Questions to Ask to Determine If Someone Is Saved
These questions to ask to determine if someone is saved are for a pastor, elder, small-group leader or friend who has to ask a person where they stand with God, and for the believer putting the same questions to themselves. The groups run in the order such a talk tends to go: openers, the person's own story, the classic assurance questions, what they understand the gospel to be, the evidence 1 John and 2 Corinthians 13:5 point to, and next steps. Nobody can see another person's heart, so use the answers to decide what to talk about next and never to pronounce a verdict.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
Openers
Would you be open to talking about where you stand with God?
Why ask it
Ask for permission before anything else, and mean it. A person who has agreed to the conversation answers the later questions honestly, and one who feels cornered says whatever ends it soonest.
When you call yourself a Christian, what do you mean by it?
Why ask it
Family, nationality, church attendance and personal faith all hide behind the same word. Take whichever meaning they give as your starting point and resist correcting it on the spot.
What was church like for you growing up, if you went at all?
Why ask it
Someone raised in the pews often has all the vocabulary and may never have been asked what is behind it, while a person with no background needs every term explained. The answer sets how much you can assume for the rest of the hour.
In your opinion, what does it take for a person to be right with God?
Why ask it
Put about people in general, it gets an unguarded answer before anything turns personal. Remember their exact words, whether 'be a good person', 'believe and do your best' or something about Christ, because the later question about what they would tell God comes back to the same ground.
How would you describe your relationship with God right now?
Why ask it
Left open on purpose so they choose the word: close, distant, complicated, nonexistent. Notice whether the answer is about someone they know or a set of duties they keep up, and ask what made them choose that word.
Has anyone asked you questions like these before, and how did that go?
Why ask it
Plenty of people were pressed at a camp or grilled by a relative, and they will hear this as round two. If it went badly, say plainly that you are not here to grade them, then slow down.
Their story
How did you become a Christian?
Why ask it
Then stay quiet and let them tell it at their own length. Pay attention to the subject of the sentences: a story that is all 'I started going' and 'I cleaned up' differs from one where God or Christ does something.
Some people can name the day they believed and some cannot. Which are you, and what tells you it is real?
Why ask it
Many people raised in believing homes have no date and no dramatic before and after. A missing date is not a missing conversion, so ask what they are trusting now and leave the calendar alone.
When you prayed that prayer or went forward, what did you understand you were doing?
Why ask it
Swap in whatever event they named: a prayer at seven, a youth camp, a confirmation class. Some understood enough and have trusted Christ ever since, and others will tell you they went because their friends did. The answer is theirs to give, so do not supply it.
Who explained the gospel to you, and what did they say?
Why ask it
What a person was told shapes what they think they responded to. 'Ask Jesus into your heart' with nothing about sin or the cross is a thin account, and hearing it explains a good deal of later confusion.
What was going on in your life when you first took this seriously?
Why ask it
A crisis, a death, a new relationship or a move often sits behind a profession of faith. That is no mark against it, but do ask whether the faith outlasted the crisis.
Were you baptized, and what did it mean to you then?
Why ask it
Churches teach different things about what baptism does, so ask what theirs taught. The thing to hear is whether baptism itself is what they are relying on, as in 'I was baptized, so yes'.
Has there been a stretch when you walked away from all of this, and what brought you back?
Why ask it
The second half matters more than the first. Someone drawn back by conviction or by missing God tells a different story from someone who returned for a spouse or out of habit, and the lost son of Luke 15 is a natural place to go next.
Assurance
If you died tonight, how sure are you that you would be with God?
Why ask it
The first of a pair that evangelists have asked together for decades. 'I hope so' is an honest answer and opens the door to the next question, and a quick 'completely sure' still needs it, because confidence says nothing yet about what it rests on.
Suppose God asked why he should let you into heaven. What would you tell him?
Why ask it
Answers tend to begin either with 'I', as in 'I have tried to be good' or 'I have always believed', or with Christ and what he did. Set it beside what they said earlier about being right with God, and hear the whole answer out before you respond to any of it.
When you feel far from God, what do you fall back on?
Why ask it
Under pressure people reach for whatever they actually trust: a prayer said years ago, a good record, a feeling, or a promise in Scripture. If the answer is a feeling, ask what happens on the days it is gone.
Do you think a person can know for certain that they are saved?
Why ask it
Some were taught that claiming certainty is presumption, and you want to know that before you go further. First John 5:13 says the letter was written so that believers may know they have eternal life, which makes it a good verse to read together here.
Have you ever doubted that you are saved, and what set it off?
Why ask it
Doubt that follows a particular sin is a different thing from doubt because nothing ever seemed to change. Do not read doubt itself as a sign either way. Believers of long standing describe whole seasons of it.
What do you make of Jesus saying that some who call him Lord will hear 'I never knew you'?
Why ask it
Matthew 7:21 to 23 is a frightening passage, so keep it for someone who professes faith and wears it lightly. Point out that the people in it appeal to their own impressive works. Leave it out entirely with an anxious person.
The gospel
How would you explain the gospel to a ten-year-old?
Why ask it
A child-sized explanation strips out borrowed phrases and shows what the person actually grasps. Check for four things: God, sin, what Christ did, and a response. Whichever is missing is the subject of your next conversation.
When people talk about being saved, what do you think a person is saved from?
Why ask it
Everyone in this conversation uses the word and hardly anyone defines it. Answers run from hell to a wasted life to 'my old habits', and Scripture speaks of being saved from sin (Matthew 1:21) and from God's wrath (Romans 5:9). A person who cannot name the danger will struggle to say why a rescuer was needed.
Who do you say Jesus is?
Why ask it
It echoes the question Jesus put to his own disciples in Matthew 16. 'A great teacher' and 'the Son of God, my Lord' are far apart, and First John makes confessing Jesus as the Christ, come in the flesh, one of its plainest tests.
Jesus is called both Savior and Lord. What does each of those words mean for you?
Why ask it
Most people have more to say about one word than the other. Ease with Savior and silence about Lord can mean forgiveness is wanted with no change of ownership, and talk of nothing but obeying can mean someone is still trying to save themselves. Ask which word they would find harder to explain to a friend.
Why did Jesus have to die?
Why ask it
'To show us how to love' and 'for my sins, in my place' are very different accounts of the cross. When the answer is 'for the sins of the world', follow with two more words: and yours?
Do you believe Jesus rose from the dead, and why does it matter?
Why ask it
A person who treats the resurrection as a metaphor or an optional extra has usually never been shown why it carries weight. Romans 10:9 sets believing that God raised him beside confessing him as Lord, and in 1 Corinthians 15 Paul calls faith empty without it.
Would you say you are a good person?
Why ask it
Most people say yes, measuring against people who are worse. Ask 'by whose standard?' and then stop. A single honest look at Romans 3:23 does more than marching someone through the commandments like a prosecutor.
What is the difference between being sorry and repenting?
Why ask it
Sorrow at being caught is one thing and turning around is another, which is the line 2 Corinthians 7:10 draws between godly grief and the worldly kind. Ask for one thing they have actually turned away from, and expect a small, specific example.
What part do your good works play in your being saved?
Why ask it
'Faith plus doing my best' is a common answer from lifelong churchgoers, so ask what happens on a day when their best is poor. Ephesians 2:8 to 10 is the passage to open together: works are named twice there, once as no part of the cause and once as what believers are made for.
What does it mean to believe in Jesus, beyond agreeing that he lived and died?
Why ask it
You are listening for trust, the difference between agreeing that a bridge will hold and walking across it. James 2:19 points out that even the demons believe God is one. Ask when they last leaned their weight on Christ for something.
What do you think Jesus meant when he told Nicodemus he must be born again?
Why ask it
John 3 was spoken to a devout, moral, religious leader, which is the point for a devout, moral, religious person. Ask whether they think of faith as something they got better at or something that was done to them.
Is Jesus one way to God or the only way?
Why ask it
Someone who says every sincere path arrives at the same place may never have looked at the claim Jesus makes in John 14:6. Read it together, ask what they make of it, and let the verse do the arguing.
Evidence
How has the way you feel about your own sin changed since you believed?
Why ask it
Ask about direction, because First John says both that no believer is sinless (1:8) and that none can settle down comfortably in sin (3:9). 'It bothers me more than it used to' is the kind of answer the letter expects. A person crushed by guilt needs 1 John 1:9 read to them slowly.
Is there anything Jesus commanded that you have decided not to do?
Why ask it
A stiff question, drawn from 1 John 2:3 and 4, and only for someone who has given you standing to ask it. Struggling and failing at obedience is the normal Christian life. A settled, defended refusal is another matter.
Do you want to be around other Christians?
Why ask it
A person hurt by a church may answer bitterly, and that is a wound, not a verdict. Ask about particular believers they love and leave the institution out of it: 1 John 3:14 makes love for fellow Christians a mark of having passed from death to life.
Do you want to read the Bible, even in the weeks when you do not manage to?
Why ask it
Appetite is the thing to ask about, never the reading record. First Peter 2:2 pictures a newborn's hunger. A believer in a dry spell usually misses it, and that missing is worth pointing out to them as encouragement.
When you pray, who does it feel like you are talking to?
Why ask it
Some people pray to a judge, some to nobody in particular, some only in emergencies. Romans 8:15 and 16 describe the Spirit moving a believer to call God Father, so that is the word to listen for. Go carefully with anyone whose own father makes it a hard one.
What do you care about now that you did not care about before?
Why ask it
New loves are harder to fake than new rules. Wanting to know God, caring about a neighbor's soul or enjoying worship all fit the new creation of 2 Corinthians 5:17. A blank look is information too, so do not fill the silence for them.
Is there someone you are refusing to forgive?
Why ask it
First John 4:20 will not let a person claim to love God while hating a brother or sister. Real believers get stuck here for years, especially after serious harm, so ask whether they want to be free of it. The wanting is what you are looking for.
Has following Christ ever cost you something, and what did you do?
Why ask it
In the parable of the soils the rocky ground receives the word with joy and gives up when trouble comes. A story about staying through a lost friendship or a mocking family carries weight. Having no such story yet tells you nothing, particularly in a young believer.
What would the people who live with you say about your faith?
Why ask it
The household sees the fruit first, and by Jesus' own picture a tree is known by its fruit. If they wince, ask what they wish those people could say. The list in Galatians 5:22 and 23 gives the two of you something concrete to talk about.
What would be hardest for you to give up if Christ asked for it?
Why ask it
The answer names the main rival for their loyalty: the rich man in Mark 10 walked away over his, and 1 John 2:15 warns against loving the world. You are asking them to notice it, not ordering them to hand it over today.
Paul told the Corinthians to examine themselves to see whether they are in the faith. When you do that, what do you find?
Why ask it
The verse is 2 Corinthians 13:5, written to a church Paul addressed as believers, so the exercise is meant to end in assurance and not in a permanent state of dread. If you are putting it to yourself, do it with Scripture open, then take what you find to someone you trust.
Next steps
Having talked this through, is there anything you feel less sure about than when we started?
Why ask it
Gives them the chance to name what the conversation stirred up before you name it for them. If they say their own confidence, ask which question did it and go back there together.
If you are not sure you are saved, would you like to be?
Why ask it
Only for someone whose earlier answers showed real uncertainty. 'Not yet' is a legitimate answer and should be met without pressure. If it is yes, go back over what trusting Christ means before anyone prays, so that whatever is said to God is understood and meant.
What is holding you back from trusting Christ today?
Why ask it
It might be a relationship, a habit, fear of family, an unanswered question or the plain cost. Each needs its own conversation, so find out which one it is before you answer any of them.
Would you read the Gospel of John or 1 John with me over the next few weeks?
Why ask it
John says his Gospel was written so that readers may believe (20:31), and his first letter so that believers may know (5:13). Pick the one that fits what you heard, then offer a day and a place, because a vague invitation rarely turns into a meeting.
Is there a pastor or an older believer you would trust to keep talking with about this?
Why ask it
One conversation with you should not be the end of it, and you may not be the right person for the next one. If they name nobody, offer to introduce them to someone and to come along to the first meeting.
May I pray for you before we finish, and what should I ask for?
Why ask it
What they request tells you where they are: assurance, faith, courage with family, or nothing at all. Keep the prayer short and in plain words, and pray for what they asked, not for the conclusion you reached.
Asking about someone's salvation without playing judge
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
What a list of questions can and cannot show
You hear a testimony, not a heart
First Samuel 16:7 says people look at the outside and the Lord looks at the heart, and 2 Timothy 2:19 says the Lord knows those who are his. Nothing on this page changes that. What you can do is hear what a person says they are trusting, see whether their life fits it, and tell them honestly what you heard. Say 'from what you have told me' and never 'you are' or 'you are not'.
Ground first, evidence second
The Assurance and gospel questions ask what a person is relying on. The Evidence questions ask whether a life is consistent with that claim. Keep them in that order. The criminal crucified beside Jesus in Luke 23 had no record of obedience to show and was promised paradise, so the tests of 1 John cannot be the ground of anyone's acceptance. They describe a family likeness that appears afterwards, sometimes slowly.
Your church's teaching comes first
Churches that all use the word saved still differ on whether salvation can be lost, on what baptism does, and on how much certainty a believer should expect. Read your own church's statement of faith before you use this page, and ask your pastor or elders how these conversations are normally handled there, especially if the answers will feed a decision about baptism or membership.
Running the conversation
Choose the setting
One person, somewhere private, with enough time that nobody is watching the clock. Do not ask these in front of a small group, a spouse or a parent, because answers bend toward the audience. When you are meeting a minor, or someone it would be unwise to meet alone, follow your church's safeguarding policy on where you meet and who else is present.
Ask a handful, not the page
Nobody should be put through the whole list. Two openers, the story, the paired Assurance questions about dying tonight and about what they would tell God, three from the gospel group and three from Evidence fill an unhurried hour. Leave out whatever their account of coming to faith has already covered.
Ask what the church words mean
Familiar phrases hide more than they show. When you hear 'I accepted Christ', 'I got saved' or 'I have always believed', ask what that involved and how they would put it to someone who had never heard the phrase. The plain-language version is the answer you are after.
Open the Bible and let them read
When an answer worries you, turn to the passage named in the note under that question, ask them to read it aloud and ask what they think it says. A conclusion someone reaches from the text holds in a way your opinion about them never will.
Four people you may be talking to
The lifelong churchgoer
Fluent, confident and quite possibly never asked. Spend the time on the Assurance pair and on the works question, and listen for a list of involvement where you expected to hear about Christ. Go slowly: decades of service deserve respect even when the footing under them is unclear.
The anxious believer
Some people ask whether they are saved every week and are not helped by harder questions. If the story and the gospel answers are sound, leave out Matthew 7 and most of the Evidence group and spend the time in the promises, such as John 6:37 and John 10:27 to 29. Fear that returns whatever they are shown may need more than a conversation: involve a pastor, and suggest they also talk with a doctor or counselor.
The child or teenager
Use their words, ask one thing at a time and keep it short. Children often say yes to please an adult, so favor open questions, such as why Jesus had to die, over anything that can be answered with a nod. Talk to the parents first, and find out what your church expects before a child is baptized.
Yourself
Write your answers down instead of circling them in your head. Start with what you are trusting, then treat the Evidence questions as a look at direction over years and not at last week. Afterwards show what you wrote to a mature Christian who knows you well. Other people usually see fruit that its owner cannot.
Mistakes that do damage
Running it as an exam
Rapid questions asked in a clipboard manner produce defensive answers and a lasting memory of being judged. Leave silences, tell some of your own story, and stop when the person is tired.
Handing out assurance yourself
'You are definitely saved' is not yours to say, and neither is the opposite. Point to what Scripture promises to everyone who trusts Christ and let the confidence come from there. Assurance borrowed from a leader's opinion tends to last until the next bad week.
Hurrying to a prayer
A prayer pressed on someone who is still unsure can become one more event for them to doubt later. Churches differ on whether to lead a person in a set prayer, so follow your own church's practice. Either way, make sure they understand what they are saying to God and want to say it, and keep meeting with them afterwards.
Passing on what you heard
What someone tells you about their soul stays with you, unless your church's process says otherwise and the person knew that before they spoke. If the conversation is part of a baptism or membership interview, say at the start who will hear the outcome. The exception is anything that suggests a person is being harmed or is in danger: your church's safeguarding policy says who has to be told, so know it before you sit down.