Questions to Ask About Group Health Insurance
For a small business owner or HR lead talking to a broker or carrier before buying or renewing a group health plan for employees. The questions follow the order the decision usually takes: whether the business qualifies and who can be covered, how the plan is funded, plan design and networks, what the employer pays, renewal, and compliance and administration. Group size rules, continuation coverage and tax treatment change with state and headcount, so many of the notes tell you what to pin down for your own business instead of giving one answer.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
Eligibility
Is our business eligible for a group plan, and how many employees do we need to qualify?
Why ask it
The minimum group size, and whether an owner alone or an owner and a spouse count as a group, depends on the state and the carrier, so ask how it works where you are. A good answer names the rule and the proof the carrier will want, such as payroll or wage reports. 'You should be fine' before anyone has looked at your payroll is worth pressing.
Who counts as a full-time, eligible employee under this plan?
Why ask it
The hours threshold can come from the carrier, from the law and from your own policy, and the three do not always match. Ask for the number in writing and for how seasonal and variable-hour staff are treated. If the answer leaves you to work it out, expect an argument the first time someone's hours drop.
What share of eligible employees has to enroll, and what happens if we fall short?
Why ask it
Carriers commonly set a participation minimum, and missing it can mean a declined application, a different rate or a wait for a special enrollment window. Ask who counts as a valid waiver, since people covered through a spouse are often left out of the math. Have the count run on your real roster before anyone spends time on quotes.
What is the least the employer has to contribute toward employee premiums?
Why ask it
The floor is usually the carrier's, often written as a share of the employee-only premium, and larger employers may also face an affordability test in law. Get both the carrier's rule and the legal one for your size and state. Then ask what the businesses you compete with for staff are paying, because the floor is seldom what wins a hire.
Can owners, part-time employees or contractors be covered, and under what conditions?
Why ask it
Each of the three is handled differently, and the answer changes with how the business is set up and where it is. Contractors are the one to be careful with: a broker who says to put them on the plan without asking how they are paid is skipping a step. Ask what the carrier would check in an audit.
How long can the waiting period for new hires be, and what would you suggest for a business with our turnover?
Why ask it
There is usually a legal ceiling and a choice underneath it, so ask what the limit is for your plan. A short wait helps with hiring, and a longer one saves paperwork where people often leave in the first months. A broker who asks about your turnover before answering is doing the job properly.
Which dependents can employees add, and how are domestic partners and adult children handled?
Why ask it
Spouses and young children are routine. Domestic partners are where carriers and states differ, both on eligibility and on how the premium is taxed, and the age at which a child comes off the plan is set by rules you should have quoted to you. Ask for the definition the carrier uses and the proof it wants, and raise it now if you know someone on staff it affects.
We have employees in more than one state. How does that change which plans we can buy?
Why ask it
A regional network that suits the main office can leave a remote employee with no nearby doctor, and it is not always obvious which state's rules govern the contract. Bring a list of the states and ask where each person would get care. With everyone in one place, skip this.
Funding
Is this quote fully insured, level-funded or self-funded, and who pays the claims in each case?
Why ask it
On a fully insured plan the carrier takes the risk for a fixed premium. On the other two the employer funds claims up to a limit, usually with stop-loss insurance above it. A good answer says in one sentence who is out the money in a bad year, and a proposal that does not label its funding cannot be compared on price with one that does.
Will employees have to answer health questions for us to get this quote?
Why ask it
It depends on the funding type, the group size and the state: some small-group fully insured rates cannot use health history at all, while level-funded quotes commonly ask for it. Find out what is collected, who sees it and whether anything individual comes back to you. You want to be able to tell staff truthfully that their employer never reads the answers.
On a level-funded plan, what happens to the money if claims come in under what we paid?
Why ask it
Some arrangements return a share of the surplus, some credit it to the next year, some keep it, and some pay only if you renew. Ask for the percentage, the timing and the conditions in the contract language. 'You may get money back' with no terms attached is a sales line.
If claims run over the expected amount, what is the most we could owe in a year?
Why ask it
The answer should be one dollar figure: the fixed monthly cost for twelve months plus anything due if you leave. Press on that last part, because a bill at termination is the piece most often left off the first proposal. No figure, no comparison with a fully insured quote.
What are the stop-loss limits, per person and for the whole group, and who is the stop-loss carrier?
Why ask it
The per-person limit caps what you fund for any one member, and the aggregate limit caps the group's total. Then ask whether the stop-loss carrier can set a higher limit for one named individual at renewal, sometimes called a laser. If that question draws a blank, the person across the table has not placed many of these plans.
If a level-funded renewal comes back high, can we move back to a fully insured plan, and on what terms?
Why ask it
This is the exit, and it is worth knowing before you go in. Whether a plan priced without regard to your claims is available to a group your size depends on your market, so have the broker say how it works in your state. Hesitation here suggests nobody has thought through your worst year.
What claims reports would we receive, and how often?
Why ask it
Seeing where the money goes is one of the reasons employers leave fully insured plans, so ask for a sample report. In a small group a single large claim can point to one person, which means you should also ask how reports are summarized to protect privacy. Monthly totals with no detail tell you little; detail with names is a problem.
Is there an alternative to a group plan we should price first, such as reimbursing employees for coverage they buy themselves?
Why ask it
Depending on your size and location, a reimbursement arrangement or a professional employer organization's plan can cost less or be simpler to run. The useful answer includes what employees would lose or gain, not only what you would save. If no alternative comes up at all, find out whether this broker sells one before you take the silence as a verdict.
Plans and networks
Which network does each plan use, and are the hospitals and doctors our employees rely on in it?
Why ask it
Before the meeting, collect an anonymous list of the providers staff would not want to lose, then have every name checked against every plan. Carriers sell several networks under similar names, and a narrow one behind a familiar logo is the usual surprise. Check the nearest hospital and the nearest children's hospital even if nobody listed them.
Which of these plans need a referral to see a specialist, and which pay nothing outside the network?
Why ask it
Those two answers are the practical difference between the HMO, PPO and EPO labels, and carriers do not all use the labels the same way, so get both for each plan instead of settling for the acronym. Employees coming from an open plan notice a referral rule in the first month. If you offer two plans, making one of them the open one gives the people who mind a choice.
How many plan options can we offer side by side, and are there rules about pairing them?
Why ask it
A lower-cost plan next to a richer one lets employees choose for themselves, which takes some of the heat out of a plan change. Carriers often tie the number of options to group size and restrict which plans can sit together. Ask whether adding an option changes the rates or only the paperwork.
Can you lay out the deductible, coinsurance and out-of-pocket maximum for each plan, for a single employee and for a family?
Why ask it
Get it as one table with the same rows for every plan. Then ask how the family deductible works: whether one sick person has to meet the whole family amount before the plan pays. The family column is where employees with children feel a plan change, and it is the one most summaries tuck away.
What will employees pay for the visits they make most: primary care, a specialist, urgent care, a therapy session?
Why ask it
Plenty of employees never reach the deductible, so they judge the plan by these four prices. The detail to pin down is whether each is a flat copay from day one or billed in full until the deductible is met. Two plans with the same deductible can feel completely different on this point.
How do prescriptions work on each plan: the drug list, the tiers and any separate drug deductible?
Why ask it
You should not be asking employees what they take, so ask the broker for a link to each plan's drug list that staff can check privately. Specialty drugs are where plans differ most and where a change of carrier can hit one household hard. A separate drug deductible is easy to miss on a summary page.
Which plans can be paired with a health savings account, and is it worth us putting money into the accounts?
Why ask it
A high deductible alone does not make a plan eligible; the design has to meet specific rules, so have the broker confirm it plan by plan. Money from the employer into the account takes some of the sting out of a higher deductible. Ask what it would cost you compared with buying the richer plan outright.
Beyond the deductible, where do these plans differ most in what they cover?
Why ask it
A broker who knows the plans will point to specifics: visit limits on therapy or rehab, prior authorization rules, what is paid out of network. 'They are all the same apart from price' is rarely true. Ask for the benefit summaries and compare two lines yourself, starting with whichever service your staff use most.
How are employees covered when they travel, or when a child is at college in another state?
Why ask it
It turns on whether the network is local or national and on what the plan pays for non-emergency care away from home. For a workforce that stays put this is minor. One family with a student three states away will ask about it on the first day of enrollment, so have the answer ready.
If we change carriers, what happens to an employee in the middle of treatment or a pregnancy?
Why ask it
Ask whether the new plan has a transition-of-care provision that lets someone keep their current doctor for a period, and how they apply for it. For a mid-year switch, ask whether deductible amounts already paid get any credit. A complete answer comes with a form and a deadline, and it lets you reassure the people most worried about the move.
Can dental, vision, life or disability coverage be bundled with the medical plan, and does bundling change the price?
Why ask it
Some carriers discount when lines are packaged and some price each line better alone, so ask for both versions of the quote. Check whether the added lines carry their own participation rules. If medical is all you can afford this year, say so and move on.
Employer cost
What is the total monthly and annual cost with our actual roster, including every fee?
Why ask it
Have it built from your census, employee by employee, with administration, platform and broker fees shown as separate lines. A quote based on assumed enrollment is an illustration. Compare totals across carriers, since a lower per-employee rate can sit on top of higher fees.
Should we contribute a percentage of the premium or a fixed dollar amount, and what does each do to us at renewal?
Why ask it
With a percentage, your cost rises automatically when rates do. With a fixed amount, the increase lands on employees unless you revisit it. Have both modeled on your roster, and ask about pegging the contribution to the lowest-cost plan so that anyone choosing a richer one pays the difference.
Do we have to contribute anything toward spouses and children?
Why ask it
Often the carrier's contribution rule applies only to the employee's own premium, but confirm it for your carrier and state. Contributing nothing can price family coverage out of reach, and then employees waive and your participation number suffers. Ask what the family tier would take out of a paycheck at the contribution you have in mind.
Are the rates age-banded or a single composite rate, and do we get to choose?
Why ask it
Age-banded pricing gives each employee a premium based on age; composite pricing sets one rate per tier for everyone. Which is available depends on group size and local rules. Ask what your bill does when you hire a 25-year-old and when you hire a 60-year-old, and how you would set employee contributions fairly under each.
Can employees pay their share of the premium before tax, and what do we have to set up for that?
Why ask it
This usually takes a written plan document and the right payroll setup, so ask who drafts the document, what it costs and how often it needs updating. Then check the answer with whoever runs your payroll. Deductions taken the wrong way are tedious to unwind after the fact.
Is there a tax credit or other help for a business our size, and what would we need to do to qualify?
Why ask it
Help of this kind tends to come with conditions on headcount, average wages and where the plan is bought, and it changes. A broker should raise it; your accountant should confirm it. Treat 'you will qualify' as a prompt to check, and do not build the budget on it until someone has run your numbers.
Are the rates locked for the full plan year, and what could change them before then?
Why ask it
Ask for the rate guarantee period in writing and for the list of events that can reopen it: a large swing in enrollment, an acquisition, an error on the application. Some carriers will lock dental or vision for longer than medical. If you are told nothing can change the rates, ask to be shown that sentence in the contract.
Renewal
What have renewal increases looked like for groups like ours on this plan over the last few years?
Why ask it
A low first-year price followed by a steep renewal is the pattern you are trying to rule out. Ask for the range across the broker's own clients, not an average and not a promise. Someone who says they cannot predict next year but shows you the history is more believable than someone who names a number.
How will our renewal rate be set: on our own claims, on a wider pool, or a blend of the two?
Why ask it
Smaller fully insured groups are often rated with a pool, so one bad year does not follow them; larger and level-funded groups tend to be rated on their own experience. Have the broker say which applies to you. It tells you whether a single serious illness on staff could change next year's price.
When will we receive the renewal, and how long will we have to decide?
Why ask it
Ask for a date, counted in days before the plan year ends, and ask whether the broker will request it early. With only a couple of weeks you will renew by default because there is no time to do anything else. Put the date in your calendar the day you sign.
If the increase is more than we can absorb, what are our options short of cutting benefits?
Why ask it
Listen for a list in some order: negotiating with the current carrier, quoting others, changing the funding, adjusting the contribution, adding a second plan. 'We shop it every year' is fine as far as it goes. Follow up by asking what each switch costs employees in new cards, new networks and deductibles that start over.
Does the deductible reset on the calendar year or the plan year, and can we move our renewal date?
Why ask it
When the two do not line up, employees who met a deductible in the fall can start again a few months later, and that generates complaints you will hear directly. Ask which the plan uses. A renewal that falls in your busiest month is also worth moving if the carrier allows it.
If we leave this carrier, how much notice do we have to give, and what happens to claims still being processed?
Why ask it
On a fully insured plan the carrier normally pays for care received before the end date, but ask for the termination clause anyway. On a level-funded plan, ask about the run-out period, who funds it and any fee for leaving. Miss the notice deadline and you may owe another month.
Compliance and admin
When someone leaves, which continuation coverage rules apply to a business our size: federal COBRA, a state version, or neither?
Why ask it
Which law applies generally turns on headcount, and state continuation rules differ a good deal, so ask for the answer for your size and state specifically. You need three things from it: how soon the departing employee has to be told, how long coverage can last and what they pay for it. Write them down, because the first departure will not wait for you to look it up.
Who administers continuation coverage: you, the carrier, an outside administrator or us?
Why ask it
Notices with deadlines are easy to miss when the work only comes up a few times a year. If the answer is that it falls to you, ask what an outside administrator charges per month. Weigh that fee against the hours and the exposure of doing it by hand.
Which notices, plan documents and filings does this plan put on us, and which will you prepare?
Why ask it
Ask for a calendar with each item, its due date and the name of whoever is responsible. 'We handle compliance' means little until you see that list. Anything on it you do not recognize is a question for your attorney or accountant, not something to take on a salesperson's word.
Is our headcount close to a threshold where the rules change?
Why ask it
Obligations tend to step up at certain employer sizes, and the way part-time staff are counted toward those sizes is not intuitive. Ask how the count is done and what would be new if you hired past the next line. A business nowhere near a threshold gets a short answer, which is fine.
If we go ahead, what is the earliest date coverage could start, and what do you need from us by when?
Why ask it
Work backward from the start date: the carrier's application deadline, the enrollment window before it, and the day staff have to be told. Ask which document most often holds a group up, because one missing wage report or waiver form can push a start date back a month. If you are leaving another carrier, line the date up with the old plan's last day so nobody has a gap.
How does enrollment run: online or on paper, who explains the plans to staff, and how long is the window?
Why ask it
Ask to see the screen or form an employee will actually use. A session where someone explains a deductible in plain words, in the languages your staff speak, lifts enrollment, and enrollment is a number you have to hit. A stack of PDFs emailed on a Friday does the opposite.
Is there a benefits administration system, does it connect to our payroll, and what does it cost?
Why ask it
Payroll deductions that do not match what people enrolled in are a routine source of errors and awkward conversations. Find out whether a change flows to the carrier and to payroll on its own or has to be keyed twice. For a very small group a spreadsheet and a careful person can be enough.
How do we add a new hire or remove someone who has left, and how quickly does that reach the carrier?
Why ask it
Get the effective-date rule for new hires and the limit on backdating a termination. Carriers commonly cap how far back they will refund premium for a person you forgot to remove, so ask what the cap is. The answer you want includes a number of days.
What can employees change in the middle of the year, and what proof do we have to collect?
Why ask it
Events such as a marriage, a birth or losing other coverage typically open a short window, so ask how many days it lasts and which documents the carrier wants. It will come up within months of the plan starting, so whoever handles HR should have the rules on a single page.
When an employee has a claim denied or a billing problem, who do they call, and do we ever need to be involved?
Why ask it
The best answer keeps you out of your employees' medical details entirely: a service line at the broker or an advocate at the carrier. If the route runs through the owner's desk, ask for another one. Get the number in a form you can hand to staff at enrollment.
What health information might reach us as the employer, and how are we expected to handle it?
Why ask it
Privacy rules limit what an employer may see and do with it, and the exposure is greater on plans where claims reports come to you. Ask what arrives, who in the business should be the one to open it and how it should be stored. 'Very little, and here is who should receive it' is the reassuring version.
How to question a group health insurance proposal
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
Before the meeting
Build the census once
A census is the list a carrier prices from: each employee's date of birth, home zip code, hours and whether they would cover a spouse or children. Prepare one accurate version and give the same file to every broker or carrier, so the quotes that come back are for the same group.
Bring the current plan's paperwork
If you are renewing, have the latest invoice, the renewal letter and the benefit summaries to hand. A broker can only tell you whether a new quote is better when they can see what you pay and what the plan covers today.
Ask staff what they would not give up
A short anonymous survey is enough: the doctors and hospitals people want to keep, and whether they would trade a higher deductible for a lower paycheck deduction. Do not ask about conditions or medications. You are after priorities, and the answers settle half the network questions before the meeting starts.
Decide the budget as a yearly total
Work out what the business can spend on premiums across twelve months before anyone shows you a rate. It is easier to hold a line you drew at your own desk than one you draw while looking at three attractive plan designs.
Cut the list to fit your quotes
If every proposal is fully insured, most of Funding falls away: keep its first two questions and the one about alternatives, and leave surplus, stop-loss and the route back for the year someone offers you a level-funded plan. A business with everyone in one state can drop the multi-state question. Send the factual ones ahead by email (eligibility rules, the rate table, the fee list) and keep the meeting for the answers you need to hear someone give.
In the meeting
Start with eligibility, not price
The Eligibility questions decide whether a quote can be issued at all. A participation shortfall, a contribution below the carrier's floor or a contractor counted as an employee can undo a proposal weeks later, after you have told staff what is coming.
Ask how it works here
Group size rules, continuation coverage, rating methods and tax treatment vary by state, by country and by headcount. When an answer begins with 'generally', follow with 'and for a business our size, in our state?' and note what you are told so you can verify it.
Have the worst year priced
For any level-funded or self-funded proposal, ask for the most the business could owe in a year where everything goes wrong, written as one figure. A plan you can afford on average but not in a bad year belongs to a business with deeper reserves than yours.
Get the answers that matter in writing
Surplus terms, rate guarantees, termination fees and who handles which notice should arrive by email or in the contract, not only in conversation. The person who made the promise may not be the person on the account at renewal.
Comparing two or three proposals
Put every quote on one sheet
Use the same rows for each: funding type, network name, deductible and out-of-pocket maximum for single and family, employer cost per year, employee cost per paycheck at each tier, and fees. Gaps in a column show you what a proposal left out.
Read it as an employee would
Pick three people on your roster in different situations, say a single 28-year-old, a parent of three and someone near retirement, and work out what each would pay per paycheck and in a year with a hospital stay. A plan that saves the business money by moving cost onto one of those three will be noticed.
Count the cost of switching
A new carrier means new ID cards, a new network to check, possibly new prior authorizations and a deductible that may start over. A small saving can be worth less than the disruption, and a broker should be willing to say when staying put is the better call.
Look at year two
Set the first-year price beside what you were told about renewals, rating method and the route back to a fully insured plan. The cheapest opening quote is a different thing from the cheapest three years.
Reasons to slow down
A quote with no funding label
If a proposal does not say whether it is fully insured, level-funded or self-funded, you do not yet know who pays the claims. Ask before reading another line of it.
Savings described without a ceiling
Talk of money back in a good year, with no figure for what you owe in a bad one, is half a description. Both numbers come out of the same contract, so anyone who can quote the first can quote the second.
Legal answers with nothing behind them
A broker can explain how plans usually work and what their other clients do. Whether a rule applies to your business is a question for the plan documents, the regulator's own guidance or your attorney or accountant. Be cautious with anyone who answers every compliance question instantly and never says 'check that'.
A deadline that leaves no time to read
Real deadlines exist: a carrier wants the application some number of days before the effective date. Ask what the date is and where it comes from. Pressure to sign today, before you have seen the contract, serves the seller.