20 Questions

Questions to Ask About College Admissions

Strategic questions that help you understand the college admissions process, requirements, and how to strengthen your application.

1

What are the most important factors in your admissions decisions?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Reveals their evaluation criteria and helps you understand what they prioritize, allowing you to focus your application efforts effectively.

2

How do you evaluate extracurricular activities versus academic performance?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Shows the balance between different application components and helps you understand how to present your activities strategically.

3

What's the most common mistake students make in their applications?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Helps you avoid common pitfalls and shows what admissions officers see repeatedly that hurts applications.

4

How do you handle students with unique circumstances or challenges?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Reveals their approach to holistic review and shows how they consider context beyond just numbers and achievements.

5

What makes an essay stand out to you?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Gives insight into what they value in personal statements and helps you craft more compelling essays.

6

How important are standardized test scores in your process?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Shows the weight given to test scores and helps you understand if your scores are a strength or area for improvement.

7

What role do letters of recommendation play in your decisions?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Reveals how they use recommendations and helps you choose the right people to write your letters.

8

How do you evaluate students from different high schools or backgrounds?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Shows their approach to contextual evaluation and helps you understand how they consider your specific circumstances.

9

What's the most impressive thing you've seen in an application?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Reveals what stands out positively and gives you ideas for how to make your application memorable.

10

How do you handle students who have changed their academic focus?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Shows their approach to students with evolving interests and helps you present your academic journey effectively.

11

What advice would you give to someone applying next year?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Provides strategic guidance and shows what they wish more applicants knew about the process.

12

How do you evaluate leadership experience?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Reveals what they consider leadership and helps you present your leadership roles more effectively.

13

What's the biggest misconception about your admissions process?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Clarifies common misunderstandings and helps you avoid making assumptions that could hurt your application.

14

How do you handle students with gaps in their academic record?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Shows their approach to non-traditional academic paths and helps you address any concerns proactively.

15

What role does demonstrated interest play in your decisions?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Reveals how much they value engagement with the school and helps you show appropriate interest.

16

How do you evaluate students who are undecided about their major?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Shows their approach to undeclared students and helps you present your exploration of interests positively.

17

What's the most challenging part of your job as an admissions officer?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Reveals the human side of admissions and helps you understand the complexity of their decision-making process.

18

How do you handle students with strong academics but weak extracurriculars?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Shows how they balance different application strengths and helps you understand what to emphasize.

19

What trends are you seeing in applications this year?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Provides current context and helps you understand the competitive landscape you're entering.

20

How do you ensure fairness in your admissions process?

Click to see why this works

Why this works

Shows their commitment to equitable evaluation and helps you understand their approach to diversity and inclusion.

Best Practices for College Admissions Conversations

Expert tips and techniques for getting the most out of these questions.

Best Practices

Be Genuine and Authentic

Admissions officers can spot insincerity. Ask questions that show genuine interest in their process and your own educational goals.

Focus on Understanding, Not Impressing

Use questions to learn about their process rather than trying to showcase your knowledge. They want to help you succeed.

Ask About Specifics

General questions get general answers. Ask about specific aspects of their process, requirements, or evaluation criteria.

Question Sequences

The Application Strategy Sequence

1
What are the most important factors in your admissions decisions?
2
How do you evaluate extracurricular activities versus academic performance?
3
What's the most common mistake students make in their applications?
4
What advice would you give to someone applying next year?

The Holistic Review Sequence

1
How do you handle students with unique circumstances?
2
How do you evaluate students from different backgrounds?
3
What role do letters of recommendation play?
4
How do you ensure fairness in your process?

Common Pitfalls

Don't Ask About Your Chances

Avoid questions like 'Do I have a good chance of getting in?' Focus on understanding the process instead.

Don't Compare Yourself to Others

Avoid questions that pit you against other applicants. Focus on understanding their evaluation criteria instead.

Don't Ask for Special Treatment

Don't ask questions that suggest you want preferential treatment. Focus on understanding their standard process.

Conversation Templates

The Process Understanding Template

1
Step 1: Start with: "What are the most important factors in your admissions decisions?"
2
Step 2: Follow with: "How do you evaluate [specific component]?"
3
Step 3: Deepen with: "What's the most common mistake students make?"
4
Step 4: Learn with: "What advice would you give to future applicants?"

The Holistic Review Template

1
Step 1: Begin with: "How do you handle students with unique circumstances?"
2
Step 2: Explore with: "What role does [specific factor] play in your decisions?"
3
Step 3: Understand with: "How do you ensure fairness in your process?"
4
Step 4: Connect with: "What trends are you seeing in applications?"

Further Reading

"The Gatekeepers" by Jacques Steinberg
"Where You Go Is Not Who You'll Be" by Frank Bruni
"The Price of Admission" by Daniel Golden
"Excellent Sheep" by William Deresiewicz

Find Your Perfect Questions

Search our collection of thoughtful questions for any conversation or situation