Questions to Ask an Executive Candidate
These are for the board member, chief executive or search committee sitting across from a finalist for a senior leadership seat, whatever the function. They start with the questions to ask an executive candidate about culture, the subject a resume and a search firm's summary say least about, then cover who they hired and fired, how they disagree with peers and a board, how they act under pressure, their track record, and this role and their references. Take a few from each group per round, and put the same culture questions to every finalist in the same words.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
Culture
How would you describe the culture of the last team you led, and what would the people on it say you got wrong about it?
Why ask it
Most candidates arrive with a polished paragraph for the first half. The second half shows whether they ever asked. If they cannot name a gap between their view and the team's, ask how they found out what people two levels down thought.
Tell me about a culture you inherited and set out to change. What did you do in the first six months that people could see?
Why ask it
Listen for acts in place of slogans: a meeting cancelled, a promotion, a rule dropped, a person moved out. Then ask what was still the same a year later, because every honest account of culture change has a part that did not shift.
Which behavior did you refuse to tolerate, and who was the first person it cost?
Why ask it
A value is real once it has cost someone something. The answer shows where this candidate's line sits and whether it held when the person on the wrong side of it was a top performer. No example usually means the line lived on a poster.
How do you find out what it is really like to work below your direct reports?
Why ask it
Executives get a filtered account by default, so the good answers are habits: skip-level conversations, time spent beside front-line work, reading exit interviews themselves. Ask what the last one told them that their own team had not.
What from your last company's culture would you bring here, and what would you leave behind?
Why ask it
It shows whether they treat culture as luggage or as something built for one place. A candidate who would bring all of it is planning to rebuild the old company in your building. When nothing is named to leave behind, ask what their last employer did that would not survive here.
What is your leadership style, and when did you last have to lead against it?
Why ask it
Nearly every candidate has a label ready, such as collaborative or hands-off, and the label tells you little. The occasion that called for the opposite is the useful part: the consensus builder who had to decide alone, the delegator who had to step into the detail. If none comes to mind, they may have one way of leading and apply it everywhere.
From what you have seen of us so far, how would you describe our culture?
Why ask it
They have had the scheduling, the panel and the people who showed them around to go on, so a good observer has something specific to say. If the reply only flatters, tell them one thing your own staff find hard about the place and see what they do with it.
Tell me about a time the culture you wanted and the results you needed pulled in opposite directions.
Why ask it
The usual cases are the top seller who is hard on colleagues and the deadline that needed everyone's weekend. Which way they went matters less than whether they saw a trade at all and can say what it cost. Be wary of a story in which nothing was given up.
How did people on your team know what you valued without being told?
Why ask it
The true answer is in what got promoted, what got praised in front of others and what the candidate asked about first in every review. If they reach for a values statement, ask what the first item on their staff meeting agenda was.
When has someone who worked for you told you that you were the problem?
Why ask it
This is a test of whether bad news travels upward to them. Strong candidates name the occasion and what they changed. If it has never happened, ask why they think that is, since the likelier explanation is that people stopped trying.
What kind of culture do you do your worst work in?
Why ask it
Every executive has one: consensus on everything, a founder who decides alone, a matrix with three bosses. A straight answer lets you compare it with what you really are. Describe how decisions get made here in a sentence and watch how they take it.
How did you hold a culture together when the team doubled, merged with another or stopped sharing an office?
Why ask it
Ask about whichever of the three is ahead of you. Habits that work at forty people stop working at four hundred, and a candidate who has lived through it can say which one broke first and what replaced it.
What would you do in your first month here to learn the culture before trying to change any of it?
Why ask it
You are checking for patience and method: who they would talk to beyond their own reports, and what they would ask. Someone who arrives with the answer tends to fix things that were working. Ask what would count as a sign to leave something alone.
Hiring and firing
Who are the three best people you ever hired, and where are they now?
Why ask it
Names come fast to people who hire well. Where those people ended up tells you whether the candidate develops talent or only collects it, and it hands you three names you could ask to speak to later, with the candidate's agreement.
If you left your current job tomorrow, who would run your function, and would your boss agree with the choice?
Why ask it
A successor the boss would accept means the candidate has been developing someone and putting that person's work in front of others. Two names is a fine answer. 'It would be hard to replace me' is the one to probe, because the team may have been built to depend on them.
Tell me about a senior hire you got wrong. How long did it take you to act?
Why ask it
Nearly everyone at this level has one. The thing to measure is the gap between knowing and acting, and what the team under that person lived through in the meantime. Close by asking what they do differently in interviews now.
Think of the last person you let go. How would that person describe the conversation?
Why ask it
It asks the candidate to sit in the other chair. Whether the reason was stated plainly, how much warning there was and how the team heard are a preview of how your own people would be treated. Do not press for a name or for private details about the person.
When you take over a team, how do you decide who stays?
Why ask it
Ask how long they give it and what evidence they use beyond first impressions. Someone who turns up with a list has already decided, and someone who has never changed an inherited team deserves a follow-up too. If there are people you expect to stay, say so now and see how they handle a constraint.
If you joined us, which seats would you expect to fill with people you already know?
Why ask it
A following is a good sign and a transplanted team is a different thing. Ask how they would run an open process for those seats and what they would say to the people in them today. Whether their current contract limits who they may approach is a question for your counsel, not for the interview.
Who have you promoted over other people's doubts, and how did it turn out?
Why ask it
The story shows what they notice in people that others miss, and how much support they give after taking the risk. Keep a quiet tally of everyone they speak warmly about across the interview. If they all sound alike, ask about that.
Who on your last leadership team was least like you, and what were they right about?
Why ask it
A top team that thinks alike is comfortable and misses the same things. A specific person and a specific occasion mean the candidate can use a different mind. A long pause means they may have hired their own reflection.
How do you tell a senior, well-paid person who is used to being right that their work is not good enough?
Why ask it
Feedback gets rarer the higher people sit, and the executive is often the only one in a position to give it. Ask for the last time and for the actual words. 'I let the numbers speak' usually means the conversation never took place.
Peers and board
Tell me about a serious disagreement with a peer on the leadership team. How did it end?
Why ask it
What you want is the route they took: straight to the person, up to the boss, or out into the corridor. Ask whether the two of them would choose to work together again, and which of them made the first move to repair things.
When did you last lose an argument at the executive table, and what did you tell your own team afterward?
Why ask it
Disagreeing and then committing is easy to claim. The test is how the decision reached their people: as 'we decided' or as 'they decided'. If they cannot recall losing one, find out whether they tend to carry the room or to stay out of the hard arguments.
How do you disagree with the person you report to: before the meeting, in it or after it?
Why ask it
No answer is right in general. It has to suit the person they would report to here, so say how your chief executive or chair likes to be challenged and see whether the two fit. Then ask for the most recent time and what was at stake.
What have you told a board that it did not want to hear?
Why ask it
If you are a director, you are asking how you would be treated. Good accounts include the timing: whether the chair heard before the meeting and how early the board knew. For a candidate who has not presented to a board, ask about the most senior group they have answered to.
A director calls you directly to question a decision your chief executive made. What do you do?
Why ask it
For anyone below the top seat this tests loyalty and openness together. The sound answers involve listening, not briefing against the boss, and telling the chief executive about the call. For a chief executive candidate, turn it around: a director phones one of their reports.
Which function have you had the most friction with across your career, and why?
Why ask it
Finance against sales, product against engineering, legal against nearly everyone: some tension comes with the seats. The same fight in three companies is about the candidate. Whichever function they name, have its leader here spend an hour with them.
When did you last give up budget or headcount so that another function's priority could go ahead?
Why ask it
An executive belongs to the top team first and leads a function second. A real example, with the amount and the person who gained, shows they act that way. If none comes to mind, ask what they do in the leadership meeting when the topic is outside their own area.
What would your peers say is hardest about working alongside you?
Why ask it
Peers see what bosses and direct reports do not: who shares credit, who goes quiet, who holds a grudge. Write the reply down as close to word for word as you can and ask a peer reference the same thing.
Pressure
Tell me about the worst quarter of your career. What did you do differently as it got worse?
Why ask it
Pressure narrows people, and this shows the direction. Some pull every decision toward themselves, some disappear into the detail, some start talking to customers. Ask what the team saw of them during those weeks.
How do the people around you know when you are under strain?
Why ask it
It is a self-knowledge question. Useful replies are concrete: shorter messages, more checking, a closed door. If the claim is that nobody can tell, ask what their assistant or chief of staff would say, and who is allowed to tell them to go home.
Who do you talk to before a decision you cannot undo, and when did one of them last change your mind?
Why ask it
By this level few people are left who will argue with them, so it matters who they go to: a peer, a former boss, someone outside work, nobody. A recent change of mind shows the advice gets used. Notice whether anyone who worked for them is on the list.
What is the hardest cut you have made, and what did you say to the people who stayed?
Why ask it
Those who remain decide what the place feels like afterward. Listen for whether the candidate did the telling in person and explained the reasoning, or sent a memo. How they talk about the people who left tells you something as well.
When has a boss, a board or an investor pressed you to do something you thought was wrong, and how did it end?
Why ask it
Small cases count: a figure rounded the helpful way, a customer told half the story. You are listening for where the line was, who was leaning on it and whether holding it cost them anything. Let the silence run before you rescue them from this one.
What is the most visible mistake you have made, and how did people first hear about it?
Why ask it
Speed and source are what matter here. The strong version has the candidate telling the boss or the board before anyone else could. Notice the grammar: 'I got it wrong' and 'mistakes were made' describe two different people.
Which decision did you make too slowly, and what were you waiting for?
Why ask it
Under pressure executives either rush or stall, and this one finds the staller. The usual subjects are a person, a product or a price. Ask next for a decision made too fast, and see which story they tell with more feeling.
Track record
What were you brought in to do in your last role, and how far did you get?
Why ask it
A mandate gives the track record a yardstick. Write down the mandate as the candidate states it and check it against the version from whoever hired them. A large difference between the two is a question for the next round.
Pick the result you are proudest of. What did you personally do in the week it turned?
Why ask it
At this level results are made by other people, so the question separates whoever made the call from whoever was in the building. If the reply is a list of meetings chaired, ask what would have gone differently had they been on leave.
Which result on your resume do you get too much credit for?
Why ask it
A rising market, an inherited team and good timing sit behind many strong numbers. Candidates who can say so without flinching usually share credit easily at work. Follow with the one they get too little credit for, which is often the more revealing story.
Tell me about a plan you championed that failed. How long did you go on defending it after you knew?
Why ask it
The failure matters less than the lag. Months spent defending a plan they had privately given up on tell you how expensive their pride could be. Ask who first told them it was not working and what became of that person.
What did you stop your last organization from doing, and how did you make it stick?
Why ask it
Strategy shows up in what gets refused. Listen for something that had a sponsor, a budget and people attached, and for who objected. Things that were already dying do not count.
How large were the team and the budget you were fully accountable for, and how does that compare with this job?
Why ask it
A step up in scale is not a reason to say no, but it is a place where capable executives stumble. Get plain figures, keeping what they ran apart from what they only influenced, then ask what they would need from you in the first year to make the step.
What is the real reason you left your last job, and who would tell that story differently?
Why ask it
Asking who would tell it differently puts the other version on the table before a reference does. Disagreement between the accounts is normal. What matters is whether the candidate can state the other side fairly.
Role and references
What are you hoping this job gives you that your current one cannot?
Why ask it
Scope, a title, a different boss, a way out: each motive predicts something about how long they would stay and what would disappoint them. Ask what else they are looking at. Someone who is mainly getting away from a bad situation may accept a job that does not suit them, and both sides pay for that.
From what you know so far, which two or three things does this business have to get right in the next two years?
Why ask it
It tests preparation and reasoning, not accuracy, since an outsider cannot know what you know. Give them one fact they are missing and see whether the answer moves. How they treat a new fact in the interview is a fair preview of how they would treat one in the job.
Before you said yes, what would you want to hear from the people who would report to you?
Why ask it
A finalist who wants time with the team, and can say what they would ask, is weighing the job as it is. Arrange it if you can. Where the search is confidential or the person in the seat has not been told, say so plainly and offer a director who knows the team well.
What would you need from the chief executive and the board to do this job well?
Why ask it
These are the terms of the working relationship: say over their own hires, budget, access to directors. It is better to hear them now than in month three. Where you cannot give what they ask, say so in the room.
What have you learned about us in this process that gives you pause?
Why ask it
A serious candidate has doubts, and none at all means they have not looked or are not saying. Answer truthfully. A senior hire who finds the problem after starting feels misled, and that is a poor beginning with someone you need to trust.
Who should we speak to who has worked for you, beside you and above you?
Why ask it
A list made only of former bosses shows how someone manages upward. Ask for at least one past report and one peer, and ask what each is likely to say. Get the candidate's agreement before contacting anyone they did not name, and ask your search firm or counsel how references are handled where you are.
When we talk to your references, what will they say you still need to work on?
Why ask it
People answer more candidly when they know the answer will be checked. Note what they say and bring it to the calls. A reference who raises something the candidate left out is giving you the topic for the final conversation.
Is there anything in your background that we should hear from you first?
Why ask it
This is the chance to raise a dispute, a dismissal or a public story before a check turns it up. How they tell it counts as much as what it is. What you may ask about and verify differs from place to place, so talk to your counsel or HR lead before any checks begin.
How to interview an executive candidate
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
Setting up the rounds
Agree what you are hiring for before anyone meets a candidate
Write one page that the board, the chief executive and the committee all sign up to: the three outcomes the hire is for, the authority that comes with the seat, and the two or three ways of working you will not trade away. Without it every interviewer measures against a private picture, and the debrief becomes an argument about the job.
Give each interviewer a group
Executive processes run to several meetings, and candidates notice when four people in a row ask about their leadership style. Hand Culture and Hiring and firing to people who will work with the person, Peers and board to a director or the chair, and Track record to whoever knows the function. Pressure questions go best one to one, late in the process, and the chair of the committee keeps Role and references for the final meeting.
Keep the culture questions identical across finalists
Pick four or five from the Culture group and ask every finalist those, worded the same way each time. Free conversation tends to favor whichever candidate is most like the panel. Identical questions give you answers you can lay side by side.
Tell the candidate what the place is really like
A senior candidate is interviewing you too, and can only judge their fit with a place that has been described truthfully. Say how decisions get made, what the last person in the seat struggled with and what staff would complain about. The questions about your own organization under Role and references only work if you have done this first.
Use the search firm for what it is good at
If a firm is running the search, ask what it has already covered so the panel does not repeat it, and ask to see its notes in the candidate's words instead of a summary. The firm's view is useful, but the firm will not be the one working with this person, so the judgment on culture stays with you.
Getting past the rehearsed answer on culture
Ask what they did, then what it cost
Anyone can describe a healthy culture. Fewer can name the person they moved, the revenue they passed up or the argument they had in order to keep it. Most questions under Culture are built in two halves for that reason, and the second half is the one to wait for.
Stay on one story
A candidate with twenty years behind them can switch examples whenever a question gets close. Choose one situation early, such as the culture they inherited or the hire that failed, and keep returning to it: who else was involved, what happened next, what the team said. Depth on one story tells you more than a tour of six.
Ask the same thing from another seat
After their account, ask how a direct report would tell it, then a peer. The Hiring and firing and Peers and board groups do this on purpose. A leader who can give the other versions fairly has usually listened to them.
Watch the process as well as the answers
How a candidate treats the scheduler, the most junior person on the panel and the member of staff who walks them to the room is evidence about culture that you did not have to ask for. Collect those impressions deliberately, and for every finalist, not only the one somebody already doubts.
Weighing what you heard
Score alone before the panel talks
Have each interviewer write a rating and two lines of evidence per group before the debrief. Once the panel is together, the most senior voice or the most confident one sets the view, and in an executive search that voice often belongs to the candidate's future boss.
Separate 'like us' from 'good for us'
Culture fit slides easily into comfort: a similar background, a shared sense of humor, the same schools. Go back to the page you wrote at the start and ask which of the stated ways of working the candidate gave evidence for. Sometimes the right hire is the one who adds what the team lacks.
Treat references as a second interview
Bring the candidate's own answers to the calls: the mandate they described, what they said peers find hard, what they expect to be raised. You are checking the story, not collecting praise. Speak to people who worked for them as well as people they worked for, with the candidate's knowledge, and before going beyond the names you were given ask your search firm or counsel what is allowed where you are.
Give weight to what they asked you
Notice what the candidate wanted to know. Questions about the team, the board's habits and why the last person left point to someone weighing the real job. Questions only about title, package and reporting line point somewhere else.
Where executive hiring goes wrong
Being dazzled by the last employer
A well-known company on a resume says the candidate was hired there once. It does not say what they did, or whether their methods depend on that company's money and name. The Track record questions are there to pull the person apart from the logo.
Letting charm stand in for evidence
Executives are practiced at rooms like this one. If the panel comes out calling the candidate impressive and nobody can repeat a concrete example, the interview measured presence. Go back with the Pressure group and ask for dates, names and amounts.
Going easy out of deference
Panels often tread lightly with senior people, as if asking about a firing or a failure were rude. The candidate expects those questions, and a board that will not ask them now is showing how loosely it would hold the person to account later. A short reason helps: 'this role inherits a difficult team, so I want to understand how you have handled one'.
Drifting into personal life
Family, age, health, faith and similar subjects have no place in the interview, however friendly the dinner. Which topics are off limits by law depends on where you are, so have your HR lead or counsel brief everyone who will meet the candidate, including directors who do not interview often.
Deciding before the references are done
By the final round a panel has usually fallen for someone, and the reference calls turn into a formality. Make the calls before the committee meets to decide, and agree beforehand what you would need to hear to change your mind.