Scary Questions to Ask
Spine-tingling and thought-provoking questions that explore fear, the supernatural, and dark what-ifs for thrilling conversations.
1If you were alone in a house and heard footsteps upstairs, what would you do?
Click to see why this works
If you were alone in a house and heard footsteps upstairs, what would you do?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Tests fear responses, decision-making under stress, and reveals fight-or-flight tendencies.
2What's the creepiest unexplained experience you've ever had?
Click to see why this works
What's the creepiest unexplained experience you've ever had?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Opens sharing of genuinely unsettling personal stories and belief in the paranormal.
3Would you spend a night alone in a notoriously haunted location for money?
Click to see why this works
Would you spend a night alone in a notoriously haunted location for money?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Reveals risk tolerance, skepticism level, and whether fear or greed wins out.
4If you could know the exact date of your death, would you want to?
Click to see why this works
If you could know the exact date of your death, would you want to?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Explores mortality anxiety, control desires, and whether knowledge is always power.
5What scares you more: being alone in the dark or feeling like you're being watched?
Click to see why this works
What scares you more: being alone in the dark or feeling like you're being watched?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Identifies specific fear triggers and whether isolation or presence feels more threatening.
6If everyone you know suddenly disappeared, what would be your first thought?
Click to see why this works
If everyone you know suddenly disappeared, what would be your first thought?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Reveals existential fears, paranoia levels, and immediate survival instincts.
7Would you rather lose all your memories or be unable to form new ones?
Click to see why this works
Would you rather lose all your memories or be unable to form new ones?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Forces impossible choice about identity, past versus future, and what makes life meaningful.
8What's a fear you have that most people would find irrational?
Click to see why this works
What's a fear you have that most people would find irrational?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Shows vulnerability, specific phobias, and unique anxieties others might not share.
9If you woke up buried alive in a coffin, what would go through your mind?
Click to see why this works
If you woke up buried alive in a coffin, what would go through your mind?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Tests claustrophobia, panic management, and darkest nightmare scenario thinking.
10Do you believe some people are inherently evil, or is everyone capable of redemption?
Click to see why this works
Do you believe some people are inherently evil, or is everyone capable of redemption?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Explores dark philosophy, human nature beliefs, and where evil comes from.
11What truth about yourself would you never want others to discover?
Click to see why this works
What truth about yourself would you never want others to discover?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Reveals deepest secrets, shame, and what feels too dark to share.
12If you could trade places with a serial killer for one day to understand their mind, would you?
Click to see why this works
If you could trade places with a serial killer for one day to understand their mind, would you?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Tests morbid curiosity, empathy limits, and fascination with darkness.
13What's a sound that immediately fills you with dread?
Click to see why this works
What's a sound that immediately fills you with dread?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Identifies specific fear triggers and auditory associations with danger or trauma.
14If you discovered your best friend committed a terrible crime, would you turn them in?
Click to see why this works
If you discovered your best friend committed a terrible crime, would you turn them in?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Tests loyalty versus morality, reveals values hierarchy, and ethical boundaries.
15Would you rather know all the horrible things people say about you or never know at all?
Click to see why this works
Would you rather know all the horrible things people say about you or never know at all?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Explores information anxiety, self-perception, and whether ignorance brings peace.
16What's the scariest thing that could happen to you that doesn't involve death?
Click to see why this works
What's the scariest thing that could happen to you that doesn't involve death?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Reveals fears worse than dying, like losing loved ones, sanity, or freedom.
17If you had to choose between being paralyzed but aware or in a coma, which would you pick?
Click to see why this works
If you had to choose between being paralyzed but aware or in a coma, which would you pick?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Forces grim choice about consciousness, control, and what makes life worth living.
18Do you think you'd recognize if you were slowly going insane?
Click to see why this works
Do you think you'd recognize if you were slowly going insane?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Explores sanity anxiety, self-awareness limits, and existential dread about losing grip.
19What would you do if you found a human bone while digging in your backyard?
Click to see why this works
What would you do if you found a human bone while digging in your backyard?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Tests crisis response, curiosity versus fear, and practical versus panicked reactions.
20If you could erase one memory that haunts you, would you, knowing you'd lose a part of yourself?
Click to see why this works
If you could erase one memory that haunts you, would you, knowing you'd lose a part of yourself?
Click to see why this works
Why this works
Explores trauma processing, identity connection to pain, and whether forgetting helps.
How to Use These Questions
Expert tips and techniques for getting the most out of these questions.
Guide content not available