Questions to Ask Before Joining a Campus Ministry
Questions to ask before joining a campus ministry, for a college student who has been to a few meetings and is deciding how far in to go, and for a parent hearing the group's name for the first time. They follow the order the decision usually takes: what the ministry believes and who it belongs to, the staff and the money, how much of your week and your friendships it asks for, how discipleship and dating rules work, and how free you are to attend a church in town or to leave. The last five are ones only you can answer, after everyone else has had their say.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
Beliefs
Which church, denomination or national organization is this ministry part of?
Why ask it
Get the exact name of the parent body, because the name on the banner is often a local one. Then read that organization's own website and search its name alongside the words former member before your next visit.
Is there a written statement of faith, and can I read it before I come back?
Why ask it
A group that is settled about what it teaches sends a link the same day. If you are told you will pick it up as you go, ask once more, and treat a second vague answer as information about how the group works.
Do I need to be a Christian, or from a particular church background, to take part?
Why ask it
The usual answer is that anyone may come, so ask what changes later: which parts stay open to everyone and which are kept for members, such as leading a study or going on a retreat. If you are still working out what you believe, say so and see how the welcome holds up.
Is this group a registered student organization with the university?
Why ask it
Recognition usually means the group has signed up to the school's rules and someone in student life knows its leaders. What the status involves differs from campus to campus, so ask that office what it means there and whether the group is in good standing.
Do you consider students in other churches and campus groups to be Christians?
Why ask it
Of everything on this page, this does the most to separate an ordinary fellowship from an exclusive one. If true faith turns out to mean this group or its own baptism, ask what that makes your home church and the Christian friends you arrived with.
What do you teach about baptism, and would the one I already had be recognized?
Why ask it
Mostly for students baptized as infants or in another tradition. Some groups will ask for it to be done again, and that is far easier to weigh in your second week than after a year of friendships.
Where does the ministry stand on women in leadership and on sexuality, and who has to agree with it?
Why ask it
Plenty of groups let anyone attend and hold the line only for those who lead, so the second half matters as much as the first. You want to hear it now and not when you open the leader application.
What happens when a student disagrees with something taught here, or goes through a stretch of doubt?
Why ask it
Ask for a story and not a policy: the last time someone pushed back in a Bible study, and how it ended. If nobody can recall one, either no one disagrees here or no one says so, and you will want to know which.
Staff and money
Who are the staff on this campus, and who do they report to?
Why ask it
You are after a name and a job title above the campus director, ideally a person who works somewhere else. An answer that stops at the director, or goes straight to God, suggests nobody is checking the work.
What training did the staff complete before they began working with students?
Why ask it
It ranges from a seminary degree to a few weeks of new staff training to nothing formal, and no one of those settles the matter. Ask what the training covered besides theology, and whether the interns and volunteers who meet with students went through any of it.
How do you help a student who is struggling with anxiety, depression or something heavier?
Why ask it
Listen for whether the campus counseling center comes up without your prompting, and whether prayer and professional care are spoken of as working together. If you hear that counseling or medication shows weak faith, that is a question about your health, and it belongs with a health professional and not with the group.
Are staff and volunteers background checked, and is there a written policy on meeting students one to one?
Why ask it
Ask to see the policy, not to hear it described. What checks are required differs by organization and by where you live, so the useful follow-up is who set this group's rules and when they were last reviewed.
Who would I contact, off this campus, if a staff member or student leader treated me badly?
Why ask it
Put the name and email address in your phone while you are standing there. An organization with a real complaints process can produce a regional director or a reporting line without having to think about it.
How are student leaders chosen, and what do they sign or agree to?
Why ask it
Read the leader covenant or application even if you never mean to lead. It is the plainest written account of what the group expects from someone at full commitment, and of who decides whether you are meeting it.
How is the ministry funded, and do the staff raise their own salaries?
Why ask it
In many campus organizations each staff member is paid by donors they recruit, which is an ordinary arrangement and nothing to be alarmed by. Knowing it explains the newsletters, and it tells you whether your parents may one day get a support letter.
Are students asked to give money, and is any amount expected?
Why ask it
The follow-up is who would see what you put in. When a leader can say who gave and who did not, or a percentage is named to students living on loans, the giving is no longer private, and you should decide with that in mind.
What do the retreats, conferences and summer trips cost over a full year?
Why ask it
Add it up yourself: fall retreat, winter conference, spring break trip, summer project. Then ask what happens for students who cannot pay, and whether the ones who stay home are treated any differently on Monday.
Would I be expected to raise support from family and friends for a trip or a summer project?
Why ask it
Support letters are a common way to pay for mission trips. Before you sign up, find out the target, the deadline, and who covers the gap if your relatives do not give.
Is there a budget or annual report showing where donations go?
Why ask it
National bodies often publish accounts while a local chapter may have nothing on paper. Ask what exists at each level and who reviews it; reporting rules for nonprofits vary by country, so ask how it works for this one.
Commitment
What does a normal week look like for a student who is fully involved?
Why ask it
Have them list every piece: the large meeting, small group, a one to one, prayer, outreach, the leaders' meeting, Sunday. Total the hours afterward and set the number beside your class schedule and your job.
Is it fine to come only to the weekly meeting and nothing else?
Why ask it
This shows whether the group has a comfortable outer ring or only an inside. Watch for an answer that says yes and then goes on to describe what real commitment would look like.
What happens when I miss a week for an exam, a work shift or a trip home?
Why ask it
Put this one to a student who has done it. Good luck on the exam is the whole of a healthy response, so find out whether theirs came with a where were you message or a talk about priorities.
Has anyone here been advised to drop a class, switch majors or quit a job or a team to be more involved?
Why ask it
Put it to an older student, away from staff. A single story may just be one person's choice, but advice of that kind coming from leaders is among the clearest marks of a group that wants too much.
How much of the breaks and the summer does the ministry expect to fill?
Why ask it
Your family is probably assuming you will be home for some of it. Ask which events are truly optional and which are the ones everybody goes to, because the second kind is not optional in practice.
Do most members have close friends, clubs or sports outside this group?
Why ask it
Look for evidence instead of taking the yes: a leader on a team, someone in a play, a roommate who never comes. When a person's whole social life sits inside one group, walking away costs every friend at once.
Do members usually live together, and do leaders have a say in who lives where?
Why ask it
Friends sharing a house is normal college life. It changes when housing is arranged from above, since a lease then ties your rent and your bedroom to staying in good standing.
What was your first month here like, compared with now?
Why ask it
Ask a sophomore, who still remembers it. You are comparing what was asked of them in the second week with what is asked now, and finding out whether the people who welcomed them hardest are still the ones they see.
Discipleship
What does discipleship mean here, and is everyone paired with a mentor?
Why ask it
The word covers everything from coffee and a Bible passage to a chain of command. Ask whether you choose the person, whether you can switch, and whether your mentor has a mentor who hears about you.
What would the person discipling me expect to know about my life?
Why ask it
Mentoring is advice you ask for. If the answer includes running your class schedule, your spending or your weekend plans past someone first, get that said in their own words, because it is the arrangement you would be agreeing to.
If I tell a leader something private, who else will hear it?
Why ask it
Ask before you confide anything, not after. Find out whether mentors pass things up to staff as a matter of routine, and what they are obliged to report under the organization's policy or local law, which differs by place.
Are there rules about dating, and would I need anyone's approval before starting a relationship?
Why ask it
Teaching about dating is common in religious groups and you can take it or leave it. The word to follow up is approval: who gives it, whether couples have been told to break up, and whether first-year students are told to wait.
Can I date someone outside the ministry, or someone who does not share my faith?
Why ask it
Many Christian groups advise against dating outside the faith, so that part should not surprise you. Listen for whether outside the faith quietly means outside this group, which shrinks your choices to the people in the room.
What lifestyle expectations come with belonging, and which apply only to leaders?
Why ask it
Get an actual list: alcohol, living arrangements, clothing, what you watch, who you spend time with. Then ask where it is written down, because unwritten rules are the ones that grow.
What happens when a student falls short of those expectations?
Why ask it
Responses run from a kind conversation, to stepping back from a leadership role, to being avoided by the whole group. Ask for a recent example with the names left out and notice how the person in the story is described.
Is everyone expected to do evangelism, and what does that involve here?
Why ask it
It can mean inviting a friend to dinner or approaching strangers on the quad with a survey. Ask whether you can belong without doing it, and whether anyone keeps count of the people you bring.
Do small groups study the Bible directly, or work through a set series of lessons?
Why ask it
Either can be fine, so ask who wrote the material and whether you may take it home. If a fixed series has to be finished one to one before you count as a member, ask to see every lesson at the start.
Freedom
Am I free to attend a local church on Sundays, and do I pick which one?
Why ask it
Many campus ministries say plainly that they are not a church and push students toward one in town. If this one holds its own Sunday service and expects you there, it is acting as your church and deserves the questions you would ask a church.
Can I go to another campus fellowship or Bible study while I am part of this one?
Why ask it
First-year students often try two or three groups through the fall, and a secure ministry knows it. Reluctance here usually comes with the view that other groups are lesser, so compare it with what you heard about them earlier.
How do people usually leave this group, and are members still friends with them afterward?
Why ask it
Graduating is the easy case, so ask about the ones who left in the middle of a year. Words like fell away or chose the world, said about named people, tell you what would be said about you.
Could I talk with someone who used to be involved and stepped back?
Why ask it
A healthy group can point to a former member who is still on good terms and still says hello on the quad. If nobody can think of one, find a former member on your own through a class or a residence hall.
How do you talk about parents and families who do not share the group's beliefs?
Why ask it
Parents can ask this one themselves. A student should listen for coaching: being told what to say at home, what to leave out, or that a skeptical family cannot be expected to understand.
After graduation, are students encouraged to stay in town, join staff or move with a new church plant?
Why ask it
Some alumni do all three happily. The thing to learn is whether a job offer in another city is celebrated or treated as a loss, since that is the freedom to leave tested four years on.
Has the university ever suspended or disciplined this ministry, and over what?
Why ask it
Check the answer with the student life office and the campus newspaper archive. The reasons vary widely, from disputes over who may hold office to complaints from students about pressure, and those are not the same kind of problem.
What do critics and former members say about this organization, and how do you answer them?
Why ask it
Do the search first and bring one specific criticism with you. You are checking two things: whether the leader has read it, and whether you are told what is wrong with the claim or what is wrong with the people making it.
Yourself
Can I say no to an invitation here without it becoming a problem?
Why ask it
Test it in a small way: turn down one event and offer no reason. What follows over the next few days, whether nothing, a friendly see you next time, or a string of check-ins, is better evidence than any answer a leader gave you.
Am I being hurried toward a decision?
Why ask it
Baptism, a membership commitment, a leadership role or a shared lease can all wait a semester. If waiting is met with urgency about your soul or your seriousness, ask whose timetable you are on.
Since I started coming, have I grown closer to my family and old friends or further from them?
Why ask it
Look at your own call log and messages for the answer. Some drift comes with college, so the thing to check is whether anyone in the group has suggested those people hold you back.
Would I be comfortable showing my parents, or a pastor from home, everything this group has asked of me?
Why ask it
Picture handing over the schedule, the covenant and the texts from your mentor. Anything you would want to leave out of the pile is the thing to talk over with someone outside the group.
Am I drawn to what this group teaches, or to being noticed during a lonely first semester?
Why ask it
Both can be true, and wanting friends is no flaw. It helps to visit one other group before deciding, so that you are choosing between two rooms and not between this one and eating alone.
Vetting a campus ministry before you commit
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
Who to put the questions to
Staff
Beliefs, oversight and money belong with the campus director or another paid staff member, who can send you documents. Ask by email as well as in person, since a written reply is something you can reread and show a parent.
Student leaders and ordinary members
The Commitment and Discipleship groups get truer answers from students, asked over a meal with no staff at the table. Try a senior and a sophomore separately: one knows where the road ends and the other remembers the first month. Staff tend to describe the policy and students describe the week, so where the two accounts differ on hours, dating or money, go back to the staff with the difference.
People with no stake
The student life office, a university chaplain if the campus has one, and a pastor from home can each tell you something the group cannot. So can a classmate who used to attend and stopped.
If you are the parent
A parent can reasonably ask a staff member about affiliation, oversight, costs and how families are spoken of. Talk to your son or daughter first and go along to a meeting with them if you are invited. A call made behind a student's back hands the group an example of a family that does not understand.
What is ordinary and should not alarm you
Enthusiastic invitations
Most campus groups, religious or not, recruit hard in the opening weeks of the fall term, and three invitations in a week is how that looks. It becomes a concern only when a no is not accepted.
Staff who live on donations
Donor-supported staff are standard across much of campus ministry. A newsletter and a request for prayer and support are part of that model and say nothing bad about the person sending them.
Firm beliefs and a leader covenant
A ministry is allowed to hold a clear theology and to ask more of the students who lead it. The test is whether the expectations are written, told to you early, and no wider in practice than they are on paper.
Being pointed toward a church
Staff who keep asking where you go on Sunday are usually trying to hand you on to a congregation that will still be there after graduation, which is the reverse of keeping you to themselves.
Signs of a high-control group
Your calendar fills from the outside
Meetings multiply until there is something most nights, and missing one brings a conversation. Study time, sleep, a job and other friendships get described as distractions.
Decisions need clearing
Dating, housing, majors, summer plans and trips home start to go past a mentor before you act. Private things you shared come back to you from someone you never told.
Everyone outside is suspect
Other churches are called lukewarm, parents are said not to understand, and former members are not spoken to. Criticism of the group is explained as an attack before you have had the chance to read it.
Leaving looks costly
Members talk about people who left with pity or as a warning, and you realize your housing, your friends and your sense of standing with God all run through one group.
One sign or a pattern
A single item from this list in a single conversation may be one clumsy leader. Several of them together, confirmed by more than one student, make a pattern, and that is the point to step back and talk to someone outside.
After you have the answers
If they were good
Go for a semester before you sign or lead anything, keep one commitment that has nothing to do with the group, and stay in touch with a church or a person from home. A sound ministry will have no objection to any of that.
If they were mixed
Take the two or three answers that bothered you back to a staff member and say so plainly. How the concern is received will tell you more than the first answer did, and a visit to a second fellowship gives you something to compare it with.
If they worried you
You do not owe anyone a meeting to explain why you stopped coming. Tell a parent, a resident advisor or the student life office what you saw, and if stepping away is weighing on you, the campus counseling center is a place to talk it through.