Questions to Ask NPCs in D&D
For D&D players, not the DM, whose character has reached the innkeeper, the quest giver, a suspect or a tied-up bandit and needs something better to say than 'so, any rumors?'. The 58 questions follow the people you meet in a typical adventure, in six groups: Around town, The job, Witnesses, Prisoners, Villains and Any NPC. Each one comes with a note on what a good or a worrying answer sounds like and what to do with it.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
Around town
What is everyone in town talking about this week?
Why ask it
This is the plainest way to ask your DM for the rumor list, and plenty of DMs hand it over without a roll. A useful answer names a person, a place or a date. If all you get is weather and grain prices, the innkeeper is the wrong source, so ask who in town hears everything.
Has anything strange happened around here lately?
Why ask it
Leaving 'strange' undefined lets the NPC choose, which often turns up a hook the party was not looking for. Write down the small odd detail, such as dogs that will not go near the mill, because a DM seldom mentions one by accident.
Is anyone around here looking to hire people like us?
Why ask it
It gets you a patron's name and where to find them, and how the NPC describes the work shows what your party looks like to a local: sellswords, rat catchers or trouble. Before you go, ask what that employer is like to deal with. An innkeeper's wince says more than the notice board.
Who around here would know more about this than you do, and will they talk to strangers?
Why ask it
Every NPC is also a signpost to the next one. The second half earns its place: a name that comes with a warning, like 'she sees nobody without a gift', saves you a wasted scene at her door.
Where do people around here refuse to go, and what do they say happens there?
Why ask it
You usually get a spot for the map with a story attached. Listen for whether the story is firsthand. 'My cousin went in and came back gray' is a lead, while 'they say' is color until a second person confirms it.
Who is in charge here on paper, and who do people actually listen to?
Why ask it
Two different names mean the town has a split you can use or fall into. An NPC who lowers their voice for the second name has told you who to be careful around before you have even met them.
Have other adventurers come through recently, and how did it go for them?
Why ask it
Rivals, missing predecessors and cautionary tales all come out here. If the last group took the same road and never came back, ask who hired them and what they were carrying when they left.
What is the road ahead like these days, and what would you not set out without?
Why ask it
Ask it of carters, ferrymen and stable hands, who know which bridge is out and where the toll has doubled. What they would pack is a shopping list from someone who has made the trip, and when the answer is 'a guide' or 'something silver', the DM is warning you about what lives along the way.
Is there a law or a custom here that strangers tend to break without knowing?
Why ask it
Towns in a campaign can have rules about drawn weapons, spellcasting in the street or who may enter the temple district, and they vary by setting and by DM. Hearing them from a friendly local costs nothing. Hearing them from the watch usually costs a fine or a night in a cell.
Has anyone else been asking the questions we are asking?
Why ask it
A yes means somebody is ahead of you on the same trail, so get a description and a direction. Watch the reaction as well: a barkeep who suddenly needs to polish a glass may already have been paid, or warned, to keep quiet.
Is there something you would tell us if we made it worth your while?
Why ask it
Saying outright that you will pay lets the DM name a price where there might have been a failed roll. When the price is a favor, take it seriously. Favors are side quests, and what sits behind them is usually better than what coin buys.
The job
Why hire strangers for this and not the town guard?
Why ask it
A reassuring answer is practical: the guard is stretched thin, or the problem lies outside the walls. Secrecy, hurry or 'certain people must not hear of it' suggests the job is not quite legal or not quite what it sounds like.
Who did you send before us, and what became of them?
Why ask it
When you are the second crew, the first crew's fate is the best briefing you will get. A patron who dodges either does not know or does not want you to know, and both are grounds to raise your price.
What exactly has to happen for you to call the job done?
Why ask it
Pin down whether you owe proof of a kill, a returned object or simply a problem that stops. Say it back in one sentence and wait for the nod. Vague terms are how a party ends up arguing about pay with the dragon already dead.
What do you get out of it if we succeed?
Why ask it
The reward says what the patron will pay; this says what the job is worth to them. If a title, an inheritance or a rival's ruin rides on it, you can ask for more, and you have learned whose side you just joined.
Who loses if we pull this off?
Why ask it
Here is your list of people who may try to stop you, bribe you or hire you away. 'Nobody' is the answer to distrust, since it means the patron has not thought about it or is hiding the one name you most need.
What are you leaving out because you think we would say no?
Why ask it
Ask it with a smile. A patron with little to hide tends to laugh and add one uncomfortable detail, like the smell or the previous owner. Offense or a quick change of subject proves nothing by itself, but it is a fair moment to ask the DM how the patron seems.
What does the job pay, and how much of it can we have up front?
Why ask it
Ask whether the figure is for each of you or for the whole group, since that argument is easier now than at the end. An advance also tests good faith. When coin is short, ask for a letter with the patron's name on it, which can open doors that gold will not.
How long do we have, and what happens if we are late?
Why ask it
This decides whether you can afford a rest, a detour or a shopping trip. When the answer is a specific night, a festival or a full moon, the DM has shown you a clock, so plan backward from it.
What are we likely to be facing, and how many?
Why ask it
Numbers, tracks and smells decide which spells get prepared and what gets bought before you leave. If the best the patron can do is 'something terrible', plan on a day of scouting and say so, because it changes how long the job takes.
Whatever else we find in there, who keeps it?
Why ask it
Settle salvage before there is any. A patron who waves the question away is easy to work for, and one who suddenly wants a particular chest left unopened has told you which chest matters.
If the watch stops us on the way, what do we tell them?
Why ask it
A careful patron hands over a writ or a cover story. A long pause means the job is quieter than advertised, and your next question is what the law in this town does to people caught doing it.
Witnesses
Can you walk us through what happened, from the start?
Why ask it
Let them run without interruption while one player takes notes. The open telling gives you a version to hold later answers against, and DMs like to tuck the one detail that matters into the middle of it.
When did you last see them, and how did they seem?
Why ask it
For a missing person or a victim, this fixes the last point everyone agrees on, and you build the timeline outward from it. 'Worried', 'in a hurry' or 'dressed for travel' matters as much as the hour. Put it to each person who knew them and see whose sighting is the latest.
Where were you when it happened, and who can vouch for that?
Why ask it
An alibi is a second NPC to visit, so go and ask that person separately. Stories that agree on the big points and wobble on small ones sound true. Word-for-word agreement sounds rehearsed.
What did you notice in the days before that seemed too small to mention?
Why ask it
Witnesses skip what they have decided is unimportant. A stranger at the well, a door left unlocked or a dog gone missing fills in the days before the event, which is usually where the culprit was careless.
Who do you think did it, and what makes you say so?
Why ask it
You are collecting an opinion, and the local grudges come along with it. Treat the name as a place to look and weigh the reason: 'she was seen with the key' is evidence, 'I never liked him' is not.
Who is better off now that this has happened?
Why ask it
Motive, put as a question anyone can answer. Try it on three townspeople and compare the lists. The name that only one of them leaves off can be telling, especially when it belongs to their own employer.
Has anyone told you what to say, or what to keep to yourself?
Why ask it
A frightened glance at the door counts as a yes. Pressing harder rarely helps a witness who has been leaned on; an offer of protection does, and it gives the party's kindest character a job in the scene.
What did you tell the watch, and what did you leave out?
Why ask it
People tidy their story for officials. The missing piece tends to be embarrassing more than criminal, a debt or a nap on duty, and promising you do not care about that part often frees the rest.
Who else saw it, and would they tell it the same way?
Why ask it
It adds names to your list and warns you where the accounts split. When an NPC is keen that you skip a certain person, that person is your next stop.
Can you take us to the exact spot?
Why ask it
Moving the conversation there gives the DM a reason to describe the scene and gives you a reason to search it. If the witness will not go back, find out whether they fear the place, a person, or being seen with you.
Prisoners
What is your name, and who is expecting you home?
Why ask it
Opening with a name where the captive expected a threat sets a tone that many DMs reward with a more talkative prisoner. Asking about home reminds them they have somewhere to go back to, and the answer shows whether anyone will come looking for them.
Who sent you, and what were your orders?
Why ask it
The orders are worth more than the name. 'Take the half-elf alive' and 'bring back the book' show what the enemy is after, and 'stop anyone on this road' means you were never the target. Ask how the orders reached them as well, since a messenger or a dead drop is one more link to follow.
How many of you are there, and when does the watch change?
Why ask it
Stick to things a low-ranking captive would really know: numbers, shifts, where the leader sleeps. 'Lots' can be narrowed with either-or questions, more than ten or fewer than thirty, which are also harder to lie through.
What were you promised for doing this?
Why ask it
Coin, safety, a cure, revenge. Once you know the price you know whether your party can beat it, and a captive who was paid badly is often glad to complain about the boss at length.
What would it take for you to walk away from this and not come back?
Why ask it
Treat the answer as a price list. A captive who asks for a head start is afraid of your party, one who asks for coin was only ever here for the pay, and one who wants hiding from the boss has shown you who they fear most. Offer only what the whole party is willing to deliver.
Is there a way in that your friends do not watch?
Why ask it
Side doors, sewer grates and the cook's entrance are what a low-ranking guard knows best. Check the answer against anything else you have before you trust it, and think about bringing the prisoner to the door they described: a guide who has to walk in first has less reason to lie.
What does your leader say all this is for?
Why ask it
Foot soldiers know the cover story, and it is still worth having, because it is what the villain needs people to believe. 'She says the old kings are coming back' is a thread for whoever in the party chases lore.
What did you see in there that you wish you had not?
Why ask it
This invites the captive to describe the worst thing in the dungeon, and the DM to foreshadow it. A prisoner who goes quiet or flatly refuses has still answered: something in there scares them more than you do.
Why should we believe any of that?
Why ask it
It puts the burden on the captive to offer proof: a password, a marked map, a detail you can check within the hour. If you plan to lean on truth magic or an insight check, ask your DM how those work at this table before you count on them.
Villains
What do you actually want?
Why ask it
Plenty of villains are written with a goal that is almost reasonable and a method that is not. Knowing the goal lets you look for another way to grant it or a way to take it off the table. Expect a long answer; most DMs have been waiting for someone to ask.
Why are you talking to us when you could be fighting us?
Why ask it
A villain who talks needs something: time, an audience, information, or the party alive. Work out which and a monologue becomes a negotiation. If the answer is time, stop talking.
When you have won, what does this place look like?
Why ask it
You hear the plan from the villain's side, often with steps you did not know about. Notice what they linger over. Pride marks the piece of the plan they care about most, and so the piece worth threatening.
Who were you before all this?
Why ask it
It reaches for the backstory, and a DM who wrote one will be pleased. A flash of anger or grief marks a lever you can pull later. No reaction at all suggests nothing is left to appeal to, which is worth knowing before anyone tries mercy.
Who do you answer to?
Why ask it
Mid-campaign villains are frequently somebody's lieutenant. A sneer can mean there is no one above them. A careful non-answer means there is, and that you have just met the smaller problem.
What would you give us to walk away?
Why ask it
You do not have to accept. The offer shows what the villain can spare and what they think your party wants, and a generous one means you are closer to hurting them than you realized.
Is there an ending to this where nobody else has to die?
Why ask it
It puts a peaceful way out on the table, and some DMs keep one ready. Even a flat no does a job: the whole party knows the talking is over, and nobody wonders afterward whether the fight could have been avoided.
Any NPC
What can we do for you?
Why ask it
Nearly every NPC wants something, and offering first turns a persuasion roll into a trade. Small wants, a letter delivered or a debt collected, are the cheapest way to make a friend in a new town.
What would you do in our place?
Why ask it
Asking an NPC for advice is also a polite way of asking the DM for a nudge when the party is stuck. The speaker colors the answer, so a coward says run and a zealot says burn it down, but the hint is usually in there.
How do you know that?
Why ask it
Three words that sort what an NPC saw from what they heard and what they are guessing. Save it for the one claim your plan depends on. Put to every sentence, it turns a chat into a cross-examination.
Have you seen this mark before, and where?
Why ask it
For the symbol on the dagger, the seal on the letter or the coin nobody recognizes. Show it to people whose trade would handle such things, a jeweler, a priest or a harbor clerk, before you spend a spell on it. A flinch and a fast 'no' is an answer too, so note who gave it.
What have you heard about us?
Why ask it
You find out how far the party's reputation has traveled and in what shape it arrived. A detailed answer also tells you the DM is keeping track, so past choices are following you from town to town.
How long have you lived in this town, and what brought you here?
Why ask it
Someone three months in town repeats what they have been told, and someone born here remembers what stood on the hill before the tower. The reason they came often turns a nameless shopkeeper into a retired soldier or a former smuggler, which is a contact worth a line in your notes.
What are you afraid will happen next?
Why ask it
Fear is more specific than rumor. A miller afraid of the tax collector and a miller afraid of the woods are living in two different adventures, and the answer says which one you have walked into.
What would change your mind?
Why ask it
For the NPC who has already said no: the guard at the gate, the clerk, the stubborn elder. It asks the DM what a yes costs, whether evidence, a favor or a bigger name vouching for you, and spares the table three failed rolls.
How old is this place, and who built it?
Why ask it
Ruins, bridges and oddly large temples generally have a reason behind them. An NPC who knows hands you the lore for free. If all you get is a shrug, the knowledge is lost locally and the party's next errand is a library or a sage.
What should we have asked you that we did not?
Why ask it
Save it for the end of any scene that mattered. It hands the DM a free turn to give you whatever you missed, and most will take it. If the NPC truly has nothing to add, the scene is spent and you can move on without second-guessing.
How to question NPCs as a player
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
Before your character opens their mouth
Know what you came for
Agree as a party on the one or two things you need from this NPC before the scene starts: a name, a location, a yes. Without that, a conversation with a friendly innkeeper can run twenty minutes and end with nothing in the notes.
Choose who does the talking
The character with the best Charisma is not always the right voice. A dwarf gets further with the dwarven smith, the cleric with the frightened widow, the rogue with the fence. Let the others chip in, but pick a lead so the NPC is not answering four people at once.
In character or described, both count
You do not need a voice. 'I ask her whether anyone else has been up to the mill' is a complete move, and most DMs answer it just as fully. Use the questions on this page word for word, or as a description of what your character is after.
Give before you ask
Buy the drink, pay for the room, pass on a piece of news from the road, or say truthfully who you are working for. An NPC who has received something is easier to play as warm, and the DM has a reason to say yes without a roll.
Getting more out of each answer
Open first, narrow later
Start with questions that let the NPC talk, such as 'what happened?', and close in afterward with 'was the door locked?'. Leading with the narrow question tells the NPC, and sometimes the culprit, exactly what you already suspect.
One question at a time
Three questions in one breath get one answer, usually to the easiest of the three. Ask, wait, and let a silence sit. DMs fill silences, often with more than they planned to give.
Write down every name
Names, places and prices are what you will want three sessions from now and will not remember. One player keeping a short list of who said what, and who they pointed to, does more for an investigation than any single roll.
Ask whether your character believes it
Tables handle lie detection differently. Some DMs want you to call for an insight check, some roll it in secret, and some simply tell you how the NPC seems. Ask yours 'does my character buy that?' and let them choose the method. Whatever comes back, treat it as a read on the NPC's manner and not as proof.
Check how magic changes the conversation
Charm, truth and mind-reading spells can shortcut a scene, and they can also carry consequences: an NPC may realize afterward what was done to them, and a town may have views on strangers casting at its citizens. How that plays depends on the edition and the DM, so ask before you cast.
Questioning prisoners
Settle the table's limits first
Some groups enjoy a tense interrogation and some want it over in two lines. If your table has not talked about how far such scenes go, ask out of character before you start, and keep it to offers and hard bargaining. A graphic scene is rarely what anyone came for.
Fear gets you agreement, not facts
A terrified captive tells you whatever ends the scene fastest, and many DMs play it that way on purpose. Offers the prisoner can believe, such as release, a meal, a head start or protection from their boss, produce answers you can act on.
Split them up
With two captives, question them apart and ask both the same three things. Where the answers match, you can plan on it. Where they differ, you have found the lie or the gap in what one of them knows.
Decide what happens afterward before you begin
The awkward part of taking prisoners comes after the questions. Agree as a party whether you are releasing them, handing them to the watch or taking them along, so that the promise your spokesperson makes is one the rest of you will keep.
When the NPC gives you nothing
They may not know
Not every NPC holds a clue. If a stablehand has answered two questions with shrugs, that is usually the DM telling you the information lives elsewhere. Ask who would know and move on.
Change the asker or the offer
A no to the paladin's appeal to duty can become a yes to the bard's gossip or the fighter's coin. Try one different approach, with something new on the table, before you decide the door is shut.
Say what you are after, out of character
It is fine to tell the DM plainly: 'we are trying to find out who hired the bandits; who in town might know?' Nothing is spoiled by it. The DM can point you at the scene they prepared instead of improvising a fifth shopkeeper.
Leave some people as scenery
Questioning every farmer on the road as if they were a suspect wears a table out and makes NPCs clam up. Pick the two or three people who matter in a place and let the rest sell you rope.