Questions to Ask a Potential Youth Pastor
These questions to ask a potential youth pastor are for the people doing the hiring: a search team, a senior pastor, or parents invited to sit in. They run in the order a search usually does, from calling and beliefs through teaching, child safety, parents and volunteers, and work on the church staff, to terms and how long the candidate means to stay. The note under each one says what a reassuring answer and a worrying one tend to sound like, and flags where the rule depends on your denomination, insurer or local law.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
Calling and beliefs
Why do you want to work with teenagers, and not in some other part of the church?
Why ask it
The strongest answers have a face in them: a leader who turned up for them at fifteen, or a student they watched change. Be a little wary of an answer that would work just as well for children's ministry or college students, since it suggests the age group was assigned and not chosen.
Tell us how you came to faith, and which adults mattered to you when you were in high school.
Why ask it
Many youth pastors are rebuilding the group they loved or repairing the one that let them down. Find out which it is, then ask for one thing they would copy from it and one they would never repeat.
What is a youth ministry for? Describe one of our students at twenty-five if it has done its job.
Why ask it
Asking about the twenty-five-year-old pushes past fun nights and full rooms to what is meant to last. Compare the picture with what your church hopes for, because a team that wants Bible depth and a candidate who wants a safe place to belong will disappoint each other.
Having read our statement of faith, which part would you teach most gladly, and which would you want to talk through with us first?
Why ask it
This only works if the candidate has had the statement for a week, so mail it with the invitation. A reservation they name themselves is healthy, and instant agreement with every line usually means a quick read. If your tradition baptizes or confirms teenagers, ask here how they would prepare a student for it.
Explain the gospel as you would to a seventh grader who came tonight only because a friend did.
Why ask it
Give them two or three minutes and let them do it, not describe how they would. Plain words and one clear picture are the test, with no assumption that the listener knows what sin or grace means. A parent on the team can say whether their own twelve-year-old would have followed it.
What made you apply here, and what have you learned so far about our church and the schools our students attend?
Why ask it
A candidate who has looked up the local schools, watched a service online or phoned someone in town is already working the way the job requires. When the answer is all about the vacancy and nothing about your students, tell them what you would like them to find out before you meet again.
What keeps your own faith alive in the weeks when every evening belongs to the youth calendar?
Why ask it
Camp season and fall kickoff eat the margin, and nobody leads teenagers well for long on old reserves. Look for something that does not depend on preparing a lesson: a friend they pray with, a morning habit, a service where they sit and are not in charge.
Teaching
Describe the last group of teenagers you led: how many, what ages, and what a normal night looked like.
Why ask it
Scale comes first: running games for two hundred as an intern is a different job from leading eight students in a living room, and your group is nearer one of those. Pin down which parts were theirs, because "we" can cover a lot.
Walk us through a lesson you gave teenagers recently. Why that passage, and what did you want them to walk out with?
Why ask it
Request the notes or a recording too. Good preparation shows in one clear point and a question written for the small groups. Three funny stories with a verse attached at the end make an entertaining night and leave very little to discuss afterwards.
If a student came every week from sixth grade to graduation, what would they have been taught by the end?
Why ask it
Youth teaching is often planned one series at a time, so a rough sketch is a fair answer. What you want is a sign that they think in years: which books of the Bible get covered, which core beliefs come around again, and whether they write lessons or adapt a bought curriculum.
How would you divide a ninety-minute youth night between games, teaching, small groups and unplanned time?
Why ask it
Ask for minutes. The split shows what they think the evening is for, and it should either resemble what your students and volunteers are used to or come with a reason for the change. Notice whether hanging around afterwards counts as part of the plan or as cleanup.
Which do you find harder to teach, middle schoolers or high school juniors, and how would you serve both here?
Why ask it
A twelve-year-old and a seventeen-year-old need different rooms, or at least different small groups, and most leaders are naturally better with one. Tell them your real numbers in each age band so the answer fits the group you have and not an imagined sixty.
A student who grew up in this church tells you they no longer think any of it is true. What do you say that night, and what happens over the next month?
Why ask it
A good first night is mostly listening, with thanks for the honesty and no rush to win. The month matters more: a coffee, a book read together, parents brought in only with the student's knowledge. Alarm or an instant apologetics lecture teaches everyone else in the group to keep their doubts quiet.
How do you teach on dating, sexuality and gender, and what do parents hear from you before that series begins?
Why ask it
Hold the answer up against your church's stated position, then listen to the tone as closely as the content. Some teenager for whom the subject is personal will be in that room, so ask how the candidate would speak to that student afterwards. Shaming language should give you pause, and so should a plan to skip the subject entirely.
Outside the weekly meeting, how does each student end up known by an adult?
Why ask it
A list of programs does not answer this. The structure is what counts: small groups that keep one leader for years, volunteers who turn up at games and recitals, some way of noticing who has been missing for three weeks.
How do you reach teenagers who have no connection to any church, and what happens the first night one walks in?
Why ask it
Events bring a crowd, and the test is the second visit: who greets a newcomer, who follows up, and how a student who cannot find Genesis gets through small group without feeling stupid. If your group is mostly church families, say so and ask what they would change first.
What have students led or run under you while you stood at the back?
Why ask it
A worship band, a service project, a small group for younger students, the welcome table. Leaders who let a sixteen-year-old do it badly the first time are building something that will outlast them, and the ones who must hold the microphone every week are building an audience.
What do you want a camp, retreat or mission trip to do that a regular youth night cannot?
Why ask it
A trip is usually the most expensive thing on the youth calendar, in money and in the leader's energy, so the reason needs to be better than tradition. Good answers name what changes when phones are put away and a leader has three days with the same six students, and what is planned for the month after everyone comes home. Ask which trip they would keep if they could run only one.
How do you get seniors ready for the year after graduation, and who keeps in touch with them once they leave?
Why ask it
Graduation is the easiest point for a church to lose track of its young people. A candidate with a plan will have practical pieces: a senior-year group, an introduction to a campus ministry or a church near the college, a text in October. If college-age ministry is someone else's job, ask whose.
How would you include a student the usual night does not suit, such as one with a disability, one who is painfully shy, or one with no ride?
Why ask it
Youth nights tend to be planned for the confident middle of the group. Adjustments they have really made count for more than goodwill: a quieter room, a buddy, a volunteer who drives a route, and a first move of asking the student and the parents what helps.
Safety
What child protection training have you completed, and when did you last renew it?
Why ask it
A real answer names the course, who ran it and the year. Which training your church needs is set by your denomination, your insurer and local law, so find that out before the interview and tell the candidate what they would have to complete before a first night with students.
Has a complaint or allegation about your conduct with a minor ever been made, at a church, school, camp or anywhere else?
Why ask it
Put it to every candidate in the same words and write down the answer. It is one check among several, alongside whatever screening and calls to former supervisors your church carries out, and what an employer may ask or obtain is not the same everywhere, so take advice from your denomination or a lawyer first. Someone suited to this work expects the question and answers it without bristling.
What rules do you keep about being alone with a student, whether in a car, an office or a home?
Why ask it
Rules they already live by are worth more than ones they would adopt if you insisted. Typical ones are a second adult within sight, meeting in public places, and a parent told before any ride. Then give them the awkward case: the last student left at the curb when a parent is forty minutes late.
How do you text, message and follow students online, and who else can see those conversations?
Why ask it
Common safeguards are group chats over private ones, a second adult or a parent copied in, church accounts, and no apps where messages disappear. Having a rule they can state without thinking matters more than which rule it is. Try the hard case on them: a student messages privately at midnight.
What do you post about students on the ministry's accounts, and what permission do you get first?
Why ask it
Photos from camp are how parents and the congregation see the work, and they are also pictures of other people's children online. Ask about signed permission, names and locations in captions, and the student whose family situation means they must never appear. Consent rules vary, so check which ones apply to your church.
A student says, "Promise you won't tell anyone," before telling you something. What do you say?
Why ask it
Child protection training generally teaches leaders to decline the promise before they hear the secret, kindly and in words a teenager can take: I can't promise that, because if you or someone else is in danger I have to get help. A candidate who would promise first and decide later will one day have to break their word to a child.
A fourteen-year-old tells you an adult is hurting them. Take us through your next twenty-four hours.
Why ask it
Strong answers stay calm, take the student seriously, write down what was said in the student's own words and report it, without investigating, confronting the adult or waiting to see. Who must report, to whom and how quickly depends on where you live, so learn the rule for your area and your denomination before you ask. Be most troubled by an answer in which the church looks into it first and decides later whether anyone outside needs to know.
A student tells you they have been thinking about hurting themselves. What do you do that night, and where does your part end?
Why ask it
Three things should be in the answer: the student is taken seriously, parents and trained help are brought in the same day in line with your policy, and the candidate knows they are not a counselor. Ask which local services and crisis numbers they would want in hand before their first week. The worrying answer is confidence that they could talk a student through it alone.
Have you ever turned down or removed a volunteer because something did not sit right? What did you do?
Why ask it
Screening adults is part of the job, and the hard cases are well-liked people with no record of anything. A good account has a process in it (an application, references, a waiting period, checks) and a willingness to disappoint an adult to protect a room of students. Find out who they told and whether the decision held.
For an overnight trip, how do you handle sleeping arrangements, drivers, medical forms and the ratio of adults to students?
Why ask it
Anyone who has run a trip carries the checklist in their head: how drivers are approved, where adults sleep, who holds medications, what a parent signs. Vague answers usually mean someone else did the planning. Your insurer and denomination may set some of this, so ask them what is required and compare.
What would you do if you saw a senior staff member or a long-trusted volunteer break one of our safety rules?
Why ask it
Rules fail at the point where the person breaking them is liked or outranks you. The answer you need is that they would say so and report it through the route your policy names. In return you owe them the obvious follow-up: who they would go to here if that person were the senior pastor.
Parents and volunteers
In an ordinary month, what do parents hear from you, and how?
Why ask it
A weekly email, a text list, a meeting each semester, the topic of the next series sent ahead. Parents forgive a great deal when they are not surprised, so ask how much notice they would get of a trip cost or a sensitive lesson. "The students pass it on" is not a system.
Tell us about a parent who was upset with you. What was it about, and where do things stand with that family now?
Why ask it
A van back an hour late, a lesson that went further than a family expected, a child who felt left out: anyone who has done the job has a story. Notice whether they phoned the parent or waited for the phone to ring, and whether they can say which part of the complaint was fair.
How do you win the trust of parents who have been raising teenagers longer than you have been leading them?
Why ask it
Humility is the right note, and so is a plan: asking parents what they see at home, turning up at school events, holding back parenting advice nobody requested. Let a parent on your team say honestly what would win them over, and see how the candidate takes it.
What part should parents play in a teenager's faith, and how does a youth ministry help without taking over?
Why ask it
Some candidates treat the youth room as the main event and home as the audience, and others the reverse. Ask what they have actually handed parents to use, such as questions for the car ride home or a class for parents of new sixth graders. Agreement in principle is easy, and the examples tell you which view they act on.
What would you teach our students about phones and what they see online, and what would you say to parents about it?
Why ask it
This is often the first thing the parents on a team want to ask, and most of them have a specific worry in mind. A useful answer has a rule for youth night itself, such as a basket at the door or phones out for the Bible app only, and something to offer parents beyond alarm. Be cautious of a firm verdict on every app with no curiosity about how your families already handle it.
A student tells you something their parents would want to know, and nobody is in danger. What do you do?
Why ask it
Think of a hidden failing grade, a relationship, doubts about faith. No single answer is right, but it should be a considered one, usually keeping the confidence while pressing the student to tell their parents and offering to be in the room. Reporting everything home is a problem, and so is siding with teenagers against their parents.
How do you serve a student whose parents have nothing to do with the church?
Why ask it
These students need rides, permission slips signed by someone hard to reach, and an introduction that does not leave the family feeling recruited. Ask whether they have visited such a home and what they said at the door. You will also learn whether outreach, for them, includes the adults.
One student keeps wrecking the night for everyone else. How do you handle it, and when do the parents hear?
Why ask it
Hope for a private word before a public one, a job that gives the student a reason to behave, and a call home that starts with something good. Ask where the line is for sending someone home, and how they treat unkindness toward another student differently from plain noise.
How do you find adult volunteers, and what do you ask of them each week?
Why ask it
Announcements from the front rarely fill a roster. Someone who has built a team asked people one at a time and can tell you who they were. A range of ages, grandparents included, is a good sign, and so is a job description clear enough that a volunteer knows when the job is done.
What does a small group leader need from you to still be doing it three years from now?
Why ask it
Students tend to stay where their leader stays, so volunteer turnover is a youth ministry problem and not only a staffing one. Good answers include training before the first night, the lesson in hand by the weekend, a check-in that is not about logistics, and summers off. Ask how many of their last team lasted more than a year.
Staff and church
How do you like to be supervised, and what did your best boss do that you would want from our senior pastor?
Why ask it
Have the senior pastor in the room for this one. Weekly meeting or open door, feedback on the spot or in writing, freedom or check-ins: mismatched habits can sour a staff relationship as surely as a difference over doctrine. The pastor should answer the same question in return.
Tell us about a time you disagreed with a senior pastor or a board decision. What did you do with the disagreement?
Why ask it
What you hope to hear is that the objection went upward and in private, and that once the decision was made they carried it out without commentary to students or parents. If they say they have never disagreed with a supervisor, ask for a small example, because there is always one.
If a parent started criticizing the senior pastor to you, what would you say?
Why ask it
It will happen, because the youth pastor is approachable and knows which families are restless. A sound reply sends the parent to the pastor directly and offers to go along. Take note of any hint that they would enjoy being confided in.
Which part of this job are you weakest at, and who covered it for you last time?
Why ask it
Speaking, organizing, one-on-one conversation and playing the fool at game time rarely live in one person. A candidate who names the gap and the volunteer who filled it has told you which helper to find before they arrive.
What would you change in your first year with our students, and what would you leave alone until you knew them?
Why ask it
People who have started somewhere new before usually change little for a semester: they learn names, keep the existing leaders and sit in on what already happens. Tell them what your students would mourn, such as the fall retreat or the Sunday breakfast, and watch whether the plan bends. Be careful with a plan that renames the group and replaces the curriculum by October, since nothing in it depends on your students.
Where should teenagers show up in the life of the whole church, apart from the youth room?
Why ask it
A youth group can turn into a separate congregation that students graduate out of. Ask what they have done about it: students reading, ushering, running the sound desk or helping in the nursery, older members invited in to tell their stories. Then say honestly how your adults would react to teenagers up front.
If attendance stayed exactly where it is for two years, how would you know whether the youth ministry was healthy?
Why ask it
Headcount is what boards ask about, so candidates learn to answer in numbers. Push for other signs: students who bring a friend, volunteers who stay, questions getting harder, graduates still in a church somewhere. Agree now on which of these you will ask about at the first annual review.
How have you managed a youth budget, and what do you do when a family cannot afford camp?
Why ask it
Find out the largest amount they have been responsible for, how receipts and fundraiser cash were handled, and who else counted the money. On camp, the good answer has a quiet scholarship route that never requires a student to ask in front of friends.
How far ahead do you publish the calendar, and what happens to the paperwork in your busiest month?
Why ask it
Ministry with teenagers runs on forms, deposits, van bookings and reminders, and plenty of gifted communicators are poor at all four. Candidates who know this about themselves will say who or what keeps them on track. Put the same question to a former supervisor, who will remember.
This role also covers some things that are not youth ministry. Which would you welcome, and which would you want to discuss?
Why ask it
List yours before asking: preaching a few Sundays, the children's program, the website, hospital visits, setting up chairs. Small churches fold a lot into the job, and resentment comes from duties discovered after the move. Put what you agree into the written description.
Terms and tenure
Why did your last role with teenagers end, and what will your supervisor there tell us when we call?
Why ask it
Saying that you will call changes the answer you get. The two accounts should match in substance, and a candidate who asks you not to contact a former church needs to give a reason you can verify some other way. Internships and volunteer posts count.
May we speak with a parent, a volunteer and a former student from the last church you served?
Why ask it
The names on an application are usually colleagues and friends. These three saw the work from the receiving end, and a former student who is now an adult can tell you what the ministry left behind. If the candidate's present church has not been told yet, settle together when the calls can happen.
A sixth grader who meets you this fall graduates in seven years. Could you see yourself here for that?
Why ask it
No honest candidate can promise seven years, and you can say so as you ask. The question is there to put a real child's timeline in front of both of you. Look at how long each earlier post lasted, and if several were short, ask for the plain reason behind each.
Where do you hope this work leads: a lifetime with teenagers, a senior pastorate, something else?
Why ask it
Any of these can suit you, but they are different hires. Someone heading for a pulpit may want preaching time and a new title within a few years, and it is kinder to both sides to hear that before the offer than at the second review.
What does a week you could keep up for years look like, and which evenings and days would you need protected?
Why ask it
Youth work happens when other people are off, so a day off has to be named and defended by the church and not only by the candidate. Get rough numbers: evenings out per week, weekends away per year. Compare them with what your last youth pastor actually worked, if anyone knows.
What do you need to know about pay, hours and expenses before you could say yes?
Why ask it
Come with your range and state it, along with whether the post is full time and how camp weeks and retreats are counted. Cover what is reimbursed: mileage, a phone, books and training. Pay, benefits and tax treatment for church staff are not the same in every country, denomination or congregation, so have whoever handles your payroll confirm the details and put the result in writing.
What do you want to know about our teenagers, our parents and the person who had this job before you?
Why ask it
Answer truthfully, including why the last youth pastor left and how many students really come. Pay attention to what they ask first, and count it in their favor if they want an hour with a few students and volunteers before deciding.
Interviewing a youth pastor candidate
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
Before you interview anyone
Write down what the job is
Settle the hours, the age range (middle school, high school or both), who supervises the role and what else is folded into it. A candidate cannot answer well about a job the team has not defined, and two team members picturing different jobs will hear the same answer differently.
Decide who is in the room
The senior pastor, two parents of current students and one long-serving volunteer leader make a workable team. Older students should meet a finalist too, over pizza and not across an interview table, and what they noticed afterwards deserves a hearing.
Send your documents ahead
The statement of faith, the child protection policy, the job description and last year's youth calendar should reach the candidate a week before. Several questions on this page assume they have read them, and what they ask about the documents is an early look at how they prepare.
Find out your own rules first
Background checks, required training and the duty to report harm to a child are set by your denomination, your insurer and local law, and they are not the same everywhere. Phone the denominational office or your insurer and ask how each works for your church. A team that knows its own rules can tell a careful answer from a merely confident one.
Four meetings, and what each is for
A first call by phone or video
Six or seven questions from Calling and beliefs and from Teaching fill forty minutes. All you are deciding is whether to spend a full day with this person, so ask about the last group they led and have them explain the gospel to a seventh grader.
The long interview in person
Safety, Parents and volunteers, and Staff and church belong here. Let one team member own each group, ideally the person with most at stake in it: a parent for the parent questions, the senior pastor for the staff ones. Whoever takes Safety reads those questions as written, to every candidate.
A night with your students
Have a finalist teach a lesson or lead an ordinary youth night, with your regular leaders present throughout. Watch the twenty minutes before and after the talk more than the talk itself: who they walk toward, whether they learn names, what they do with the student standing alone.
A last meeting about terms
Keep Terms and tenure for a smaller meeting with the senior pastor and whoever handles pay. Bring the salary range, the written job description and the days off in draft, so the conversation ends with something both sides can read.
Screening for a job with minors
Finish the screening before the offer is final
Whatever screening your denomination, insurer and local law require for adults who work with minors applies to this hire before any other. Which checks exist and who may request them depends on where you are, so ask, and make any offer conditional on the results.
Phone every former church yourself
Reach the supervisor, and not only the friend named on the application. Ask plainly whether there were ever concerns about conduct with students and whether they would hire the person again. A church that will confirm only dates of service has told you something too, and it is fair to ask the candidate why.
Read what is already public
Go through their social media and any ministry accounts they ran before the interview. You are looking at how they speak about students, former churches and people they disagree with, and at whether the photos of teenagers look like they were posted with care.
No shortcuts for people you know
The intern everyone loves, the elder's nephew and the volunteer of ten years get the same questions and the same checks as a stranger. Familiarity is the usual reason a step is skipped, and it is no evidence of anything.
Mistakes churches make hiring for youth
Hiring the personality
The funniest person in the room interviews well and is good at game time. The job is mostly preparation, volunteers, parents and paperwork, so weigh the answers under Parents and volunteers and Staff and church as heavily as the sample lesson.
Softening the safety questions
Teams skip them or mumble them because they feel like an accusation. Tell each candidate at the outset that everyone is asked the same things, then ask them straight. A candidate worth hiring will be glad you did.
Asking what you may not be allowed to ask
Questions about marriage plans, children, age or health can be restricted for employers, churches sometimes included, and the rules vary by country and state. Check with your denomination or a lawyer before the interview, and let the candidate raise their household if they wish to.
Rushing because fall is coming
A semester led by volunteers with a clear plan is survivable. A hire made in a hurry is much harder to undo, and it is the students who lose a leader twice.
Bringing the senior pastor in last
The two will work together every week, and the search team will not be in those meetings. If the pastor meets the candidate only to approve a decision already made, the question of how they like to be supervised has been answered by nobody.