Questions to Ask Mayoral Candidates
Good questions to ask a mayoral candidate at a forum, on the doorstep or in a written questionnaire. They open with the staples (why the candidate is running, what comes first, what the office controls) and then go where a mayor's decisions land: the budget, housing and growth, public safety, streets and services, and who the candidate answers to. Each has a note on what a real answer sounds like and the follow-up to use when you get a slogan. City charters and state laws differ, so several notes tell you what to check about your own city first.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
The Job
Why are you running for mayor, and why this year?
Why ask it
Every candidate has this one rehearsed, which is why it is worth hearing first: the rehearsed version shows what they think the race is about. Listen for a problem they want to fix as opposed to a career they want to extend, and write it down, because the rest of the night's answers should line up with it.
What are the first three things you would do, and which of them needs a council vote?
Why ask it
Splitting the list this way exposes how much of the platform depends on other people saying yes. Follow up on who those people are and whether the candidate has spoken to any of them, since a first-year agenda with no vote counting behind it is a wish list.
What does the mayor of this city actually control, and what do you have to ask someone else for?
Why ask it
City charters differ enormously. In a strong-mayor city the office runs the departments and proposes the budget, while under a council-manager charter a hired manager does that and the mayor mostly persuades. Blurring the line usually means the candidate is new to the subject or plans to promise what the office cannot deliver.
What is the biggest problem facing this city, and what evidence put it at the top of your list?
Why ask it
The problem they pick tells you whose city they are describing: downtown's, the homeowners', the renters', the employers'. The evidence matters as much as the pick. A figure from the budget or the crime reports can be checked, while 'what I hear at the doors' depends on which doors they knocked on.
What have you run before, and how does its size compare with city hall?
Why ask it
Whatever its size, a city government is a payroll, a stack of contracts and a public that can show up at the microphone. Time on a council, in a business or at a nonprofit can all carry over, so ask how many staff and how large a budget they answered for, and what went wrong on their watch.
What is your vision for this city, and what would look different on an ordinary street by the end of your term?
Why ask it
The word vision invites a speech, which is why the second half is there. Every candidate's city is clean, safe and thriving. Only this one's has a particular repaved block, a reopened corner shop or a bus that comes more often, and those are things you can walk past and check when the term is over.
Where do you and the other candidates in this race actually disagree?
Why ask it
Forum answers tend to blur together, because everyone favors safe streets and good jobs. Asking for the disagreement makes them draw the line themselves. If all they can offer is character or experience, the policy differences may be thin, and that is worth knowing before you spend an evening comparing platforms.
How long have you lived in this city, and which part of it do you know least well?
Why ask it
Length of residence matters less than the admission in the second half. Nobody knows every neighborhood, and naming the blind spot leads straight to how they plan to fix it. Claiming to know the whole city equally is an answer too, just a less believable one.
Would being mayor be your only job, and what would you give up to do it?
Why ask it
In some cities the office is full time with a salary to match, and in others it is a part-time post beside a career, so ask how it works in yours. Then ask how many hours they expect to put in and which outside work or board seats they would drop. Whatever they intend to keep is the first place to look for conflicts.
Who would you keep from the current administration, and who would you replace?
Why ask it
Mayors govern through department heads, so an agenda with nobody named to carry it out is half an answer. Few candidates will name names from a stage. Settle for the posts they would look at first, and check whether your charter lets the mayor hire and fire those people at all.
When the council disagrees with you, what do you do?
Why ask it
Ask for a method rather than a temperament: negotiate item by item, take it public, trade votes, or let it fail and campaign against them. All four are real strategies with different costs, and the honest answer predicts how the term will feel from the outside.
What happens if the state legislature blocks something you campaigned on?
Why ask it
In the United States a state can overrule its cities on many subjects, and depending on the state that has covered rent rules, local wages, firearms and taxes. Ask which of the candidate's promises needs the state's permission and who they know in the delegation. 'We will fight it' is a posture, so ask for the fallback too.
Budget
Where does most of the city's money come from, and which of those sources worries you?
Why ask it
The first half checks basic literacy: property tax, sales tax, fees and money passed down from the state or federal government, in whatever mix your city has. The second half is where judgment shows. A source that swings with the economy, or a grant with an end date paying for permanent staff, is the kind of worry a prepared candidate will raise.
What would you cut or raise to pay for what you just proposed?
Why ask it
A spending list is easy to write and a funding list is not. Look for a named source rather than efficiency, waste, or growing the tax base, which are the three standard ways of declining to answer. If the answer is a new tax, ask who approves it and whether it needs a ballot measure.
Would you raise property taxes, the sales tax or city fees, and what would have to happen first?
Why ask it
A flat no sounds firm at a forum and has to survive the first shortfall, so ask what gets cut if the pledge holds. A conditional yes is more useful when the condition is specific. Rules on who can raise which tax differ by state and charter, and a candidate should know whether voters get the final say where you live.
What does the city already owe, in bonds and in pensions, and how much room does that leave for your plans?
Why ask it
Debt payments and pension contributions come off the top before any new mayor's priorities, and in some cities they take a large share. The city's audited financial report has the figures. You are listening for whether the candidate treats them as a limit on the platform or has never looked.
If revenue came in well under the forecast in your first year, what would you protect and what would go?
Why ask it
Platforms are written for good years. A downturn question forces the ranking the campaign has avoided giving, and the order of what they protect, whether police, parks, libraries or road repair, is the real statement of priorities. 'Across-the-board cuts' means they have declined to rank.
When a company asks for a tax break to move here or stay, how would you decide, and what would it owe the city in return?
Why ask it
Incentive deals can be among the largest commitments a city makes and the least examined afterward. A careful answer includes job or investment targets in writing, repayment if they are missed, and someone outside the mayor's office doing the math. Enthusiasm for being 'open for business' with no terms attached is how cities overpay.
Which neighborhood has waited longest for its share of city spending, and what would it see in your first budget?
Why ask it
Naming one neighborhood in front of voters from all the others carries a cost, which is the reason to ask. Push for an item with a price: a repaved corridor, a rebuilt park, a library's hours restored. If the answer is that every neighborhood deserves investment, nobody was chosen.
Housing and Growth
How many homes do you want built during your term, and where would they go?
Why ask it
A number plus a location is a real position, because both halves cost something politically. Answers about supporting housing at all levels commit to nothing. Ask which neighborhoods, since the distance between a citywide zoning change and building only along the highway is where the argument lives.
What specific change to the zoning code or the permitting process would you make in year one?
Why ask it
This is where housing promises meet the mechanism. Useful answers name a step: parking minimums, approval timelines, discretionary review, height limits near transit. An answer with no step in it suggests the code has gone unread, and the code is where a housing promise either happens or does not.
What would you do for renters whose rent is rising faster than their pay, and does state law let a city do it?
Why ask it
Renters are a large part of many cities, and when few of them are in the room this goes unasked. The tools vary widely: some states allow rent rules or tenant protections and others forbid them outright. Promising one the state bans means nobody checked, and 'nothing can be done' skips over legal aid, relocation help and code enforcement.
On homelessness, what would you fund, how many people would it serve, and who would run it?
Why ask it
All three parts are needed. Programs get announced without operators and beds get counted without services attached. Ask what happens to people who decline shelter, because that answer separates approaches more honestly than any label a candidate uses for themselves.
What would you do to help a small business open or stay open here, and what does city hall make harder than it should?
Why ask it
What city hall makes hard is the part a mayor can fix without new money: licenses, inspections, sign rules, the wait for a permit. Candidates who have talked to shop owners will have a specific complaint ready. Those who answer only with 'support local business' are describing a ribbon cutting.
What should happen to the empty storefronts and half-used office buildings downtown?
Why ask it
Notice who they expect to act: the owners, a business district, the city itself. Converting offices to housing, registering or charging long-vacant property and filling ground floors with temporary tenants are all live ideas with real costs, and local law decides which are available. Having no view on vacancy leaves the middle of the city to chance.
Is there a kind of development, or a specific proposal, that you would say no to?
Why ask it
Candidates are practiced at saying what they are for. A refusal is clearer: a warehouse beside homes, a subdivision beyond the water lines, a tower in a historic district, a stadium subsidy. Whatever they name, ask what they would allow on that site instead, so the no comes with a plan.
Safety
Which crime worries people in this city most, and what would you do about it in your first year?
Why ask it
Car break-ins, shootings and shoplifting call for different responses, so an answer about crime in general has not picked one. Ask whether the worry matches the police department's own reported figures, which many cities post online, and what the plan is besides hiring. Fear and figures do not always move together, and a mayor has to answer for both.
What would you change about the police budget, and what would you expect to change as a result?
Why ask it
Ask for a direction and a number in one sentence, whether up or down. Then ask for the outcome they expect, since a budget change with no stated result cannot be checked later. Response times, clearance rates and use-of-force complaints are the measures worth naming.
What would you push for the next time the police contract is negotiated?
Why ask it
Where officers bargain collectively, much of what a city can do about discipline, overtime and staffing is written into that contract and not into policy statements. Some states do not allow police bargaining at all, so find out first whether your city has a contract and when it runs out. If it does, the bargaining position is the policy.
Which emergency calls should be answered by someone other than a police officer, and who would that be?
Why ask it
Some cities now send clinicians, medics or civilian staff to mental health crises, noise complaints and minor crashes. The candidate should say which calls, who goes, and who pays. Both 'none' and 'many' are defensible when they come with a reason.
What would you look for in a police chief, and what would cost a chief the job?
Why ask it
The mayor hires the chief in some cities and the city manager does in others, so check who makes the appointment in yours. The firing half is the sharper one. Describing the failure that would end a chief's tenure takes some thought about oversight, and not only about support.
How long does it take a fire engine or an ambulance to reach the farthest neighborhood, and what would you do about it?
Why ask it
Most departments track response times, and they can differ a good deal from one address to the next. Every fix is expensive: a new station, more crews, a different ambulance contract. If the ambulance service belongs to the county or a private firm, ask what leverage a mayor has over it.
The next flood, fire, heat wave or storm arrives in your first year. Walk me through the first forty-eight hours.
Why ask it
This is a competence question dressed as a hypothetical, so swap in the hazard your city actually gets. Look for named roles, an emergency operations center, cooling or warming shelters, and who speaks to the public. Resolve without procedure suggests the emergency plan is still unread.
Streets and Services
Which street, transit or infrastructure project would you finish, and by when?
Why ask it
Plenty of cities have a project that has been studied for years and never built. Naming one and attaching a date can be proved wrong later, which is what makes it a commitment. Ask what the holdup has been, since the answer shows whether they understand their own bureaucracy.
What is the deferred maintenance backlog on water, sewers and roads, and what is your plan for it?
Why ask it
Many cities put a figure on this, often in the capital plan, and it tends to be larger than residents expect. Knowing it is a sign of someone who reads the documents. The plan matters more than the number, because pipes and pavement quietly consume the money promised elsewhere.
Which street or intersection in this city is the most dangerous, and what would you change about it?
Why ask it
Crash records are usually public, so a prepared candidate can name the corridor. Then weigh the remedy: enforcement, a redesign that slows cars, better crossings, or another study. Redesigns draw complaints about lost lanes and parking, and you want to know now whether they would hold firm when those arrive.
How do you get around the city, and when did you last make a trip here without a car?
Why ask it
It sounds like a gotcha and works better asked with curiosity. People plan for the trips they make themselves, and to someone who only drives, bus and sidewalk complaints can stay abstract. A candid 'not in years', followed by what they intend to do about that, is a perfectly good answer.
Which city service works worst right now, and what would you fix about it first?
Why ask it
Trash pickup, permits, water billing, snow clearing, the bus: most places have one that residents grumble about. The choice tells you what the candidate hears from people. The fix tells you whether they see a staffing problem, a contract problem or a management problem, and those call for different mayors.
What would you add for teenagers and young adults in this city, and what would it replace in the budget?
Why ask it
Youth programs are an easy promise in a campaign and an easy cut in a lean year. Ask for the specific thing, such as summer jobs, later recreation center hours or a reopened library branch, and for the tradeoff. If young people are in the room, let one of them ask it.
What can the mayor's office do for the public schools here, given who actually runs them?
Why ask it
In many places a separately elected board runs the schools and the mayor has no vote, though some cities give the mayor a role, so find out which applies to you. What a mayor can usually touch sits around the school day: safe routes, after-school programs, libraries. A promise about test scores from someone with no authority over classrooms deserves a follow-up.
What is the biggest environmental risk to this city, and what would you spend to reduce it?
Why ask it
The answer changes with the map: stormwater in one city, smoke or drought in another, an old landfill or a polluted site in a third. Naming the local risk and a line in the capital plan beats a speech about the planet. Ask what gets built, since trees, drains and cooling centers are budget items before they are values.
How will residents reach your office, and what happens to a complaint after it is filed?
Why ask it
For many residents a pothole report or a missed trash pickup is the only dealing they ever have with city hall. Ask about the tracking system, the target response time, and whether the results are published. It is unglamorous work, and it is the part of the job people judge from their own front step.
Accountability
Who is funding your campaign, and is there a donation you would return?
Why ask it
Campaign contribution reports are generally public, though where they are filed depends on your city and state, so this tests candor more than it gathers information. Listen for whether they distinguish between developers, unions and firms bidding on city contracts. Then ask how they would handle a decision involving a major donor.
Do you, your family or your business own property or hold contracts that could come before the city, and how would you handle it?
Why ask it
Mayors decide on land, contracts and hiring in the town where they live and invest, so some overlap is normal. What you want is the disclosure and the rule they would follow, whether that is stepping aside from the decision or selling the interest. Ethics requirements differ by city and state, so ask which filings they have already made and where you can read them.
Who has endorsed you, and what do they want from city hall that you would refuse?
Why ask it
Endorsements from unions, business groups, developers or party committees come with hopes attached. Naming one request they would turn down shows the relationship has limits. When nothing comes to mind, the endorsers' priorities and the candidate's are probably the same list.
What has the current administration gotten right?
Why ask it
Refusing to name anything is a tell. Governing means working with people you ran against and inheriting work already in motion, and a challenger who can credit one item sounds less likely to cancel a working program for show. For an incumbent, flip it and ask what they got wrong.
Which city issue have you changed your position on, and what did it take to move you?
Why ask it
A position that moved because of a budget figure, a site visit or an argument lost to a neighbor shows how the candidate takes in information. Be wary of the change that arrived along with the campaign. If nothing has ever shifted, ask what kind of evidence could.
If a higher office opened up halfway through your term, would you run for it?
Why ask it
City hall is sometimes a stop on the way to somewhere else, and a mayor who leaves at the midpoint hands unfinished work to whoever the charter puts in the chair. Few candidates will rule out ambition, and they do not need to. A plain commitment to the full term is the part you can quote back.
How often will you take unscreened questions from residents in public, and where?
Why ask it
Access is at its peak during a campaign and tends to shrink after the swearing-in. Ask for a format and a frequency: town halls that rotate through neighborhoods, open office hours, questions at council. Get it said into a microphone, since it is one of the few promises that costs nothing and can be checked by showing up.
Which of your promises are you least sure you can keep, and what stands in the way?
Why ask it
Asked late in a forum, this occasionally produces the only unrehearsed moment of the night. The useful answer names the obstacle: a council majority, a state law, a price tag. Insisting that every promise is safe tells you the question was not taken seriously.
What will you publish so voters can check on you, and how often?
Why ask it
Accountability is a measurement question. Ask for the numbers, the location and the cadence: a dashboard, a quarterly report, an annual scorecard. Agreeing to publish figures that might embarrass them is a promise you can hold them to.
Getting a real answer out of a candidate
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
How to ask so you get an answer
One question, no preamble
Forum questions get diluted by explanation. State the question in a sentence and stop. If you attach your reasoning first, the candidate answers the reasoning and never reaches the question.
Ask for a number, a date or a name
Values questions produce values answers, and every candidate has those ready. Asking how many, by when, or who decides forces a position that can be checked afterward.
Have one follow-up ready
The first answer is prepared and the second is not. Decide in advance what you will say if they answer in generalities, usually some version of which one, or how would you pay for it.
Choose your two before you arrive
A forum gives each resident one question, and sometimes none. Pick one from the opening group and one from the subject you care most about, and write both down. If someone asks yours first, spend your turn on the follow-up instead of repeating it.
Put the same question to every candidate
Answers can only be compared when the question was identical. If the format allows, address the whole panel and ask each person for the number, the date or the name. At a door or by email you get one candidate at a time, so send the others the same wording and line the replies up.
Fit the question to the setting
At a forum you often get one sentence and no chance to reply, so use a question that asks for a number or a name. On the doorstep the candidate is in a hurry but there is no moderator, which makes it the place for a follow-up. A written questionnaire can ask for more, and it leaves an answer on paper that you can hold up after the election.
Homework that makes your questions sharper
- Read the city budget summary, especially the general fund breakdown and the capital plan. Both are usually online in a short version.
- Check whether your city is strong-mayor or council-manager, since it determines what the office can promise. The city charter or the city's own website will say.
- Find out who runs the schools, the buses and the ambulance service where you live, so your one question is not spent on something the mayor does not control.
- Look up campaign finance filings before the forum, so you can ask about a named donor. Where they are posted varies, and the city clerk or the state elections office is the usual place to start.
- Skim the last council agenda for items that were postponed. Those are the fights the next mayor inherits.
- Find the one number that matters on your block: permit times, response times, potholes filled, units approved.
- Write down what each candidate said and the date. A promise is only checkable later if someone kept the wording.
Common dodges and what they mean
- I will convene a task force: no position yet, and possibly none by election day.
- We will find efficiencies: no funding source has been named, so ask which line of the budget and how much.
- That is a county or state issue: sometimes true, so ask what they would do with the part the city does control.
- I will work with all stakeholders: a description of process standing in for an answer about outcome.
- Your problem described back to you at length: sympathy in place of a proposal, so ask what they would do about it first.