Skip to content
Question Vault?
Free to readNo accountNo email wallNo invented statisticsNo partial listsCopy or print any set and take it with you

Questions to Ask a Youth Group

Questions to ask a youth group, written for whoever leads a church teen group or small group. The list opens with fun icebreaker questions any youth group can answer in its first ten minutes and moves through everyday life. Then come the questions to ask youth about faith and doubt, about church itself, and about friends and family, with a last group for wrapping up the night.

63 questions

Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.

The questions

Each question, and why to ask it

Icebreakers

What was the best part of your week, and the worst?

Why ask it

Giving both halves is what makes this work: a teenager who would never volunteer a problem will mention one when it is simply the second item. Keep your own answer short, because a long leader answer sets the length for everyone after you.

Would you rather lose your phone for a month or your bed for a month?

Why ask it

A would-you-rather with no right answer gets the whole room to pick a side in ten seconds, including the ones who never speak. Have them walk to opposite walls to vote, then give each side a minute to argue its case.

What's something you're good at that nobody here knows about?

Why ask it

Useful in a group where the same three confident people talk. Quieter members often have something specific, a game, an instrument, a job, a sibling they look after, and it can change how the rest of the group sees them.

If you could skip one thing coming up this week, what would it be?

Why ask it

Easier than asking what is worrying them, and it surfaces the same information: a test, a game, a visit, a conversation at home. Anyone who names something they cannot get out of has just told you what to check in about next week.

What's big at your school right now that most adults haven't heard of?

Why ask it

Reverses the usual direction and makes them the ones who know something. You also learn what is actually going around, a game, a rumor, a trend, a teacher who left, which is often not what the parents are worried about. Resist the urge to comment on whatever they name.

Would you rather give the talk at youth group next week or lead the singing?

Why ask it

Both options horrify most of the room, and that is the fun of it. Watch for anyone who picks one without flinching: that person might say yes if you asked them to read, pray or play one week, and would never have volunteered.

If this youth group had a mascot, what animal would it be?

Why ask it

Silly on purpose, and the reasons are the fun part: a sloth for the late starts, a golden retriever for how new people get greeted. Put the top two to a vote. You will also hear, sideways, how they see the group.

Which movie title best describes your week?

Why ask it

A one-line answer that needs no explanation, so it goes round a big circle in two minutes. Laugh first, then remember who said a disaster film. That title is a check-in the person chose to give you as a joke.

If you could have one meal with anyone who has ever lived, who would you choose?

Why ask it

The name alone tells you little, so ask what they would want to ask that person over the meal. Somebody will say Jesus because it sounds like the right answer in this building; put the same follow-up to them and it often turns into a real one.

What's the best thing anyone at your house cooks?

Why ask it

Food is safe ground for a nervous newcomer, and the answers arrive with a person attached: a dad's barbecue, a grandmother's dumplings. Write a few down, because they hand you the easiest shared-meal night you will ever plan.

What song, show or game would you defend against anyone in this room?

Why ask it

Inviting an argument about taste wakes a sleepy group faster than asking for a favorite. Let the disagreement run for a while, since teasing over a band is how plenty of teenagers show they like each other, and step in only if it settles on one person.

What's a rule at your house that your friends think is strange?

Why ask it

Phone curfews, shoes off at the door, no sleepovers, church twice on a Sunday. It gets a laugh and quietly shows how different their homes are, which is worth knowing before you ask anything about family. Do not rule on whether a rule is fair.

If you had a whole Saturday with no phone and no homework, what would you do?

Why ask it

The no-phone condition is what makes it interesting: some will plan a full day outdoors and some will be honestly stuck. Anyone who says fishing, baking or football has just volunteered an idea for the group's next social.

Which would you pick: flying, being invisible, or reading minds?

Why ask it

Three fixed options work better than an open superpower question, where the first answer gets copied around the circle. Ask the mind readers whose mind they would read first. That answer is usually about a parent, a friend or a crush, and says more than the choice did.

What's the strangest thing in your bag or your pockets right now?

Why ask it

Show and tell with no preparation. A lucky coin, a week-old receipt, somebody else's hair tie: objects come with stories attached. Make it clear that nobody has to empty anything out, since a bag can hold something private.

If this group had to enter a talent show next month, what would our act be?

Why ask it

Planning an act that will never happen has them casting each other: who sings, who does the backflip, who holds the sign. Listen to who gets given which part, because it is a quick map of what they admire in one another.

What's the funniest thing you've seen happen in church when everyone was supposed to be serious?

Why ask it

A microphone left on, a toddler loose during the prayer, a hymn started in the wrong key. Laughing about church inside the church tells them they do not have to be on best behavior with you. Keep it kind if a story is about someone the group knows.

What do the adults at this church assume about teenagers that isn't true?

Why ask it

You will hear about phones, short attention spans, and being called the future of the church when they are sitting in it now. Take it without defending the adults: how you receive this answer decides whether anyone risks something more personal later in the evening.

Everyday Life

Where do you go when you need to be by yourself?

Why ask it

A concrete answer, a bedroom, a bus, a bathroom at school, a walk. It tells you how much privacy someone has, which varies enormously between households. Somebody who says there is nowhere is telling you something worth noticing quietly.

How late were you up last night, and what kept you up?

Why ask it

Everyone can answer with a time, so nobody is stuck. What kept them up covers phones, homework, noise at home and worry, and now and then something heavier that a direct question would not have reached. Treat it as ordinary conversation in the room and save any concern for a quiet word later.

What's the kindest thing someone did for you that they've probably forgotten?

Why ask it

This produces small specific stories rather than platitudes: a ride, a seat saved, a teacher who noticed. It also lands better than asking them to describe kindness in general, which reliably produces the answer they think you want.

What part of school is hardest right now: the work, the people, or thinking about what comes after?

Why ask it

Someone can say 'the people' here without having to raise it cold, because it is only one item on a menu. Work and the future mostly want encouragement. A people answer wants a quiet word afterwards about whether it is a falling-out or something closer to bullying.

How different are you online from how you are in this room?

Why ask it

Most will say a bit funnier, a bit braver, or a lot quieter. Ask which version they like better and not which one is real, since the second question sounds like the start of a lecture about phones, and they have heard that lecture.

Who do you look up to that you actually know in person?

Why ask it

Limiting it to people they know rules out celebrities and turns them toward a coach, an aunt, an older cousin. Ask what that person does, specifically. If someone cannot name a single adult, that is a gap your volunteers can do something about.

What do you like about yourself that has nothing to do with looks or grades?

Why ask it

Expect a long pause and some jokes, because many teenagers have never been asked. If someone is stuck, let the group answer for them; hearing three people their own age name something good can be the part of the evening they remember longest.

What's something you worry about that people would be surprised by?

Why ask it

The word 'surprised' gives permission to name a worry that does not fit their image: the loud one who frets about money at home, the top student afraid of failing. Thank them and move on without trying to fix it while everyone is watching.

Faith

Who taught you what you believe: one person, or a lot of small things?

Why ask it

Lets someone describe inherited faith honestly without having to defend it. Answers naming a grandparent, a camp, or a single conversation are common. Anyone who says they are not sure they believe it has been given a safe way to say so.

What did you believe about God when you were little that you see differently now?

Why ask it

The answers start out funny: God as an old man on a cloud, heaven somewhere above the planes. Laughing at the six-year-old version makes it normal for belief to change shape as a person grows, which is a relief to anyone who has read their newer questions as a sign that faith is slipping.

What's something people at church say that you don't understand, or don't buy?

Why ask it

Permission to be skeptical, framed as a question about language rather than loyalty. If the group is silent, offer one of your own first. The list you get back is a ready-made plan for what to teach over the next few months.

What's a question about God you've never asked out loud in here?

Why ask it

Expect suffering, hell, prayers that were not answered, and friends of other faiths or none. Answer only what you can answer, and say plainly when you do not know. A confident bad answer here can cost you months of honesty.

What does praying actually look like for you, if you pray at all?

Why ask it

The last five words matter, because some of the group only pray when an adult asks them to and need room to say so. You will hear about prayers in bed, before exams, and in a panic. All of those count, and telling them so helps more than a talk on technique.

Is there a Bible story you've always liked, or one that bothers you?

Why ask it

The 'bothers you' half makes the better conversation: the flood, Abraham and Isaac, Job, people punished for what looks like very little. You do not have to resolve it tonight. Offering to read the passage together next week treats the objection as serious, which it is.

When have you felt closest to God, and when has God felt far away?

Why ask it

Camps, worship nights and funerals come up on the close side; ordinary weeks and unanswered prayers on the far side. Give the second half as much time as the first, or the ones who have only known the distance will decide that they are the problem.

What's awkward about being known as someone who goes to church?

Why ask it

For some it is nothing, and for others it means being the one friends stop swearing around or stop inviting. Ask what they do in that moment, and hold back the pep talk about boldness. They need to feel understood before they need a strategy.

If a friend asked why you come here, what would you honestly say?

Why ask it

Honest answers include 'my parents make me', 'my friends are here' and 'the snacks', and each of those is a fine place to start from. In a group that can say this aloud, an answer about faith will be a real one when it comes.

How would you explain who Jesus is to a friend who has never been to church?

Why ask it

Most reach for phrases they have heard from the front and stall when you ask what those words mean. The stall is useful and nothing to be embarrassed about: it shows which words the group repeats without owning. Let two or three people try, then build one plain-language answer together.

What do you think God thinks when he looks at you?

Why ask it

Listen for 'disappointed', which can come even from teenagers who could recite that they are loved. Do not correct it on the spot. Ask where that picture came from, and let what you teach over the following weeks do the answering.

Church

What's your earliest memory of being in a church?

Why ask it

This asks for a story before it asks for an opinion: a scratchy collar, a crying room, a grandmother's usual seat. Whoever first walked in last year has an answer too, and theirs shows the lifelong members what the building looks like to fresh eyes.

Which part of a Sunday service do you get the most from, and which part do you just sit through?

Why ask it

Naming both parts lets them be honest without sounding as if they dislike the whole thing. Hold back the explanation of why the service runs the way it does. Ask what goes through their heads during the part they sit through, which is usually the more revealing answer.

What job at this church could someone your age do as well as an adult?

Why ask it

Sound desk, welcoming at the door, reading, helping with the little ones, running the social accounts. Many of these answers are offers in disguise. Take one to whoever leads that team within the week, because an offer nobody follows up is hard to make twice.

Apart from the people in this room, who at church knows your name?

Why ask it

Take it as a fast round so that a short list does not hang in the air. A short list says nothing bad about the teenager who gives it; it tells you which adults to introduce on purpose, starting this Sunday.

What do your friends who don't go to church think happens in here?

Why ask it

The guesses are usually funny: chanting, hours of sitting still, a long list of rules. Underneath them is what your group feels it would have to explain before inviting anyone. Ask which guess is closest to the truth and let them argue about it.

Have you ever been to a church or place of worship very different from this one, and what stood out?

Why ask it

Weddings, funerals, a friend's congregation and school trips all count. Seeing another way of doing things helps them notice that their own church's habits are choices somebody made. Stop any mocking of other traditions early, and stay curious yourself.

When you picture yourself at twenty-five, is church part of the picture?

Why ask it

Ask it without a hopeful face. A shrug or a no is information and not a verdict on your work, and you will not change it by arguing tonight. The follow-up worth asking is what a church would need to be like for them to choose it once nobody is driving them there.

Friends and Family

What's the hardest part of being honest with your parents?

Why ask it

Note that this asks about the difficulty, not the secrets. Common answers involve disappointing them, being overreacted to, or not wanting to add worry. Do not follow up by asking what they are hiding; that ends the conversation for everyone listening.

When you're stressed, who do you tell first, and who do you never tell?

Why ask it

The second half is where the information is. Someone whose answer is nobody is worth a private word later, and a group that hears the question asked plainly learns that having such a person is normal rather than weak.

When have you gone along with something you didn't agree with?

Why ask it

Better than asking about peer pressure, which invites the rehearsed answer about saying no. Real answers involve laughing at something, staying quiet, or not defending someone. Share your own example, ideally a recent adult one.

If a friend told you something that scared you and made you promise to keep it secret, what would you do?

Why ask it

Keeping the promise is the loyal answer at fifteen, and it is the one you will mostly get. Use it to say that some secrets are too heavy for one friend to carry, to ask which adult they would go to, and to explain what you yourself would have to pass on, before anyone tests that with something serious.

What does a good friend do that an okay friend doesn't?

Why ask it

Comparing two kinds of friend gets past the stock list of loyal, kind and funny. You will hear specifics such as 'tells me when I'm being annoying' or 'doesn't screenshot'. Then ask, lightly, which of those things they find hardest to do themselves.

Where do you feel the most pressure to be someone you're not?

Why ask it

School, a team, home and online are the usual four, and now and then someone says this group. If church makes the list, thank them and ask what would make it easier to show up as themselves. Getting defensive will only confirm the point.

What do you do when you see someone being left out?

Why ask it

Phrase it as what they do, not what they should do, or you will get the poster answer. Many will admit they notice and stay put. That honesty is more useful than a promise to be brave, and it leads naturally to who gets left out of this room.

When a friendship goes wrong, do you talk it out, wait it out, or walk away?

Why ask it

Nearly everyone has a default, and naming it is half of changing it. The ones who walk away often think of it as keeping the peace. A good follow-up is whether there is a friend they miss because of how one argument was left.

What makes it hard to forgive someone, even when you want to?

Why ask it

Keep it general and never ask who. In a church setting forgiveness is easily heard as an order to act as if nothing happened, so say clearly that forgiving a person and staying close to them are separate things, above all where that person is not safe to be around.

Wrapping Up

What's one small thing you were thankful for this week?

Why ask it

'Small' is doing the work: it rules out the stock answers of family, friends and health and gets you a canceled test, a dog, a good sandwich. Go around the circle with it just before the closing prayer and even the person who never prays aloud has a line to offer.

What's something you'd want us to pray about that isn't about you?

Why ask it

Turns prayer outward and makes it possible to join in without disclosing anything personal. It also shows you what they are carrying on behalf of other people: a grandparent's illness, a friend's family, something from the news.

What's one thing you could do this week for someone who can't pay you back?

Why ask it

Push for something small enough to actually happen: carrying a neighbor's groceries, an hour with a younger sibling, a text to the friend who has gone quiet. Next week, ask each person by name how it went. The question is only a nice thought until that second conversation.

If you could fix one thing about your school or your town, what would it be?

Why ask it

Keeping it local stops the answers drifting off to world peace. Listen for something the group could take on together, such as a litter cleanup, a food collection or a welcome for new students, and let whoever raised it help plan it.

What do you want to be different about your life a year from now?

Why ask it

The answers tend to be concrete: making a team, passing a class, getting a job, mending a friendship. Write them down and ask again in a few months. If someone's answer is to be out of their house or out of this town, do not steer them toward something cheerier. Ask what would be better there.

What do you want the people closest to you to say about you?

Why ask it

A gentler version of the legacy question, which can feel morbid at fifteen. If the group has already talked about pressure, put the two answers side by side: wanting to be called kind while feeling pushed to be impressive is a tension worth naming out loud.

What's one thing from tonight you'll still be thinking about tomorrow?

Why ask it

Asking what they learned sends everyone hunting for the lesson, and this asks only what stuck. Often it is something another teenager said and nothing from the talk. Count that as the discussion working, and tell the person who said it.

What's your best memory with this group, or your first impression if you're new?

Why ask it

The 'if you're new' half keeps newcomers in the conversation, and an honest first impression is something leaders rarely get to hear. Regulars will retell the same bus breakdown or midnight game every year. Let them, because those stories show a newcomer what the group is like at its best.

What would you say to someone your age who came here for the first time and felt out of place?

Why ask it

Asks them to be the host, and quietly tells you how welcoming the group actually is. If the honest answers describe the group as hard to join, you have found a real problem that is usually invisible to the leaders.

Is there anything you'd want this group to be that it isn't yet?

Why ask it

Ask it in the last ten minutes and be ready to act on one small suggestion. Requests are usually practical: more time to talk, less talking at them, food, different music. Ignoring the answers teaches them the question was decoration.

Running the conversation

Practical guidance for the conversation itself

Choosing questions for the night

  1. 1Do not try to cover the list. Four or five questions fill an hour once people are really talking: two Icebreakers, two from one of the middle sections, and one from Wrapping Up.
  2. 2Stay in one middle section per evening. Everyday Life suits a new group or the start of a school year. Faith and Friends and Family go better once the group has laughed together a few times. Church works in any week, and best when you can carry what you hear to the people who plan the services.
  3. 3With younger teenagers, or on a night with several newcomers, an evening made only of Icebreakers and Everyday Life is a good evening. Nobody has to go deep for the night to count.
  4. 4Get the room moving for the either-or questions. Standing on one side or the other is taking part, and it costs a shy person nothing.
  5. 5After the meeting, jot down what people said they would do or wanted prayer for. Several of the Wrapping Up questions only earn their place if you come back the following week and ask how it went.

Setting it up

  1. 1Say at the start that anyone can pass on any question. Then actually let it happen without comment when someone does.
  2. 2Be explicit about confidentiality and its limits: what is said here stays here, except anything that suggests someone is being hurt or is at risk, which you have to pass to the person your church names for child protection or safeguarding.
  3. 3Break into groups of four to six for the more personal questions. Ten teenagers in a circle produces performance; five in a corner produces conversation.
  4. 4Put an adult in each group who is briefed to listen rather than teach.
  5. 5Have food or something to do with their hands. Eye contact is often the hardest part of this format for a teenager, and a slice of pizza gives them somewhere else to look.

While you are asking

Wait longer than is comfortable

Count to ten in your head before rescuing a silence. Most leaders fill the gap long before that, which trains the group to wait for the adult to answer their own question.

Answer first, and briefly

Going first sets the depth, but a five-minute leader answer tells them this is a talk with pauses. Two sentences, including something real, is the right size.

Do not correct the answers

In faith settings teenagers are quick to work out which answer is wanted and to supply it. If you improve on their first honest answer, you will get correct answers from then on and learn nothing.

Follow up with what and how, not why

"Why do you think that?" sounds like a challenge to most teenagers. "What was that like?" or "What happened next?" gets the detail without the sense of being tested.

Protect the quiet ones without spotlighting them

Rather than calling on someone directly, use rounds where everyone gives one word, or written answers on paper for the harder questions. Both let a reluctant member take part without having to perform.

Common pitfalls

Using a personal question as a way into a lesson

If every answer gets tied back to the evening's teaching point, the group will notice and stop offering real material. Some questions should just be answered and left alone.

Promising total secrecy

Never say that whatever they tell you stays between the two of you. Say instead that you will tell them if you have to pass something on and why. A promise of secrecy that you later have to break does more damage than being upfront at the start.

Reacting visibly to something serious

Shock or urgency in front of the group turns a disclosure into a scene. Acknowledge it briefly, keep the session going, and follow up one to one afterwards, then with the appropriate person.

Letting the confident three carry every week

It looks like a lively group and functions as an audience. Track who has not spoken across a month rather than within a session, and design the next one around them.

Asking questions you would not answer

Before using any of the harder items here, answer it yourself in your head. If you would not say your answer in this room, do not ask a fifteen-year-old to.

When something serious comes up

Have the practical details ready before you need them: who your church's child protection or safeguarding contact is, how to reach them out of hours, and the local services you can point a family toward. Who has a duty to report, and to whom, differs by country, state and denomination, so read your church's policy and ask how it works where you are before the first meeting. If a young person describes harm at home, thoughts of suicide, or an unsafe relationship, stay calm, do not interrogate for detail, write down what they said in their words as soon as you can, and pass it on the same day. If someone is in immediate danger, call the emergency services first. Tell the young person what you are doing and why. Your role is to notice and to hand over, not to assess or to counsel.

More on this topic