Questions to Ask Potential Puppy Buyers
For breeders, and for families with a single litter to place, who have to decide which of the people asking gets a puppy. The questions follow the order screening usually takes: the first message or application, the home and yard, daily life, experience with dogs, money and vet care, and the contract and handover. A few answers should end the sale, such as a surprise gift or a plan to breed a puppy sold as a pet, but most gaps, from a missing fence to a long workday, are a reason to say not yet.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
First contact
What made you decide to get a puppy now, and why this breed?
Why ask it
Put this first, on the form or in the opening minute of a call, while the buyer is still talking freely and has not started guessing what you want to hear. People who have thought it through talk about their own lives: the hours they keep, the dog they grew up with, what they want to do with this one. An answer that is all about how the puppies look in your photos is not a no, but it tells you to spend longer on the breed's difficult side later.
Who lives in your home, and does every adult there want this puppy?
Why ask it
Ask for names and ages, including anyone who stays part of the week. A puppy brought home over a partner's objection, or sprung on a roommate, is a puppy that tends to come back to you. If one adult is lukewarm, ask to have that person on the next call before you take a deposit.
Is the puppy for your own household, or is it a gift for someone else?
Why ask it
Whoever will live with the dog for the whole of its life is the person you need to screen. For a gift to another adult, ask to speak to them directly, and treat a surprise as a stop until you have. A puppy for a child is really a puppy for the parents, so they are the applicants.
Do you want a family pet, or are you hoping to show, compete or work the dog?
Why ask it
This decides which puppy you would point them to more than whether you sell at all. A home that wants agility or field work needs the busy, bold puppy that would wear out a quiet household. If they mention showing or breeding, move to your registration and contract terms before the conversation goes further.
When are you hoping to bring a puppy home, and what else is going on in your life around then?
Why ask it
You are listening for a new baby, a house move, a new job or two weeks abroad in the puppy's first month. None of them rules a home out, but each is a reason to offer a later litter. A hard deadline such as a birthday or a holiday morning means the date matters more to them than the match.
What is your full name, your home address and the best number to reach you on?
Why ask it
Collect these before the first call and see that they hold together: the address exists on a map, the phone is answered by the person who wrote to you, and the name is the one on the payment later. Someone who will not say where the puppy is going to live until pickup day has ended the conversation for you. Ask for no more than you will use, and keep it to yourself.
How did you find us, and are you talking to other breeders or on other waiting lists?
Why ask it
Being on two or three lists is ordinary and sensible, and a buyer who says so is being straight with you. What you are checking is whether they chose you for a reason, such as your dogs' health results or a recommendation, or simply because you have puppies ready this week. Someone who will take any puppy from anyone by Saturday will not wait for your answer either.
Do you have your heart set on a particular sex, color or markings, and what if that puppy is not available?
Why ask it
A preference is fine. A buyer who will only take the one with the blue eyes is choosing a look, and may be less patient with the dog inside it. The useful part is the second half: whether they would wait for another litter or consider the puppy you think suits them.
Home and yard
Do you own or rent, and if you rent, can you send me your landlord's written permission for a dog of this breed and adult size?
Why ask it
Ask for it in writing, with the breed and the expected adult weight named, since leases and buildings often set limits on both. A verbal yes from a landlord tends to vanish when the property changes hands. What a landlord may restrict differs from place to place, so it is the buyer's job to check their own lease and local rules, and no written permission is a fair reason to hold the puppy back.
What kind of home is it: a house or an apartment, which floor, and how close are the neighbors?
Why ask it
An apartment suits plenty of dogs, so do not treat the word as an answer. Match the details to your breed: three flights of stairs for a heavy puppy, a shared wall for a dog that barks, no elevator for one that will weigh more than its owner can carry. Ask how they picture the first toilet trip at six in the morning.
Is there a yard, is it fenced all the way around, and how high is the fence?
Why ask it
Ask for a photo of the fence line and the gate. You know what your dogs do: some clear a four-foot fence, some dig under, and a small puppy fits through railings an adult would not. Tell them what yours need and see whether they offer to fix it.
If the yard is not fenced, how will the puppy get out for toilet breaks and exercise each day, including in bad weather?
Why ask it
Skip this if the yard is secure. Otherwise you want a routine with times in it: leash trips, a long line, a nearby park. A plan to let the dog out loose, or to leave it on a tie-out while everyone is at work, is one to turn down.
Where will the puppy sleep at night, and where will it stay when nobody is home?
Why ask it
A crate beside the bed and a pen in the kitchen mean someone has pictured the first week. If the answer is the garage, a shed or the yard, and you raised this litter in your living room, say so plainly. Some buyers change the plan once they hear how the puppies have lived, and some show you they will not.
Is there a pool, a pond, a balcony or a busy road close to the house, and how will you keep a puppy away from it?
Why ask it
Buyers rarely think of these until asked. A pool cover or fence, a blocked balcony rail and a gate latch that actually closes are small jobs to do before pickup day. Ask for a photo once the work is done, the same as you would for the fence.
Have you checked the rules at your address, such as a homeowners association, a building pet policy, your home insurance, or a local limit on breeds or the number of dogs?
Why ask it
You cannot know the rules at their address, and they vary from one street to the next. All you need is a yes, and ideally which documents they read. For breeds that insurers and cities single out, ask them to confirm in an email so nobody is surprised after the sale.
Are you likely to move in the next couple of years, and what happens to the dog if the next place does not take pets?
Why ask it
Ask this even of homeowners, because the dog that fit the old address may not fit the next one. The answer to hope for is that a home that refuses the dog is not a home they would take. Military families, students and people on short leases can be excellent owners, but they should have thought about this already.
May I visit your home, or have you walk me through it on a video call, before the puppy leaves?
Why ask it
Explain that you are looking at the fence, the stairs and where the pen will go, not at the housekeeping. Most serious buyers say yes at once, and a phone camera does the job when the drive is too long. If you do go in person, take someone with you. If they refuse any look at all, weigh that with everything else they have told you.
Daily life
Can you walk me through an ordinary weekday in your house, from the first alarm to lights out?
Why ask it
Asked this way, people describe their real day instead of guessing at the answer you want. Add up the hours when the house is empty and note who is home first. It also tells you whether this is a quiet household or a loud one, which helps you pick the puppy.
On a workday, how many hours would the puppy be alone, and who can come by in the middle of the day?
Why ask it
A young puppy cannot hold on for a full working day, so a long absence needs a lunch break at home, a neighbor, a walker or daycare with a name attached. Working full time is not a reason to refuse anyone. Nine hours alone with no plan is a reason to say not yet, and to invite them back when they have one.
Which adult will be the main one feeding, walking and training the puppy?
Why ask it
You want one name. When a parent says the children have promised to do it all, say kindly that the promise usually lasts a few weeks and ask which adult takes over then. A shrug deserves more of your attention than a wrong answer would.
How old are the children in the home, or who visit often, and how much time have they spent around dogs?
Why ask it
Ages matter because a toddler and a mouthy young puppy need gates and an adult in the room, while a ten-year-old can help with training. Ask how they will separate the two when no one can supervise. If the family visits, watch the children with your adult dogs and see whether a parent steps in without being asked.
What other animals live with you, and how did they react the last time a new animal came into the house?
Why ask it
Get species, age, sex and whether each is neutered. An elderly dog with sore joints, a cat that has never met a dog, or rabbits and chickens alongside a terrier or a hound each call for a plan you can talk through. A resident dog that has fought with visiting dogs is a reason to pause until a trainer has seen it.
Which vet do your current pets see, and will you tell the clinic it is all right to speak to me?
Why ask it
A vet reference is the one answer on the form you can check with a phone call. Clinics differ on what they will share and most need the owner's say-so first, so ask the buyer to arrange it. Regular visits and current vaccinations are what you are hoping to hear about, and a first-time owner, who has no record to check, can offer a different reference: a trainer, or someone whose dog they have looked after.
How much exercise do you expect to give this dog every day once it is grown?
Why ask it
Compare their figure with what your own adults need to stay sane. If someone describes a short evening stroll for a working breed, tell them the real number and watch what happens to their face. The opposite mismatch matters too: a runner who wants a companion for long miles should not be handed a breed built for the sofa.
When you travel or get stuck late at work, who looks after your animals?
Why ask it
A named sitter, a relative nearby or a boarding kennel they have stayed with before shows a circle of help around the dog. People who say they never go away are usually forgetting weddings, hospital stays and funerals. Suggest they line someone up before the puppy arrives.
Is anyone in the household allergic to dogs, or does anyone have asthma that flares around animals?
Why ask it
Do not promise that any coat is safe for an allergic person, whatever the breed's reputation. Invite them to spend an hour indoors with your adult dogs before a deposit changes hands, and suggest they talk to their own doctor. A puppy that has to come back in its third week because someone cannot breathe is hard on everyone, so it is kinder to find out now.
Who is taking time off for the first week, and what will those days look like?
Why ask it
The first days set the house training and the nights, and they go far better with someone home. A long weekend is a reasonable minimum to suggest. If pickup is planned for the evening before a full work week, propose a different date.
Experience
Which dogs have you lived with as an adult, and where is each one now?
Why ask it
Childhood dogs were looked after by somebody else, so ask about the ones they were responsible for. 'She died at fourteen' and 'we gave him to a farm when we moved' are very different histories. For each dog, ask how long it was with them and how it left, and notice which ones they would rather skip.
Have you lived with this breed before, or spent real time around an adult one?
Why ask it
Never having owned one is no reason to refuse, but a buyer should have met a grown dog of the breed, not only puppies and pictures. The mother of your litter is the obvious place to start, and a breed club event or a local show will supply more. People who grew up with the breed often remember the settled old dog and not its first two years, so describe those years yourself.
Have you ever rehomed, surrendered or returned a pet, and what led to it?
Why ask it
One rehoming with a clear reason and some regret is ordinary life. Several, or one told as the animal's fault, is a pattern you should expect to continue. Ask what they would do differently, and whether the previous breeder or rescue was told.
What have you read or been told about the hard side of living with this breed?
Why ask it
They should be able to name something real: the shedding, the barking, the heel-nipping, the prey drive, the vet bills the breed is prone to. If nothing comes, point them to the national breed club's pages and arrange to talk again in a week. Whether they do the reading tells you as much as the first answer did.
Have you raised a dog from a young puppy, or have your dogs come to you as adults?
Why ask it
People who adopted a calm three-year-old often have no picture of the broken nights and the puddles. It is not a mark against them. Describe a normal day with the litter at this age, and if their face falls, mention any older puppy or retired adult you have.
How will you house train, and what will you do when there is a puddle on the carpet anyway?
Why ask it
Good answers involve going out often, praise in the right spot and cleaning up without fuss. If you hear rubbing a nose in it or a smack, say what you would want done instead. How they take that correction from you is a preview of how they will take advice once the puppy is theirs.
What is your plan for the weeks when the puppy bites hands and chews whatever is left on the floor?
Why ask it
Every puppy does both, so the question is about the owner's temper. Listen for swapping in a toy, shutting doors, picking up shoes and giving the puppy a nap. Talk of showing the dog who is boss, or of a child being allowed to punish it, should worry you.
Do you plan to take a puppy class or work with a trainer, and have you found one near you?
Why ask it
A named class with a start date is a plan, and 'we will probably train him ourselves' is a hope. With a large or strong-willed breed you may want a class written into your contract. Offer the names of trainers your earlier buyers have liked, if you have any.
If the dog develops a problem at a year old that you cannot solve yourselves, such as lunging at other dogs or wrecking the house when left, what would you do?
Why ask it
Adolescence is when many owners run out of patience, long after the cute stage has passed. You are hoping to hear that they would call you, their vet or a trainer, in whatever order. A buyer who cannot imagine their dog ever having a problem needs to hear about the teenage months from you now.
Money and vet care
How soon after pickup will the puppy see your vet, and is that appointment booked yet?
Why ask it
If your contract asks for a vet check within a set number of days, this is the moment to say so. An appointment already on the calendar means they have done something for this puppy beyond wanting it. For someone new to the area, registering with a clinic before pickup is a small, reasonable condition.
Have you added up what the first year costs beyond the price of the puppy?
Why ask it
Ask for their number before offering yours. Vaccinations, neutering, food, a crate, a class and, for some coats, a groomer every several weeks add up to more than most first-time owners expect, and prices differ a lot by region. Suggest they call a local clinic for its puppy price list so the figure is real.
If the dog needed emergency surgery next year, how would you cover the bill?
Why ask it
Savings, insurance and a credit line are all answers. 'That will not happen to us' is not one. You have no business asking for bank statements, but you can ask whether they have compared insurance policies and what those cover where they live.
This coat needs regular grooming. Who will do it, and have you priced a groomer?
Why ask it
Leave this out for a smooth-coated breed. For poodles and their crosses, spaniels and any coat that mats, an owner who expects two haircuts a year will end up with a shaved, sore dog. Show them the brushing you do on the mother and ask whether they would keep it up.
What are your plans for spaying or neutering, and have you read what my contract says about it?
Why ask it
The right age is something for the buyer to settle with their own vet, and advice varies with breed and size, so avoid quoting one as fact. Your part is to know whether they intend to follow the clause you sell under. If they object to it, better to hear that now than after the papers are signed.
Do you intend to breed from this dog, now or ever?
Why ask it
If you sell pets on a neuter contract or restricted registration, a yes is a stop unless you choose to have a separate, much longer conversation about breeding homes. 'Maybe one litter so the children can see it' is still a yes. How registration limits work depends on your registry, so ask them what your paperwork can and cannot do.
How do you plan to pay, and do you understand what the deposit holds and when it is returned?
Why ask it
State your terms in writing before any money moves: the amount, what it reserves and what happens if either side backs out. Be careful with anyone who offers more than the price, sends a check for too much and asks for the difference back, or wants to pay through a person you have never spoken to. Ask your bank how long a payment takes to clear for good, and hand over no puppy before then.
Contract and handover
If you could not keep this dog, at any age and for any reason, what would you do?
Why ask it
The answer you are waiting for is that they would call you first. Tell them now what your contract says, whether that is taking the dog back yourself or approving the next home. Someone who insists it could never happen has not thought about divorce, illness or a job overseas, so walk them through one.
Will you sign an agreement that the dog comes back to me instead of going to a shelter or being sold on?
Why ask it
You want a plain yes. Whether a clause like this can be enforced, and how, depends on where you and the buyer live, so have someone who knows local contract law read yours if you rely on it. Even where it is hard to enforce, it tells the buyer there is always somewhere for the dog to go.
Who has agreed to take the dog if something happens to you?
Why ask it
Ask every buyer, and listen hardest with people who live alone or are older. A named friend or relative who has actually said yes is a full answer. Do not turn anyone down on age alone: a seventy-year-old with a plan is a safer home than a thirty-year-old who has never considered it.
What would have to happen for you to decide this dog was not working out?
Why ask it
This shows where their limit sits. A serious bite is one kind of answer, and a chewed sofa, a new baby or a new partner who dislikes dogs is another. When the bar is low, say so, and ask whether a dog is the right choice this year.
Will you stay in touch, send a photo now and then, and tell me about any health problem that turns up?
Why ask it
A breeder needs to hear about hips, eyes, allergies and temperament in the puppies already sold to make decisions about the next litter. A family placing one litter simply wants to know the puppy is all right. Either way, agree how often, since a buyer who bristles at a yearly email will not phone you when things go wrong.
Can you come in person to meet the puppy and collect it, and who will come with you?
Why ask it
Meeting face to face shows you what no form does: how they hold a puppy, how they speak to it, who in the family hangs back. Be slow with anyone who wants the puppy shipped unseen, handed over in a parking lot, or collected by a third party you have not screened. If the distance is real, a long video call and a pet transport service you both agree on can stand in.
If I think a different puppy in the litter suits your household better than the one you chose, will you hear me out?
Why ask it
You have watched these puppies since the day they were born, and the buyer has seen photos and perhaps an hour of a visit. A good home listens, asks why, and often changes its mind. If they still want their first pick, tell them before pickup day whether you will sell them that puppy, so nobody arrives expecting an argument.
What would you like to ask me?
Why ask it
Save it for the end and then stop talking. Careful buyers ask about the parents' health tests, meeting the mother, what the puppies have been exposed to and what your contract covers. A buyer with no questions at all, other than the price and the pickup time, is the one to think about overnight.
How to screen puppy buyers without interrogating them
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
Before the first inquiry
Write down your stops
Decide which answers end a sale for you before anyone gets in touch: no landlord permission, a plan to breed a puppy sold as a pet, a surprise gift, a puppy left alone all day with nobody coming by. A line drawn in advance is far easier to hold than one you invent with an eager family and an envelope of cash standing in your kitchen.
Put the facts on a form
Housing, the people in the home, other pets, the vet's name and past dogs can all be collected in writing. Keep the application to a page or so. People abandon long forms, and the ones who abandon them are not always the ones you wanted to lose.
Give every applicant the same questions
One form and one call outline for everybody makes the homes comparable and stops you going easy on the person you liked in the first message. If you sell puppies regularly, ask locally whether any rules apply to what a seller may ask or refuse on, since that depends on where you are.
Say in the ad that you screen
Mention the application, the call and the return clause wherever you list the litter. Buyers who want a puppy by the weekend with no questions asked will mostly go elsewhere, which saves you the conversation.
On the call and at the visit
Ask what is already arranged
Everyone intends to walk the dog, train it and come home at lunch. Ask what exists today: the name of the walker, the date the class starts, the clinic they have registered with, who got up in the night with the last puppy. An arrangement can be checked, and an intention can only be believed.
Describe the worst of the breed yourself
Tell them about the hair, the noise, the adolescent months and the health problems the breed is prone to, in more detail than is comfortable. Buyers who lean in and ask follow-ups are the ones you want. Silence, or a quick change of subject, is information.
Watch them with your adult dogs
Bring the mother or another adult into the room before the puppies. Notice who gets down to the dog's level, who flinches, and whether a parent manages a grabbing child without being prompted. Ten minutes of this is worth a page of the application.
Keep the puppy out of the decision
Do not hand anyone a puppy until you have more or less made up your mind. It is very hard to tell a family no while their child is holding one, and they know it.
Weighing what you heard
Answers that end it
A buyer who lies about something you can check, wants the puppy as a surprise for an adult who has not been asked, plans to breed against your contract, or will keep the dog chained or shut outside alone has given you the answer. Thank them, say the litter is not a match, and do not reopen it.
Answers that mean not yet
No fence, a long workday, a lease that has not been checked and a first-time owner with no trainer are all fixable. Name the gap, say what would close it, and hold the place for a set number of days if you are willing. People who come back with the landlord's letter or a walker's name have told you a good deal about themselves.
Answers that only sound bad
An apartment, no yard, living alone, being past retirement age and never having owned a dog are each compatible with an excellent home. Look at the plan behind the fact. A retired owner in a small apartment who walks three times a day may give a dog more than a busy family with an acre.
Answers that only sound good
'We have a huge yard' says nothing about who will be out in it with the dog. 'We have always had dogs' can cover a string of animals that did not stay long. 'Money is no object' is not a budget. Ask the follow-up each time.
Where sellers go wrong
Letting the calendar decide
At ten or eleven weeks, with the litter eating more and the house upside down, the next person with cash starts to look acceptable. Keeping a puppy two more weeks costs you food and sleep. A bad placement can mean the dog coming back in a year, or never learning where it went.
Trusting the form alone
A tidy application shows that someone can fill out a form. Check at least one thing independently, the vet or the landlord's letter, and talk by voice or video before you agree to anything.
Saying no badly
Turn people down once, plainly and without a lecture: this litter is not the right match. Return any deposit as your written terms say, and promptly. Arguing your reasons point by point invites a debate that helps nobody.
Promising what you cannot know
Adult size, temperament, coat type in a cross and whether an allergic child will cope are estimates, so present them as estimates. If your contract includes a health clause, show the exact wording instead of summarizing it kindly. Buyers hold sellers to what was said at the kitchen table.