heard of, say so and ask for the one-sentence pitch.
- If they answer with an audiobook, treat it as a book. Asking who narrated it is a better follow-up than debating whether listening counts.
- If someone cannot choose a favorite, narrow it: the favorite this year, the favorite in one genre, the one they have given away most.
- When an answer comes with an apology, such as 'it is only a romance' or 'I know it is a children's book', skip the reassurance and ask what they love about it.
What ends a book conversation early
Testing them
Quizzing someone on whether they have read a canonical author turns a conversation into an exam. Readers who feel graded stop volunteering anything, and you learn nothing further.
Spoiling
Assume they have not finished it. Ask where they are in the book before saying anything at all about how it goes, including whether the ending is good.
Ranking their taste
Calling anything a guilty pleasure, even your own reading, invites them to hide half of what they read. Most people's reading is a mix, and the mix is the interesting part.
Handing over recommendations too fast
A list offered before you know how they read is how books go unread. Establish length, pace, and what they last abandoned, then suggest one book and not five.