Questions to Ask When Renting an Apartment in NYC
For renters talking to a New York City broker, landlord or management company before applying for an apartment or signing a lease. The questions follow the order the decision usually takes: fees and qualifying, rent and stabilization, co-ops and condos, the building, the apartment itself, then signing and move-in. Each has a note on what a good or a worrying answer sounds like, and where a note touches New York's rental rules, check the current version with the city or state before relying on it.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
Fees and qualifying
Is there a broker fee on this apartment, and who pays it?
Why ask it
The rules on who pays a broker in New York City have changed in recent years, so what a friend paid on their last move is no guide. Ask for the amount, who it goes to and when it is due, by email, before you see the place. 'The owner pays' or a stated figure is a clean answer. A charge that turns up under another name after you have applied is the one to question.
Who do you represent here: the owner, the management company or me?
Why ask it
A broker who listed the apartment for the landlord and one you asked to search for you are in different positions, and that usually decides who owes the fee. A straight answer takes one sentence. If it comes back as 'I work with everyone', ask who signed an agreement with them and whether you are being asked to sign one too.
What income do you need to see for this rent?
Why ask it
Many New York landlords look for yearly income of roughly forty times the monthly rent. Ask whether roommates' incomes are added together or each person has to qualify alone, and whether savings, an offer letter or freelance income counts. Getting this on the phone costs nothing; finding out after you have applied costs the fee and a day.
If I fall short of that, will you take a guarantor, and what does the guarantor have to earn?
Why ask it
The bar for a guarantor is normally well above the tenant's, often about double, and some landlords want one who lives in or near New York. Ask both things, and whether one guarantor can stand behind a whole group of roommates. A parent who would qualify in their own city may not qualify here, and it is better to learn that before they fill in forms.
How much is the application fee, and is it charged per person?
Why ask it
New York limits what a landlord may charge an applicant, and co-op and condo buildings are often treated differently, so ask for the figure and what it pays for. A small charge covering a credit and background check is the ordinary answer. A large 'processing' or 'administrative' line deserves a question before you pay it, and the state attorney general's tenant guide is the place to check it against.
Is there a minimum credit score, and what happens if I have no US credit history?
Why ask it
Landlords here usually pull credit along with income, and the cutoff differs from owner to owner, so get the number before you pay for the check. With a thin, low or foreign file, ask what would make up for it: a guarantor, a guarantor company or extra documents. 'We look at the whole application' is fine if they can also say what settled the last borderline one.
Do you accept a guarantor company, and which ones?
Why ask it
Renters with no one to ask, such as students, new arrivals and the self-employed, sometimes pay a company to act as guarantor. Not every building takes them, and those that do often name the ones they will accept. Get the price before you treat this as the fix: the fee is usually a share of the year's rent and does not come back.
Which documents go with the application, and how soon do you need them?
Why ask it
The usual New York package is an employment letter, recent pay stubs, tax returns, bank statements and photo ID, sometimes with a reference from your current landlord. Have them as PDFs in one folder before you view anything, because a good apartment often goes to the first complete application. If you are asked for something odd, such as a login to your bank, decline and ask why it is needed.
What date is it available, and how much room is there on the lease start?
Why ask it
New York apartments tend to be listed only a few weeks before they are free, and owners usually want the lease to begin as soon as the place is empty. If your current lease runs another six weeks, say so on the first call: some landlords will meet you halfway on the start date and some will move on to the next applicant. Work out what the overlap would cost you before you agree to it.
How many applications are already in, and does the first complete one get the apartment?
Why ask it
This tells you whether you have a night to think or an hour. Real competition sounds specific: two applications in, one waiting on a guarantor. 'Lots of interest' with no detail is a sales line, and you can treat it as one.
Is a deposit taken with the application, and what happens to it if I am turned down or change my mind?
Why ask it
Some brokers ask for money to take a listing off the market while the application is reviewed. Get the refund terms in writing before you send anything, and pay in a way that leaves a record. Do not send money for an apartment you have not been inside, whoever is asking.
Rent and stabilization
Is this apartment rent stabilized?
Why ask it
A stabilized apartment has regulated increases and renewal rights, so this one answer shapes what the next several years cost. Ask it plainly and ask for the reply in writing; a stabilized lease should arrive with a rider that says so. If nobody can tell you, the state housing agency explains how a tenant requests a unit's registered rent history.
Is the rent you are quoting the legal rent, or a preferential rent below it?
Why ask it
In a stabilized unit an owner can charge less than the registered legal rent, and the lower figure is called a preferential rent. The rules for working out renewals from it have changed over the years, so ask which number your increase would be based on. Both figures should appear in the lease. If only one does, ask where the other is.
What did this apartment rent for on the last lease?
Why ask it
Where the owner is covering the broker, this is the plainest way to see whether that cost has moved into the rent: a jump well beyond what similar apartments nearby have risen deserves a 'why'. In a stabilized unit it matters more, because the increase allowed between tenants is set by rule and the registered rent history will show it. A fee is paid once, while a higher rent is paid every month and is the base for each renewal.
Is the advertised price a net effective rent, and what amount will the lease show for each month?
Why ask it
A free month spread across the year makes the listing look cheaper than the check you will write. Ask whether the free month comes off one payment or is averaged in, and which figure the income requirement is measured against. The renewal offer will be built on the higher number, so do your second-year budget with that one.
Is the building in a tax program that keeps it stabilized, and when does that end?
Why ask it
Some newer and renovated buildings are stabilized only for as long as a tax benefit lasts, and the lease rider should give the date. A leasing office that knows the year straight away is reassuring. 'I would have to check' is fine if the date then arrives by email; if it never does, read the rider yourself before you sign.
Will I be offered a one-year and a two-year lease, and what is the rent on each?
Why ask it
Stabilized tenants are normally given the choice, at different rates, and some market-rate owners will fix a second year for a set increase if you ask. Two years costs a little more now and removes one renewal negotiation. If you may leave the city within the year, the shorter lease is the safer of the two.
If this is a market-rate apartment, what increases have tenants in the building had at renewal lately?
Why ask it
With no regulation on the unit, the owner's habits are the best forecast you have. A manager who says 'a few percent most years' and can point to long-staying tenants is describing a building you can plan around. Ask as well how much warning tenants get before an increase or a non-renewal, and check that against the notice rules the state publishes.
If it is not stabilized, is this apartment covered by the good cause eviction law?
Why ask it
New York passed a good cause eviction law in 2024 that covers some market-rate apartments and exempts others, depending on things like the age of the building, how many units the owner has and the rent. A lease is meant to come with a notice saying which applies and why, so ask to see it with the lease package. Where it does apply it bears on renewals and on how large an increase can go unchallenged, and the state housing agency publishes the current terms.
Which of these does the rent cover: heat, hot water, cooking gas, electricity?
Why ask it
In many older New York buildings heat and hot water come with the rent and you pay for electricity and sometimes cooking gas. Newer buildings often heat each apartment with an electric unit under the window, which puts the winter on your own bill. If that is the setup, ask what the current tenant paid in a cold month.
Co-ops and condos
Is this a rental building, or one apartment in a co-op or condo that its owner is renting out?
Why ask it
The answer changes who approves you, how long it takes, what it costs and how long you can stay. In a rental building none of the board questions apply. In a co-op or condo, ask them before you apply, because the owner's yes is only the first of two.
Does the board have to approve me, and how long has that taken for recent renters?
Why ask it
Co-op boards commonly want a full application package and sometimes an interview, and the wait can run to weeks. Condos are usually quicker. Set the realistic timeline against the day you have to be out of your current place, and ask what happens to the money you have paid if the board says no.
What does the building itself charge on top of the owner's rent?
Why ask it
Board application fees, move-in fees and a refundable move-in deposit go to the building or its managing agent, and they can add up to a noticeable sum. Ask for the building's own fee sheet instead of the owner's memory of it. Also ask who pays if the building bills the owner a yearly charge for renting the unit out.
Is there a limit on how long the owner may rent this out, and could I renew?
Why ask it
Many co-ops cap rentals at a year or two, and an owner may plan to move back in or sell. A good answer quotes the building's policy and the owner's intentions. 'We will see next year' is a worrying one if you hope to stay, so plan on moving again unless you hear better.
The building
What is the exact address and apartment number, and whose name is on the lease as landlord?
Why ask it
With the address you can look up the building's complaints and open violations in the city housing department's online records, and read what tenants say about the owner's other buildings. Do that before the viewing so your questions are specific. A broker who will not give an exact address but wants application money is a reason to stop.
How many flights up is it, and if there is an elevator, how often was it out last year?
Why ask it
Count the stairs yourself, because a 'third floor' above a stoop and a parlor level can be four flights of climbing. Then picture groceries, laundry, a bicycle, moving day and a sprained ankle. In an elevator building with a single car, ask what happens for tenants on high floors when it is down for repairs.
Is there a super, do they live in the building, and how do I reach them?
Why ask it
A live-in super who answers texts is one of the best things a New York building can have. One person covering six buildings from another neighborhood is a different arrangement, and it shows when a toilet overflows on a Sunday. Ask how repair requests are made and who covers weekends and holidays.
Is the heat from radiators on the building's boiler, or something I control inside the apartment?
Why ask it
Older buildings often run steam radiators from one boiler, which means heat arrives on the building's schedule, the pipes knock, and some floors run hot while others stay cool. The city sets minimum indoor temperatures for the cold months. Ask how tenants report a problem, and ask someone who lives there what January is like.
Were there heat or hot water outages last winter, and how long did each one last?
Why ask it
Every boiler fails eventually, so the useful part is the length of the outage and what management did meanwhile. 'Two days in January, we brought in a temporary boiler' is a decent answer. Compare what you hear with the heat complaints listed for the address in the city's records; if the two do not match, trust the records.
What is the bedbug history for this apartment and the rest of the building over the past year?
Why ask it
A bedbug history form normally comes with a New York City lease, so ask to see it now instead of on signing day. A reassuring answer has dates, floors and what the exterminator did afterward. A flat 'never' in a big old building deserves a follow-up with a neighbor.
How often does the exterminator come, and is it for mice, roaches or both?
Why ask it
A monthly visit with a sign-up sheet in the lobby is routine in the city and counts in the building's favor. 'Only when someone complains' is the weaker answer. While you are there, look under the kitchen sink and behind the stove for droppings, traps and unsealed gaps around the pipes.
Where is the laundry: in the apartment, in the basement or down the block?
Why ask it
Washers inside the apartment are uncommon in older buildings, and many leases forbid adding one. For a basement laundry room, ask how many machines work, the hours and how you pay. With no laundry at all, walk to the nearest laundromat before you decide and see whether it offers drop-off service.
Where does the garbage sit before collection, and is it near this apartment's windows?
Why ask it
Bags and bins wait at the curb or in an areaway, and the ground-floor front apartment lives next to them. Ask what the building does about rats, and look at the spot yourself on the way out. On upper floors the question is how far you carry it: a chute, a basement room or the street.
Can tenants use the roof, yard, gym or bike room in the listing, and is there an amenity fee?
Why ask it
Photos of a roof deck do not mean you are allowed on it: some roof doors are alarmed and some yards belong to the ground-floor apartment. Newer buildings often bill a yearly amenity fee on top of the rent, sometimes whether or not you ever use the gym, so get the amount and whether it is optional. If the space is your reason for choosing the place, go and stand in it before you apply.
Is there scaffolding, facade work or other construction on this building, or anything planned for the lot next door?
Why ask it
A sidewalk shed can stay up for a long time and takes most of the daylight from the lower floors. Ask why it is there and when it is due down, and read the permit posted on it. A low building or empty lot beside your windows is worth a question too, since a new building there could close off the view or the light.
Are cats and dogs allowed in this building, and is there a pet rider with a size limit or a fee?
Why ask it
Skip it if you have no pet and do not expect one. Otherwise ask to see the rider itself, because 'pet friendly' on a listing can mean cats only, one animal, or a weight limit your dog is over. In a co-op or condo the board's rule can be stricter than the owner's, so ask whose rule you are being told.
The apartment
Does every room listed as a bedroom have a window and a door?
Why ask it
Listings stretch the word to cover windowless rooms, alcoves and living rooms with a divider. Stand in each one and check it holds a bed with the door closed. If the listing says 'flex' or 'convertible', the bedroom does not exist yet, and whether it ever can depends on the building's rule about temporary walls.
Does the building allow a temporary wall, and who has to put it up?
Why ask it
Roommates splitting a one-bedroom depend on this. Some buildings ban pressurized walls, some allow only a bookshelf partition that stops short of the ceiling, and some insist on their own contractor. Get the rule and the price in writing before you sign, along with whether the wall has to come down when you leave.
Can I put in a window air conditioner, and are there rules about brackets or which windows?
Why ask it
Many older apartments have no central air, so this matters by June. Buildings may require a bracket or professional installation, charge a seasonal fee where electricity is included, and forbid a unit in the window that opens onto the fire escape. Ask whether the current tenant's unit stays, and measure the window while you are there.
What do the bedroom windows face: the street, an air shaft or the back of the building?
Why ask it
Open the bedroom window and stand there for a full minute. A room on an air shaft is quiet and dim; one over a bar, a bus stop or an elevated train is bright and loud until late. If the broker says the block is quiet, come back on a Friday night and judge it yourself.
Is the cooking gas on in the building right now, and has it ever been shut off?
Why ask it
When a leak is found, gas to a whole building can be turned off until repairs are finished and inspected, and that can take a long time. Light a burner during the viewing. If the gas is off, ask what the landlord is providing in the meantime and get the expected date by email.
Has this apartment, the basement or the street outside flooded in a heavy rain?
Why ask it
Ask it of any basement, garden-level or ground-floor apartment, and look for a water line on the walls, a sump pump, or a neighbor's things stored up off the floor. New York leases are now meant to include a flood disclosure, so ask for it before you apply. If the answer is 'once, in that big storm', find out how high the water came and what was changed afterward.
Is there enough power in here to run an air conditioner and a microwave together?
Why ask it
Prewar wiring often means few outlets and a breaker that trips in August. Ask where the panel is, count the outlets in each room and note any that take only two prongs. A broker will rarely know the amperage, so a neighbor or the super is the better person to ask.
Signing and move-in
What exactly is due at lease signing, and in what form of payment?
Why ask it
Expect at least the first month's rent and a security deposit, plus any broker fee you agreed to. Many landlords want certified or bank checks, which take a trip to the bank, so ask for each amount and each payee name by email a few days ahead. Cash, or a transfer to someone's personal account, is a reason to pause and ask questions.
How much is the security deposit, where is it held, and when does it come back?
Why ask it
New York limits what a landlord may hold and sets a deadline for returning it, so check the figure you are quoted against the state attorney general's tenant guide. If you are asked for extra months up front because of thin credit or a job abroad, ask how that fits the current rules. A landlord who can name the bank holding deposits is usually one who handles them properly.
Which riders come with this lease, and can you send the whole package before signing day?
Why ask it
A New York lease is usually a standard form plus a stack of riders: stabilization status, bedbug history, window guards, lead paint, house rules. The surprises tend to sit in the riders, such as a ban on washing machines or a fee for a lost key. One evening to read them is a fair request, and a refusal is worth noting.
Does the lease require rugs over most of the floor, and does anyone enforce it?
Why ask it
Many city leases say a large share of the floor must be covered to keep noise down. Ask whether management has ever acted on it, and whether the neighbor above you complies. If you love the bare hardwood, this clause is the one a downstairs neighbor can hold you to.
What are the move-in rules: which days and hours, and do the movers need a certificate of insurance?
Why ask it
Larger buildings often allow moves only on weekdays in working hours and want a certificate of insurance from the moving company that names the building. Ask for the form as soon as you are approved, since movers can take days to issue it. For a walk-up, ask where a truck can stop without being ticketed.
If I have to be away for a few months or leave before the lease ends, can I sublet or hand the lease to someone else?
Why ask it
New York has its own rules on sublet and assignment requests, and a co-op or condo adds the board's rules to those, so ask for the procedure and the timeline in writing. Ask too what the landlord did the last time a tenant left early: a set fee, rent until a new tenant started, or a replacement the tenant found. Do not budget on renting the place out by the night; the city restricts short stays tightly and many leases forbid them.
If one roommate moves out mid-lease, how do we replace them?
Why ask it
With everyone on one lease, each of you usually answers for the whole rent. Ask whether a newcomer is added by an amendment, whether the group must qualify on income again, and what happens to the departing person's share of the deposit. A manager who has a form for this has done it before.
How to use these questions on a New York apartment
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
Before you see anything
Do the income arithmetic first
Divide your yearly income by forty and you have the rent many landlords will approve you for on your own. Do the same for a roommate group both ways, combined and per person. If the number falls short of the apartments you are looking at, line up a guarantor before the first viewing, not after.
Build the application folder
Employment letter, pay stubs, tax returns, bank statements and ID, saved as PDFs with clear names. Ask your guarantor for the same set. An applicant who can send everything within the hour is in a stronger position than one with a better salary and a missing document.
Settle the fee by email
Ask the first group of questions in writing when you book the viewing: the broker fee, who the broker represents, the income requirement and the application charge. The replies are your record if a figure changes later, and they tell you whether the trip is worth making.
Look the address up
Search the building in the city housing department's online records for heat complaints, pest complaints and open violations, and note the owner's name. Ten minutes of reading turns 'any problems with the building?' into 'what happened with the boiler in January?'
At the viewing
Test what you can touch
Light a burner, run the hot tap and time it, open the bedroom window, flush, flip the light switches. Count the flights on the way up and the outlets in each room. A broker's answer is useful; your own hand on the radiator valve is better.
Ask the building, not only the broker
A tenant in the hallway or the super by the mailboxes will tell you in two minutes what January is like, whether mice are a yearly visitor and how fast repairs happen. Ask one question, thank them and move on. Most New Yorkers will answer.
Walk the block both ways
Time the walk to the subway yourself, find the laundromat and the grocery store, and look at what is next door. Return after dark on a weekend if you are serious. The broker cannot answer these for you, and they decide daily life as much as the apartment does.
Pick the questions for this apartment
Nobody asks all of them at one viewing. For a walk-up in an old building, lead with heat, pests, laundry and stabilization. For a new tower, lead with net effective rent, the amenity fee, the tax program and the move-in rules. On the ground floor or below it, add flooding and where the garbage sits. For a co-op or condo, the board questions come before everything else.
Comparing two apartments
Put the first-year cost side by side
Add twelve months of the rent written on the lease, any broker fee, the building's move-in charges, a yearly amenity fee and a guarantor company's fee if you need one. An apartment with a fee and a lower rent can cost less over two years than one with no fee and a higher rent, and the sums take five minutes.
Compare the second year too
A stabilized apartment and a market-rate one at the same rent today are different bets for next year. So are a gross rent and a net effective one. Write down what each would cost after a plausible renewal before you call them equal.
Price the daily trade-offs honestly
A fifth-floor walk-up with laundry down the block is cheaper for a reason. Decide whether the saving covers a weekly drop-off service, and whether you would still carry groceries up those stairs in February. If you would, the cheaper apartment is the better one.
Weigh the timeline
A rental building can approve you in a day or two. A co-op sublet can take weeks and may end after a year or two. If your current lease is running out, the slower apartment needs to be clearly better to be worth the risk of a gap.
Reasons to walk away
Money before you have been inside
A deposit requested for an apartment you have only seen in photographs is a familiar rental scam. The story changes, an owner abroad or a tenant who cannot be disturbed, and the request stays the same. See the inside, with someone who has keys, before any money moves.
No address, no names
You should be able to get the exact address, the apartment number and the landlord's name before you apply. Without them you cannot look anything up, and there is rarely an honest reason to hold them back from a serious applicant.
Answers that will not go in an email
The fee, the stabilization status and the amounts due at signing are simple facts. Someone who states them aloud and then declines to write them down is telling you they may change. Ask once more, in writing, and treat silence as the reply.
A deadline that keeps moving up
Good apartments do go quickly, and an honest broker will tell you how many applications are in. Pressure to pay tonight before you have read the lease or seen the riders is different. Another apartment will come up next week; money sent in a hurry is much harder to get back.