Questions to Ask Piano Students
For piano teachers who want better questions to ask their students, in private lessons and when leading a group workshop or masterclass. The list runs in the order a teacher needs it: a first lesson, the weekly lesson and how practice went at home, questions that get a student listening to their own playing, questions for a room of students hearing one another play, and what to ask after a performance. The note under each says what a good or a worrying answer sounds like, or what to do with it.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
First lesson
What made you want to learn piano?
Why ask it
A child who says 'my mom signed me up' needs a different first month from one who has been picking out tunes on a tablet. Neither answer is a problem. It tells you whether your first job is to teach or to give them a reason of their own to come back.
What music do you listen to when nobody else is choosing?
Why ask it
Ask for a song title or an artist, and write it down in front of them. Game and film music, a hymn from church, a grandparent's records: whatever they name, a few measures of it arranged at their level in the first month tends to get played at home without anyone asking.
If you could play one piece by this time next year, what would it be?
Why ask it
The piece they name is usually years away, and that is fine. Say honestly how far off it is, then show the first step toward it that fits in the next few months, such as its opening melody in one hand. A student with no answer may need to hear you play three short, contrasting pieces and pick one.
Have you played piano or another instrument before, and what do you remember from it?
Why ask it
Transfer students often carry a level in their head that does not match their hands, in either direction. Listen for what they remember fondly and what they dread, since both came from somewhere. If they mention exams or levels, ask which program and where they stopped, because those differ from place to place.
Can you play me something you already know, even a few notes you worked out yourself?
Why ask it
Thirty seconds of playing shows you hand shape, pulse, whether they read or play by ear, and how they react to a slip. Say something true and kind about it before anything else. If they freeze, play something simple yourself and invite them to copy one measure.
What will you practice on at home, and which room is it in?
Why ask it
You need to know whether the keys are weighted, whether there is a pedal, and whether the instrument sits beside the television. A short keyboard is workable at the start, but it changes what you assign, so plan around it. With younger students, put the same question to the parent.
When in your day could ten minutes of piano fit without a fight?
Why ask it
Practice attached to something that already happens, such as breakfast or getting home from school, tends to survive the third week. 'Whenever I have time' is the answer to worry about. Help them pick a slot before they leave and write it at the top of the assignment page.
Who at home will hear you play, and is there anyone who can sit with you?
Why ask it
For a young beginner this decides how much you can send home: a child practicing alone needs instructions they can follow without reading much. For a teenager or an adult it tells you whether they have an audience or would rather use headphones. Keep it light, and move on if the student goes quiet.
Would you rather learn a new song by copying my hands or by reading it from the page?
Why ask it
Most beginners pick copying, and a first piece taught by rote lets them go home playing something that sounds like music. A student who asks for the page may already read a little, so try a line from an easy book and see. Whichever they choose, plan a little of the other each week so that the ear and the eye grow together.
Is there anything about piano lessons that you are a little nervous about?
Why ask it
Reading notes, playing in front of people, getting in trouble for not practicing: the common fears are all things you can speak to in one sentence. A returning adult often names a former teacher. Whatever comes out, say plainly how it works in your studio so they do not spend the first month bracing for it.
If you took lessons before and stopped, what made you stop?
Why ask it
Boredom with the pieces, a schedule that got too full and a recital that went badly each call for a different plan. Take the answer as information and resist defending or criticizing the last teacher. Skip this with a true beginner.
What would make a lesson feel like a good one to you?
Why ask it
Younger children say 'if we play a game' or 'if I learn a new song', and that is a fair request to meet at least briefly each week. Adults tend to say they want to feel they got better at one thing. Ask it again after a few months, because the answer moves.
Weekly lessons
What do you want to play for me first today?
Why ask it
Their choice is a report on the week before a word has been said about practice. The piece they pick is the one that got the time, and the one they steer away from is the one to open gently later. A student who shrugs every week may need fewer pieces on the list.
How did practice go this week, and which day went best?
Why ask it
Asking for the best day gets a story where 'fine' would have ended the conversation. Listen for what made that day work, whether it was the time, the room or the piece, and build next week's plan around it.
Which part of this piece got most of your time?
Why ask it
Often it is the opening, because they started from measure one every day and ran out of minutes before the hard page. If so, number the sections and assign a different starting point for each day. If they went straight to the hard measures unprompted, tell them that was the right call.
Where did you get stuck, and what did you try before leaving it?
Why ask it
'I just kept playing it' means they have one practice tool, so this is the week to teach a second: hands separately, a slower pulse, or stopping on the trouble note. A student who tried something sensible and still got stuck has shown you exactly where to spend the lesson.
Can you show me exactly how you practiced this line at home?
Why ask it
Watching two minutes of real practice explains more than hearing the result. You will see whether they stop to fix a slip or run past it, and whether the tempo at home was ever slow enough. Make it clear you are curious and not checking up, or you will get a performance of good practice.
Was anything on your assignment page confusing once you got home?
Why ask it
If the answer is yes, the fault is usually in how it was written down, and that is useful to hear. Have the student say next week's instructions back to you, or write them in their own words. A blank look at this question can mean the page was never opened.
What did you play this week that I did not assign?
Why ask it
Tunes worked out by ear, a friend's piece, the same four chords over and over: this is where their own interest lives. Ask to hear it and take it seriously. A student who never touches the piano outside the list may be treating it purely as homework.
What got in the way of practice this week?
Why ask it
Use it on the weeks when it is obvious little happened, and ask it without an edge. A test, a tournament or a week of illness needs no fixing. If the reason is the same three weeks running, the plan does not fit their life as it is, and the two of you should change it, with the parent if the student is young.
How slowly did you take this at home, and what happened when you sped it up?
Why ask it
Most students have no number for 'slow'. Have them show you the home tempo, then find together the fastest speed at which every note is right, and write that marking on the page. If speeding up always brings back the same slip, the fingering there needs another look.
Is this still a piece you want to be playing?
Why ask it
Three or four weeks in, some pieces have gone stale and polishing will not help. Dropping one is allowed, and saying so tends to buy goodwill for the piece you do need them to finish. If they want to quit everything hard, ask what would make this one worth another two weeks.
Before you play a note of this new piece, what do you notice on the page?
Why ask it
Give them a minute with the score and no sound. A repeat, a pattern that climbs a step each time, a hand that never leaves its position, the line where the clef changes: each thing they find is one they will not have to decode at the keys. If all they see is 'a lot of notes', point to two lines that match and ask what is the same.
In your own words, what did we change in this passage today?
Why ask it
Ask it before they pack up. If they cannot say it, they will not do it on Tuesday, and you have learned that the instruction was yours alone. Let them write the sentence on the assignment page themselves, spelling and all.
When you sit down tomorrow, what is the first thing you will do with this?
Why ask it
A plan for one sitting is easier to keep than a plan for a week. A good answer names a place and a method, such as 'the left hand of line three, five times slowly'. If you hear 'play it through', ask which line comes first and how they will play it.
Listening
What did you notice in that play-through?
Why ask it
Ask before you say a word of your own, and wait longer than is comfortable. Early on you will hear 'I messed up' and nothing else; ask where, then ask what went well. Over months the answers grow more exact, and that is the skill that lets a student practice alone.
What went better that time than last time?
Why ask it
Students are quick to list faults and slow to hear improvement, so this one has to be asked on purpose. If they cannot find anything, name one specific thing yourself, such as an even left hand in the second line, so they learn what counts as better.
If we swapped seats and you were the teacher, what would you tell me to work on?
Why ask it
Play their piece back to them with one of their habits in it, exaggerated a little, and let them catch it. Children love being handed the red pen. Whatever they correct in you they have just heard in themselves, which lands more softly than being told.
Where is the loudest moment in this piece, and did it come out as the loudest?
Why ask it
Many students play the dynamics in their head and a flat medium with their hands. Have them point to the measure, play again, and judge only that. If the answer is 'I don't know', play the line back to them twice yourself, once flat and once with the peak, and ask which one was theirs.
Which hand has the tune here, and could you hear it over the other one?
Why ask it
Balance between the hands is hard to judge from the bench, since the accompaniment is usually the busier part. Try having them play the melody while you play the other hand, then swap. A student who had not realized the tune moved to the left hand has found the reason the passage sounded muddy.
What is this piece about for you: a mood, a place, a story?
Why ask it
There is no wrong answer, and the title is not the only clue. Once they have said 'a storm' or 'someone sneaking downstairs', you can ask whether the middle section sounded like it. Older students may prefer to give one word for the character, and that works as well.
I will play this phrase two ways. Which do you like better, and why?
Why ask it
Change only one thing between the two, such as where the phrase peaks or how short the staccato is, so the student has something definite to hear. Their preference matters less than their reason. If they cannot tell the versions apart, make the difference bigger and try again.
Where does this phrase end, and how would a singer show that?
Why ask it
Singing or humming the line settles it faster than talk, because a voice has to breathe somewhere. Students who play every note at one weight usually have not noticed that the music has sentences. Mark the breath in pencil once they have found it.
What happened in the beat just before that slip?
Why ask it
The mistake a student hears is often the result of something earlier: a finger that ran out, a late shift, eyes that left the page. Asking about the beat before turns 'I always mess up there' into a place to fix. Younger students may need you to play it slowly while they watch your hand, then their own.
Listening back to this recording, what do you hear that you missed while you were playing?
Why ask it
A phone on the music stand is enough. Rushing, uneven runs and a heavy left hand tend to be obvious on playback and invisible from the bench. Ask the student, or the parent of a young one, before you record, and warn them that nearly everyone dislikes the first listen.
Was that the speed you meant to take, or the speed that happened?
Why ask it
Nerves and excitement both push the tempo up, and a student may not feel it. Have them count a measure aloud before starting, or hum the fastest passage first and take the pulse from that. If they chose the fast tempo on purpose, ask whether the hardest measure can keep up with it.
Where in your hands, arms or shoulders do you feel that passage?
Why ask it
You are teaching them to notice tension before you point to it. 'My wrist gets tired on the octaves' gives you something to work with: a smaller motion, a softer dynamic, a rest. If a student reports actual pain, stop that passage for the day and suggest they have it looked at if it keeps coming back.
Workshop
What is your name, how long have you played, and which piece have you most enjoyed learning?
Why ask it
Go around the room with it before anyone plays, starting with a student you know will answer easily. One sentence each is enough. If you are a guest, it shows you the spread of ages and levels in two minutes, and the pieces named give you something to mention when each student comes to the bench.
Before you play, what can you tell us about this piece?
Why ask it
Title, composer and one sentence about why they chose it is plenty. Speaking first slows the walk to the bench and gets the performer's voice working before their hands have to. Tell students ahead of time that you will ask, so a shy one can prepare a line.
How long have you been working on this piece, and which part took the longest to learn?
Why ask it
A piece that is three weeks old and one polished for a recital call for different coaching, and the listeners should know which they are hearing. The part that took longest is often the part the student is proudest of, so say what you heard in it. With a student you do not teach, ask this before you suggest any change, since you cannot know what their own teacher has already asked for.
What would you like us to listen for?
Why ask it
It hands the performer some control over the feedback and gives the listeners a job. 'Tell me if you can hear the tune in the left hand' is ideal. If the performer has no idea, offer two choices from what you worked on in lessons.
What is one specific thing you enjoyed in that performance?
Why ask it
Make 'it was good' unacceptable from the first workshop: ask for a place in the piece and a reason. The ending, the quiet section, the way the hands crossed. Praise comes before any suggestion every time, and the performer should hear at least two before you move on.
What word would you use for the character of that piece?
Why ask it
Take one word from each listener and write them where everyone can see. When the words agree, the performer learns the mood came across. When they scatter, ask the performer which they intended, and you have the topic for the next ten minutes without having criticized anything.
Where did the music change, and how did the performer show us?
Why ask it
It directs attention to contrast: a key change, a new texture, a sudden hush. Beginners can answer with 'it got quiet', and advanced students can name what the hands did differently. If nobody noticed a change the score clearly asks for, the performer can hear that from the room's silence.
Can you raise a hand each time the opening tune comes back?
Why ask it
This is for a group of young children who cannot yet talk about what they hear but can catch it. It keeps wiggly listeners busy and teaches form without the word. Tell the performer beforehand so the hands going up do not startle them.
I asked for one change. What was different the second time?
Why ask it
Coach the performer on a single thing, have them play the passage again, and put this to the room. The listeners practice hearing detail and the performer gets proof that the change was audible. If nobody heard a difference, ask the performer to exaggerate it. That is usually the lesson.
What felt different to you that time?
Why ask it
Ask the player once the group has answered. Often they say it felt strange or too much while the room heard it as just right, and that gap is worth pointing out. Keep it short: a student on the spot can manage one sentence.
Who else has a piece with a spot like this, and what helped you with it?
Why ask it
Students take practice advice from a peer in a way they do not always take it from you. A fast left hand, a big jump, a page turn: someone in the room has met it. If the advice offered is poor, thank them and ask for a second idea before adding your own.
What did you notice before the first note and after the last one?
Why ask it
Bench height, a breath, hands in the lap, a bow that was or was not rushed. The frame around a performance is easiest to learn by watching someone else do it. Use it early in the workshop so later performers try what they just saw.
What would you like to ask the performer?
Why ask it
Children ask wonderful things: how long it took, which part is hardest, whether their hands get tired. The performer gets to be the expert for a moment. If nobody has a question, ask one yourself about how they practiced the trickiest measure.
How was playing for this group different from playing at home?
Why ask it
Put it to everyone once all have played, not to one student alone. Hearing that the confident teenager's hands also shook can reach a nervous beginner in a way an adult's reassurance does not. Follow with what each might try next time, such as a slower first measure.
What did you hear today that you want to try in your own practice this week?
Why ask it
Close the workshop with it and have each student say or write one thing. It turns an hour of listening into a line on the assignment page. Check on it at the next lesson, or students learn that the answer was only for show.
After performing
How did that feel from where you were sitting?
Why ask it
Leave it for a few minutes after they come off the stage, when most students can only hear what went wrong, and hold back your own opinion until they have answered. Their account and yours will differ. Start from theirs.
What are you proud of in that performance?
Why ask it
Some students need to be made to answer this, and 'nothing' should be met with a patient second ask. Pride in keeping going after a slip counts as much as pride in a clean run. Write the answer down and read it back before the next recital.
When something went wrong, what did you do next?
Why ask it
Recovery is the performing skill, and this names it as one. A student who kept the pulse and jumped ahead did the right thing and should be told so. One who stopped and restarted from the top needs landing points in the piece, practiced on purpose, before the next time.
What were you thinking about just before you started?
Why ask it
The answer shows what the last ten seconds looked like from inside: the first notes, the audience, nothing at all. Students who rushed the opening often report they simply wanted it over. Use it to build a short routine together, such as hearing the first measure in their head before lifting their hands.
Did the piano feel or sound different from yours, and how did you cope?
Why ask it
A heavier action, a brighter treble or a pedal that catches higher can throw students who have only ever played one instrument. If it rattled them, look for chances to play on other pianos before the next event, and ask the host whether a warm-up on the instrument is allowed, since that varies by venue.
Which part of your preparation helped most, and what would you change next time?
Why ask it
Wait a few days and ask it at the next lesson, when the performance has settled. Mock performances for family, recording themselves and starting from random measures are the usual things students credit. Whatever they name goes into the plan for the next piece from week one.
What did you hear someone else play that you would like to learn?
Why ask it
Recitals and workshops are where students find out what the piano can do beyond their own book. A named piece is a ready-made goal, even if it is two levels away. If they heard nothing they liked, ask what they would have wanted on the program.
Do you want to keep this piece in your fingers, or are you ready to let it go?
Why ask it
Some students want a piece they can sit down and play for a grandparent six months later, and keeping two or three alive is a real pleasure. Others are done the moment the applause ends. Either is fine. Ask, so the choice is theirs.
What do you want to work toward next?
Why ask it
The week after a performance is flat for many students, and a new target fills it. Offer a choice of two or three pieces if they have no idea. A student who asks for something harder than the last piece has told you the performance went well for them, whatever the slips.
How to ask piano students questions that get real answers
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
Before the lesson or workshop
Pick two or three, not the page
In a half-hour lesson, more than two or three real questions and the talk starts to crowd out the playing. Choose one from Weekly lessons to open with and one from Listening for the piece that matters most this week. The rest will keep.
Match the question to the age
A six-year-old does better with a choice ('was that loud or soft?') or with something to point at than with an open question. A teenager can take an open one but may need a long pause, or may answer more honestly on paper. Adults tend to apologize before they answer, so ask them for one sentence and tell them there is no wrong one.
Know what you would do with each answer
Before you ask, picture two different replies and what you would assign after each. If both lead to the same lesson, the question is filling time. The ones worth keeping are the ones that could change what goes on the assignment page.
If you are a guest, ask the host how it works there
When you lead a workshop or masterclass in another teacher's studio, a school or a festival, find out beforehand the ages and levels, how long each student has, whether parents will be watching, whether students expect to be stopped and coached or only to hear comments at the end, and what the rules are on recording. These differ from one place to the next, so ask and do not assume.
In the lesson
Ask before you tell
After a play-through, let the student speak first, even when you can see exactly what needs fixing. Each time they describe their own playing before hearing your view, they are practicing the listening they will need on the six days you are not there.
Wait for the answer
Count slowly to five in your head. Silence after a question is usually thinking, and a teacher who fills it teaches the student that the answer will be supplied. If nothing comes, narrow the question instead of answering it.
Ask about a measure, not the piece
'How was that?' gets 'OK'. 'How even was the left hand in the second line?' gets something you can use. Point to a place on the page and name one element: the balance, the pulse, the pedal, the ending.
Let the hands answer
Many students, and most young ones, can show what they cannot yet say. 'Play it the way you think it should sound' or 'show me the loudest measure' is still a question. Put what they showed into words for them afterwards, so the vocabulary arrives with the sound.
Write down what they say
Keep the student's own words in the assignment notebook: what they noticed, what they plan to do first tomorrow, what they were proud of. Read one back a few months later. It shows both of you how much sharper their listening has become.
Running the questions in a workshop
Set the rules for comments first
Before anyone plays, say how feedback works in this room: a specific thing you liked comes first, comments are about the playing and never the player, and suggestions for change come from the teacher. With younger groups, give sentence starters such as 'I liked' and 'I noticed'.
Give the listeners their job before the playing starts
A question asked after the performance tests memory. The same question asked beforehand gives every listener something to do while the music is happening. One question per performance is enough, and changing it for each player keeps the room awake.
One change, then play again
Pick a single thing to coach, have the performer try it, and ask the room what was different. Three corrections in front of an audience is more than most students can absorb or carry out. Anything else you noticed can wait for the private lesson.
Protect the performer
Stand near the student who has just played and cut in kindly if a listener's comment turns into criticism. A performer who is shaking does not need to answer anything: let them sit down and put the questions to the room. Put a first-timer second or third in the order, so they neither open the session nor wait through all of it.
Mix the levels on purpose
Beginners can answer on mood, loud and soft, and where the tune came back. Advanced students can answer on structure, balance and pedal. Ask the youngest first, so they are not repeating what an older student just said, and let the older ones add to it.
Mistakes to avoid
Corrections dressed up as questions
'Do you think that was the right fingering?' has one acceptable answer, and students know it. If you have a correction, make it plainly. Keep questions for the moments when you want to find out what the student heard or thinks.
Asking 'Did you practice?'
A yes-or-no question about practice invites a fib or a confession, and neither helps you teach. Ask what they did, which day went best or what got in the way. You will learn how much practice happened anyway, along with why.
Answering for them
It is easy to ask 'what did you notice?' and then say what you noticed. Students work out quickly that the question is a formality. If you catch yourself doing it, ask a smaller question and wait again.
Questioning a student who is upset
Straight after a performance that fell apart, or in a lesson that has ended in tears, questions feel like a test. Say one true, kind thing and leave the rest for next week. The After performing questions work best once the student has had time to settle.
The same words every week
'How did practice go?' asked identically at the start of every lesson becomes a greeting, and gets a greeting in return. Rotate the opening question, or let the student choose what to play first and ask from there.