Questions to Ask About a Roth IRA
For savers in the United States about to open, fund or convert to a Roth IRA, and for whoever they are asking: a brokerage, a bank, an advisor or the person who prepares their tax return. The list starts with whether you can contribute and whether a Roth beats a traditional IRA for you, then covers what the account holds and costs, the rules for taking money out, conversions and the backdoor route, and who inherits it. Limits and income thresholds are reset most years and Congress rewrites the rules from time to time, so the questions ask for this year's figures instead of quoting them.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
Eligibility
Does my income qualify me to contribute to a Roth IRA this year, and which income figure is the test based on?
Why ask it
The test uses a modified version of your adjusted gross income, not your salary, and the cutoffs depend on how you file and are adjusted most years. Ask for this year's thresholds and work out where a raise, a bonus or a sale of investments would leave you. If you are near the line, the person who prepares your return is a better judge than the firm opening the account.
What is the most I can put in this year, and does that limit cover all of my IRAs together?
Why ask it
One yearly cap is shared across every traditional and Roth IRA you own, so a second account at another firm does not buy a second allowance, though you can split the cap between the two types in the same year. You also cannot put in more than you earned. The dollar figure is revisited annually, so take it from the firm or the IRS website and not from an old article.
What is the deadline to contribute for a given tax year, and how do I tell you which year a deposit counts toward?
Why ask it
Contributions for a year are generally allowed up to the tax filing deadline the following spring, and an extension to file does not usually stretch that. For those few months a deposit could belong to either year, so find out how the form or app makes you choose, then read the confirmation. A deposit coded to the wrong year is slow to correct and can leave one year over the limit.
Can I contribute to a Roth IRA as well as the 401k at my job, and does one limit eat into the other?
Why ask it
The two generally have separate limits, and having a plan at work does not by itself block a Roth IRA contribution. What the workplace plan can change is whether a traditional IRA contribution would be deductible, which feeds straight into the Roth or traditional comparison. Check both points against your own plan type, because a SEP or SIMPLE plan is itself built on IRAs and has rules of its own.
What happens if I contribute and then earn too much, or put in more than the limit?
Why ask it
An excess left in the account is charged a penalty tax for every year it stays, so the fix has a deadline. The two usual fixes are a removal of the excess with its earnings and a recharacterization to a traditional IRA. Find out how this firm processes each, how long they take and what paperwork you get for your return, above all if you contribute in January on a guess about the year's income.
If my income lands in the phase-out range, how is my reduced limit worked out?
Why ask it
Between the lower and upper thresholds the allowance shrinks on a sliding scale instead of vanishing at once. Have the tax preparer run the worksheet with your real numbers, because a rough guess in either direction leaves you with an excess to remove or room you did not use.
I have no wages of my own this year. Can I still contribute, and can a working spouse fund an account for me?
Why ask it
Contributions have to be backed by earned income, which leaves out investment income, and what counts is worth checking if yours comes from self-employment or a stipend. Couples who file jointly can usually fund an account for the partner without pay from the other's earnings. That account belongs to the partner whose name is on it, whatever happens to the marriage later.
Is there a higher limit once I reach a certain age, and when does it start for me?
Why ask it
Savers aged 50 and over are currently allowed a catch-up amount on top of the standard limit, and it generally counts for the whole calendar year of that birthday, not only the months after it. Check the current figure, then raise any automatic deposit yourself, since a standing transfer will not adjust on its own.
Can a child or teenager with a job have a Roth IRA, and who controls the account?
Why ask it
A minor with earnings of their own can usually have a custodial account, opened and run by an adult, with the contribution capped by what the child actually earned. Babysitting or yard work produces no pay stub, so keep a dated log of who paid and how much. Not every firm offers these accounts, and the age at which control passes to the child is set by state law, so get that age for your state.
Roth or traditional
How is a Roth IRA taxed compared with a traditional IRA, on the way in and on the way out?
Why ask it
In outline, Roth contributions are made with money that has already been taxed and qualified withdrawals come out untaxed, while a traditional IRA can give a deduction now and taxes what comes out later. Have whoever you are asking say it back in terms of your own paycheck and your own tax return. If the explanation leans on the word 'tax-advantaged', keep going until the timing of the tax is plain.
Do I expect to pay a higher or lower tax rate when this money comes out than I pay today?
Why ask it
This is the whole Roth decision in one line: pay the tax now at today's rate or later at a rate nobody knows yet. Early in a career or in an unusually low-income year the Roth side tends to look stronger, and at peak earnings the deduction does. Treat any answer delivered with certainty as a guess about future tax law.
Would I get a deduction for a traditional IRA contribution this year, or does my workplace plan rule that out?
Why ask it
The comparison only exists if the traditional contribution would be deductible for you. Above certain incomes, people covered by a plan at work lose that deduction, and then the choice is between a Roth and a nondeductible traditional contribution, which is a much easier call. Get the answer for your filing status before weighing anything else.
If I took the traditional deduction instead, what would I actually do with the tax saved?
Why ask it
A traditional IRA only comes out ahead on paper if the tax saving is invested too. Be honest: if the refund would go on a vacation, the Roth holds more spending power for the same deposit. Nobody else can answer this one for you.
Is this money I can leave untouched for decades, or might I need it within a few years?
Why ask it
A Roth IRA is built for the long term, and earnings taken out early can be taxed and penalized even though your own contributions can come back. If the same dollars are also your emergency fund, say so, because that changes what they should be invested in. Money you already know you will spend within two years deserves a separate conversation about whether a retirement account is the place for it.
Should I capture the full match in my workplace plan before I fund a Roth IRA?
Why ask it
Money an employer adds is hard to beat, so most orderings put the match first and the IRA second. Check your plan's match formula and whether it vests before treating this as settled. Where there is no match, set the fund costs inside the plan against what you could buy in an IRA.
My plan at work has a Roth option. How is that different from a Roth IRA, and is there a reason to use both?
Why ask it
They share the tax treatment but not the rules: the workplace version has a far higher limit and no income test, while the IRA usually gives you a wider choice of investments and easier access to your own contributions. Each plan writes its own withdrawal terms, so read them in the plan's summary document instead of assuming the IRA rules carry over.
How much of my retirement savings do I want in pre-tax accounts and how much in Roth?
Why ask it
Holding both kinds gives you a choice each year in retirement about which pot to draw from, and so some control over your taxable income. An advisor should be able to show your current split and say what they are aiming for. A vague line about tax diversification with no figures attached is not a plan.
Is there a tax credit or a government match for lower and middle earners who contribute, and would I qualify?
Why ask it
A federal benefit for retirement savers on modest incomes has existed for years, and Congress has scheduled a change to how it is paid, so find out which version applies to the tax year you are contributing for. It is easy to miss because the account provider has no reason to mention it. Bring it up with whoever prepares your return.
Investments and fees
After I deposit money, is it invested automatically or does it sit in cash until I choose something?
Why ask it
A Roth IRA is a wrapper, not an investment, and at many firms a deposit lands in a cash or sweep position and stays there. Check a week after your first contribution that the money is where you meant it to be. If you have set up automatic deposits, ask whether automatic investing is a separate switch.
What can I hold in the account here: index funds, individual stocks, bonds, CDs?
Why ask it
The menu depends on where you open it. A brokerage usually offers a wide range, a bank may offer only deposit products, and an insurer or advisor platform may steer you to its own funds. If the thing you want to own is not available, open the account somewhere else.
Can I lose money in a Roth IRA, and what does the balance depend on?
Why ask it
The account promises no return of its own. The balance follows whatever is held inside it, so a stock fund can fall a long way in a bad year and a certificate of deposit earns its stated rate and no more. Have them pull up the worst calendar year of the fund they are suggesting, and note that a loss inside the account is generally not something you can claim on a tax return.
What does the account itself cost: opening, annual, inactivity, transfer and closing fees?
Why ask it
Many large brokerages charge nothing to hold an IRA, so any annual fee deserves an explanation. Ask for the fee schedule as a document instead of a verbal summary and read the lines about transfers out and account closure. Those are the ones nobody mentions on the day you open.
What do the funds I would hold charge each year, in dollars on the amount I plan to put in?
Why ask it
Fund costs come out of returns quietly and never appear as a line on a statement. Have the percentage turned into dollars on your balance, and ask whether a lower-cost fund tracking the same index is available on the platform. In an account meant to grow untaxed for decades, this is the cost that compounds.
Is there a minimum to open the account or to buy the funds, and can I set up automatic monthly contributions?
Why ask it
Some funds carry their own minimum even when the account has none, which catches people starting with a small sum. A monthly transfer spreads the yearly limit across twelve paydays and removes the spring scramble. Check that the transfer stops by itself at the limit, because an overshoot becomes an excess contribution.
If I open the account at a bank, what rate does it pay, and is it a deposit or an investment?
Why ask it
A bank IRA held in savings or certificates does not move with the market, and it earns only the rate on offer. Get the rate, the term and the penalty for moving the money before a certificate matures. With decades to go before retirement, hold that rate up against inflation before settling on a bank as the home for the account.
If you manage the account for me, what is your fee, and is it taken from inside the IRA?
Why ask it
A fee paid out of the account shrinks money that the yearly limit will not let you replace. Some firms will bill an outside account instead, so request that, and have them say what you would be getting that a single low-cost fund would not provide. On a small balance, a percentage fee and a flat fee can look very different in dollars.
Which of my investments belong in the Roth instead of my taxable or pre-tax accounts?
Why ask it
Because qualified withdrawals are tax-free, many planners prefer to hold the assets they expect to grow most in the Roth and steadier ones elsewhere. With a single account there is nothing to arrange, so skip this one until you have a second. An advisor who does this for you should be able to show your holdings by account and give the reason for each placement.
What protects the account if this firm fails, and is the coverage different for cash and for investments?
Why ask it
Bank deposits fall under FDIC insurance, credit union deposits under NCUA and brokerage holdings under SIPC, each with its own limit, and none of them covers a fall in the market. Have each thing you would hold matched to one of the three. Membership can be confirmed on the insurer's own website, which is a better source than a brochure.
If I want to move the Roth IRA to another firm later, how does the transfer work and what will it cost?
Why ask it
A transfer made directly between custodians keeps the account's tax status and involves no deadline for you. The details to get are the outgoing fee, whether your funds can move as they are or must be sold first, and how long the money is out of the market. Proprietary funds that cannot leave are worth knowing about on day one.
Withdrawals
Can I take back the amount I contributed at any time without tax or penalty?
Why ask it
Direct contributions can generally come out at any age with no tax and no penalty, which is what makes a Roth IRA more forgiving than most retirement accounts. That covers the amount you put in, not its growth. The catch is that a withdrawn contribution cannot simply be put back later beyond the normal yearly limit.
When did the five-year clock on my earnings start, and does a second Roth IRA restart it?
Why ask it
The clock for tax-free earnings starts with the first tax year you contributed to any Roth IRA and does not reset when you open another. A contribution made in spring for the previous year can start it a year earlier. Find the date of your first contribution and write it down, because a new custodian will not know it.
What has to be true for a withdrawal of earnings to be completely tax-free?
Why ask it
Two tests apply together: the five-year clock has run, and you have reached the qualifying age, currently 59 and a half, or meet one of a short list of other conditions such as disability. Meeting one test without the other is the usual reason an expected tax-free withdrawal turns out taxable. Get the full list of conditions in writing, not from memory over the phone.
Which exceptions let me reach earnings early without the penalty, and would I still owe income tax?
Why ask it
A first home purchase, some education costs and certain medical or family events are among the exceptions, each with its own conditions and some with caps. Waiving the penalty is not the same as waiving the tax, and the answer differs by exception. Get the specifics for the one you have in mind before counting on it.
When I take money out, which dollars leave first: contributions, conversions or earnings?
Why ask it
The rules set a fixed order, with your contributions treated as coming out first, then conversions from oldest to newest, then earnings. All of your Roth IRAs are counted as one pot for this. Knowing the order tells you how much you could withdraw before any tax or penalty question arises.
Will I ever be forced to take withdrawals during my lifetime?
Why ask it
Under current rules the original owner of a Roth IRA has no required minimum distributions, unlike the owner of a traditional IRA. That is why some people plan to spend it last or to leave it to someone. An inherited account is treated differently, so raise that case separately if it is yours.
Who keeps the running total of what I have contributed and converted, and what should I keep myself?
Why ask it
Every answer about early withdrawals depends on knowing your basis, and a firm only knows what happened on its own books. Keep the yearly contribution statement the custodian sends and your own list of amounts and dates. After a move between firms, that list may be the only complete record there is.
If I take money out and want to return it, how long do I have and how often can I do that?
Why ask it
The window for putting a withdrawal back as a rollover is short, 60 days under the current rules, and the move is allowed only once in any 12 months across all of your IRAs. Miss either and the withdrawal stands, with whatever tax and penalty go with it. Have the custodian confirm both limits before treating the account as a short-term loan.
Does my state tax Roth IRA withdrawals or conversions differently from the federal rules?
Why ask it
Nearly everything you will be told about a Roth IRA is federal. States with an income tax decide for themselves how to treat a conversion, an early withdrawal and money that was contributed while you lived somewhere else. If you expect to move before retirement, put the question to a preparer who knows both states.
Conversions
If I convert money from a traditional IRA or an old 401k, how much tax will I owe, and for which year?
Why ask it
A conversion of pre-tax money is added to your income for the year it happens, on top of everything else you earn. Get the estimate in dollars at your marginal rate, with state tax included if your state has one. A large conversion can also call for an estimated payment during the year, so raise that with the preparer before the money moves.
Where will the money to pay the conversion tax come from?
Why ask it
Paying the bill from savings outside the account keeps the whole converted sum working. Having tax withheld from the conversion itself means less reaches the Roth, and for younger savers the withheld part can be treated as an early withdrawal. If the IRA is the only place the tax could come from, say so before an amount is chosen.
Would converting in smaller pieces over several years cost less than doing it all at once?
Why ask it
Spreading it out can keep each year's slice inside your current bracket instead of spilling into the next. The figure to request is the size of conversion that fills your bracket this year and no more. Years with unusually low income, such as a gap between jobs or the stretch after retiring, are the ones to look at first.
Will the extra income from a conversion raise anything else that is tied to my income?
Why ask it
Health insurance subsidies, Medicare premiums, income-driven student loan payments and college aid formulas can all look at the same figure a conversion inflates. Which ones apply depends on your age and situation, so list yours and have each checked. A conversion that looks cheap on the tax table can be expensive once these are counted.
Once a conversion is done, can it be reversed?
Why ask it
Under current federal rules a conversion cannot be undone, even if the market falls the week after or your income turns out higher than planned. Confirm that is still the case, then size the conversion as if there were no way back. It is one reason some people wait until late in the year, when their income is easier to see.
Does each conversion have its own five-year wait before I can touch it without a penalty?
Why ask it
Converted money carries a separate clock per conversion, and taking it out early while you are under the age the rules set can trigger the early withdrawal penalty even though the tax was already paid. Anyone planning to live on conversions before that age needs the date of each one laid out in a row.
Can my old workplace plan be rolled straight into a Roth IRA, and will it go as a direct transfer?
Why ask it
A direct transfer between the plan and the new custodian avoids the withholding and the deadline that come with a check made out to you. Pre-tax money moved this way is a conversion and taxable; Roth money from the plan generally is not. Have the old plan tell you how much of each type you hold before you fill in any form.
My income is too high to contribute directly. How does the backdoor route work, and do you handle it often?
Why ask it
The usual version is a nondeductible contribution to a traditional IRA followed by a conversion to the Roth. The steps are permitted under current law, proposals to close the route have come up in Congress before, and the result depends on the tax reporting being done correctly. Find out how long money must sit before it can be converted on the firm's platform, and whether your preparer has filed returns for this before.
I already have pre-tax money in other IRAs. How does the pro-rata rule change the tax on a backdoor contribution?
Why ask it
The tax calculation looks at all of your traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRA balances together at year end, not only the account you converted. With a large pre-tax balance elsewhere, most of a small conversion becomes taxable. Moving that pre-tax money into a workplace plan that accepts roll-ins is the common way around it, so check whether yours does.
Which tax forms will a conversion or a nondeductible contribution generate, and which ones do I have to file myself?
Why ask it
The custodian reports the money leaving and arriving, but the form that tracks your after-tax basis, Form 8606 at present, is filed by you with your return. Skipping it is how people end up taxed twice on the same dollars years later. Keep a copy from every year you make one of these moves.
Beneficiaries
How do I name primary and contingent beneficiaries, and how do I change them later?
Why ask it
Fill in both levels when you open the account, while the form is in front of you: the contingent is who inherits if the primary has died before you. Find out how a change is made, whether it takes effect at once and how it is confirmed to you. Marriage, divorce, a birth and a death in the family are the four moments to look at it again.
Does the beneficiary form override my will, and what happens if I leave it blank?
Why ask it
Retirement accounts generally pass by the form on file with the custodian, not by the will, so an old form can send the money to the wrong person. With no one named, the firm's default rules decide, and those often send it through your estate. The default wording sits in the account agreement and is worth reading once.
What could my spouse do with the account that a child or another heir could not?
Why ask it
A surviving spouse usually has the widest choices, including treating the account as their own. Other heirs typically get an inherited account with a deadline attached. Have the options for each person you plan to name set out side by side, since the rules here have changed in recent years.
How quickly would a non-spouse heir have to empty the account, and would they owe tax on it?
Why ask it
Most non-spouse heirs now face a set number of years to withdraw everything, with exceptions for some groups. Whether the earnings come out tax-free depends partly on whether your own five-year clock had run. Tell your heirs what you learn, since they are the ones who will have to act on it.
If I want to name a minor child or a trust, what extra steps does that involve?
Why ask it
A child cannot take control of an inherited account directly, so someone has to be appointed to manage it, and a trust has to be written with retirement accounts in mind to avoid a faster payout. This is a question for an estate lawyer, with the custodian confirming which forms it will accept.
Does my state or my marriage limit who I can name without my spouse's consent?
Why ask it
In some states a spouse has a legal interest in retirement savings built up during the marriage, and a custodian may require a signed consent to name anyone else. Find out how it works where you live before assuming the form alone settles it. A second marriage with children from the first is the case to check most carefully.
How to get clear answers about a Roth IRA
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
Who can answer what
The brokerage or bank
The firm holding the account can tell you its fees, its investment menu, its forms and its processing times. Most will not say whether a Roth or a conversion suits you, and their phone staff are usually not allowed to. Take the Investments and fees group to them, plus the mechanics of deadlines, rollovers and transfers.
The tax preparer
Eligibility, the phase-out worksheet, the cost of a conversion, the pro-rata rule and anything your state does differently are tax questions and belong with whoever signs your return. Ask before the money moves, not the following spring when the forms arrive.
A financial advisor
An advisor is the person for how the Roth fits with everything else: the split between account types, what goes where, when to convert. Ask how they are paid first, because an advisor paid on assets has a stake in which account your money sits in.
Yourself
Several questions under Roth or traditional have no outside answer. Only you know whether you would invest a tax refund, how steady your income is and when you might need the money. Write your answers down before the meeting so the conversation starts from them.
What to have in front of you
Last year's tax return
It shows your filing status and the income figure the eligibility test starts from. With the return on the table, whether you qualify gets a real answer in a minute instead of a description of the rules.
A balance for every IRA you own
Include SEP and SIMPLE accounts and anything left at an old firm. The combined limit, the pro-rata rule and the withdrawal order all treat your IRAs as a group, so one forgotten account can change the answer.
Your workplace plan summary
You need to know the match, whether there is a Roth option and whether the plan accepts money rolled in from an IRA. HR or the plan's website has a summary document that covers all three.
A realistic income estimate for this year
Count the bonus you expect and any investment sales you plan. Eligibility and conversion cost are both judged on the year's final figure, which you will not know for certain until December is over.
Where to start in four common situations
Opening your first one
Stick to Eligibility, then the Investments and fees questions on whether a deposit gets invested, what you can hold and what the account costs. What matters at this stage is getting the money in under the right tax year and making sure it is actually invested. The Conversions group can be skipped entirely.
Income near or above the threshold
Start with the income test and the phase-out, then go straight to the backdoor and pro-rata questions in the Conversions group. If you hold pre-tax IRA money, settle what to do with it before making a nondeductible contribution, not after.
Converting an old 401k or traditional IRA
The whole Conversions group applies. Get the tax estimate in dollars and the list of income-linked side effects before choosing an amount, and treat the decision as final once it is made.
Close to or in retirement
Withdrawals and Beneficiaries carry the most weight now. Establish when your five-year clock started, what your contribution basis is, and whether the forms on file still name the people you intend.
Slips that cost real money
Funding the account and never investing it
A deposit that sits in the cash position for years is the most common slip and the hardest to see, because the balance still shows up. Log in a week after each contribution until you trust the automatic setup.
Losing track of your basis
Without a record of contributions and conversion dates you cannot show which withdrawals are free of tax and penalty. One spreadsheet with year, amount and type is enough, kept alongside the yearly statements.
Converting with no cash for the tax
If the bill has to come out of the converted money, the conversion is smaller than it looks and may bring a penalty with it. Work out the tax first and the amount second.
Treating the beneficiary form as a one-time task
The form on file wins over what you meant. Check it after any change in the family and whenever the account moves to a new firm, because a transfer does not always carry the old designations across.