Questions to Ask Your Girlfriend
Questions for the woman you're dating, whether it has been three months or three years: 128 of them in five groups. The fun questions to ask your girlfriend come first, for an easy evening. The deep questions, about who she is and how she got that way, come next, followed by Us, Future and Hard. Each one has a note on what her answer is likely to show you and where to take it next. Answer every question you ask: that's the deal.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
Fun
What was the first thing you told your friends about me?
Why ask it
There was a report, and it was more detailed than you'd like. Ask who heard it first and what the verdict was, then admit what you told your own friends.
Which habit of mine did you find ridiculous at first and have secretly grown fond of?
Why ask it
This is a compliment dressed up as a complaint. Whatever it is, the sock system or the voice you use on the cat, take the win and keep doing it.
If you came with a user manual, what would the first warning say?
Why ask it
Do not approach before coffee. Do not say 'calm down'. She'll write it for laughs, and you should memorize it all the same.
What would your teenage self think of me?
Why ask it
The fifteen-year-old version of her had firm requirements, most of them involving a band or a haircut. Hearing where you pass and where you fail is funny, and it shows how far her taste has travelled.
What's the worst date you could plan for me on purpose?
Why ask it
To design a truly bad one she has to know what you can't stand, and people enjoy showing off that knowledge. Return the favor, and notice how accurate hers is.
Which foods are simply not worth the effort of eating?
Why ask it
Pomegranates, crab legs, anything with a shell. A harmless argument waiting to happen, and useful knowledge when you're the one cooking.
Which of us is the worse passenger, and which is the worse driver?
Why ask it
Two verdicts, so each of you can lose once. Flinching, phantom braking and unrequested directions all count as evidence.
What's something everyone is supposed to love that you find overrated: brunch, beach days, surprise parties?
Why ask it
Permission to dislike something everyone is meant to enjoy. File the answer carefully, because it doubles as a list of things never to plan for her.
Which emoji do I lean on too hard, and what do you think I'm trying to say with it?
Why ask it
Her translation will be nothing like what you intended. Open your most-used rows side by side if either of you wants evidence.
Which fictional character did you have a crush on, and what do you think that says about you?
Why ask it
Asking her to do the analysis is the trick. She'll be funnier and more honest about her own taste than you would dare to be.
If we got a pet tomorrow, what would you name it, and which of us would it like better?
Why ask it
A dog called Kevin and a dog called Biscuit belong to two different people, so the name is a sample of her humor. The second half starts a rivalry over an animal that doesn't exist.
When have you laughed at exactly the wrong moment?
Why ask it
Assemblies, ceremonies and serious meetings feature heavily. The story is nearly always good, and you find out who she can't make eye contact with.
Which of my possessions would you quietly get rid of if you thought I wouldn't notice?
Why ask it
She has a list and has been tactful about it, and the novelty mug is probably near the top. Laugh, defend one item at most, and listen for what she thinks your stuff says about you.
If you could be instantly world-class at one thing with no practical use, what would it be?
Why ask it
Removing usefulness removes the sensible answer. What's left is pure appetite: juggling, yodeling, competitive sandcastles.
Which reality show would we win as a team, and which would finish us by the second episode?
Why ask it
The show you'd win is her idea of what the two of you are good at together. The one that sinks you tends to involve a map or a shared kitchen, and she'll have a specific argument in mind.
What's a fear of yours that you know perfectly well is ridiculous?
Why ask it
Conceding that a fear is silly makes it easy to share. If it turns out to be moths or a ringing phone, you've also learned what to quietly deal with for her.
What song do you turn all the way up no matter who's in the car?
Why ask it
No shame allowed, and no skipping it the next time it comes on. Learn the chorus, because a duet is coming.
If you did an impression of me, what would you say first?
Why ask it
Everyone has a catchphrase they can't hear themselves. Ask for the full performance, voice and hand gestures included, and don't sulk about how accurate it is.
What did you collect as a kid, and where is the collection now?
Why ask it
Where it ended up is the better half. Whether it sits in a labeled box or vanished long ago says something about how she treats her own past.
Which game should the two of us never play against each other again?
Why ask it
Somewhere there is a board game, a racket sport or a go-kart track with history. Retelling the incident from both sides is the fun, provided nobody demands a rematch.
What rule in your childhood home did you later find out wasn't normal?
Why ask it
Every family has an odd law: no shoes on the stairs, no singing at the table. It's a funny side door into how her household ran.
What's a meal you only make when you're alone, and would you ever serve it to me?
Why ask it
Being let in on the secret meal is a small promotion. If it turns out to be cereal eaten standing at the counter, ask for a bowl.
What's the text from me you'd be most likely to screenshot and send to a friend?
Why ask it
She has a group chat and you have appeared in it. Asking with a grin shows you know, and tells you which version of you gets passed around.
What's the longest you've ever kept a plant, a diary or a New Year's resolution going?
Why ask it
A friendly audit of her follow-through, with three chances to look good. The diary that lasted nine days and the fern that made it to March are both good stories. Confess your own record before you judge hers.
What film or show do you love that you're slightly afraid to show me?
Why ask it
The fear is that you'll talk through it or pick up your phone halfway. Promise to watch it properly, and keep your review to yourself until she asks for it.
Which season are you, as a person, and which one do you think I am?
Why ask it
Silly on the surface, but people pick with care and then explain themselves at length. Pay most attention to the season she hands you, and why.
What was the most elaborate make-believe game you ran as a kid?
Why ask it
Notice her role in it: director, star, or the one who drew the maps. Childhood games are a decent forecast of how she likes to run a project.
What would you do first if you woke up as me for a day?
Why ask it
Whatever her first errand is, cancelling a subscription or finally booking the haircut, it's a gentle note on what she'd fix, delivered as a joke.
What touristy thing in our own town have you secretly wanted to do?
Why ask it
Nobody who lives in a place takes the boat trip or the open-top bus, which is why she has never been. Book it and be uncool together for an afternoon.
What was the best day you've had that cost almost nothing?
Why ask it
A guide to what she enjoys once spending is off the table. Steal the structure of that day for a date, without announcing that you've done so.
If someone made a film about the two of us, what would it be called and who would play you?
Why ask it
Casting is where vanity and honesty collide. Let her cast your part as well, and accept the actor she picks without lodging an appeal.
What nickname would you never let me call you?
Why ask it
Most people have one that makes their skin crawl, and it is often the first a partner reaches for. Better to learn it here than to try it out in front of her friends.
What's the best present you've ever given someone, and how did you know it would land?
Why ask it
The way she gives is a fair hint at how she'd like to receive. If her proudest present was something noticed months earlier, made by hand or booked as a surprise, you've been told what a good gift means to her without having to ask.
Deep
What do you wish someone would ask you about, and nobody ever does?
Why ask it
Nearly everyone has a subject they light up on and rarely get invited into. Once she names hers, the next move is plain: ask about it, and keep asking in the weeks after.
What part of your life right now do you think you'll look back on as the good old days?
Why ask it
It turns the present into something she will miss one day. If you feature in the answer, enjoy that, and if it's a flat full of friends or a job she likes, help her protect it.
What does being loved well look like to you on an ordinary Tuesday?
Why ask it
Tuesday rules out anniversaries and grand gestures. What's left is small and specific, a cup of tea brought without asking, a message at lunch, and all of it is within your reach this week.
Which place has felt most like home to you, and what made it that?
Why ask it
It may not be where she grew up. The ingredients she lists, light, noise, people dropping by, are worth remembering if you ever share a front door.
What makes you cry that has nothing to do with being sad?
Why ask it
What moves her without warning, a choir, strangers being kind to each other, anyone winning anything, points straight at what she holds dear. It's also far easier to talk about than grief.
Which friend of yours knows a version of you that I haven't met yet?
Why ask it
Old friends hold earlier editions of a person. Ask what that version was like, and take it as a hint about who you should get to know better.
What do people tend to assume about you when they first meet you, and how wrong is it?
Why ask it
She has had years to be irritated by this, so expect a quick answer. It also invites the question of what you assumed, so have that ready.
What did you spend hours doing as a kid without anyone making you?
Why ask it
Unforced childhood hours point at what absorbs her by nature. Ask whether anything in her life now gives her the same lost-track-of-time feeling.
What's the best advice you ever ignored?
Why ask it
There's self-mockery built in, which keeps it from getting heavy. Whose advice it was matters too: it tells you who she wishes she'd listened to.
Who outside your family had the biggest hand in how you turned out?
Why ask it
People love being asked about whoever took an interest in them. Whether it was a teacher, a friend's mother or a first boss, that person explains a lot about her standards.
When were you last properly proud of yourself, and did you tell anyone?
Why ask it
The second half is the one to listen to. If she got something right and kept it quiet, ask to hear the whole story now, start to finish.
What compliment have you never quite believed?
Why ask it
She has heard it many times and waved it away on every occasion. Don't repeat it louder. Ask what would have to be true for her to accept it.
What small moment from your life do you think about far more often than it seems to deserve?
Why ask it
A remark from a stranger, a look across a classroom, an afternoon when nothing much happened. Moments that stick for no obvious reason usually have one, and working it out together is the conversation.
What have you changed your mind about in the last few years that you used to be certain of?
Why ask it
A changed mind shows how she changes, and whether it took a person, a bad year or just time. That's worth knowing about anyone you plan to disagree with for years.
What are you stricter with yourself about than you'd ever be with a friend?
Why ask it
The gap between what she'd forgive in a friend and what she forgives in herself, over her work or a mistake from years ago, shows where a kind word from you counts most. Advice there would only sound like one more critic.
What kind of attention do you enjoy, and what kind makes you want to leave the room?
Why ask it
Some people love a speech in their honor and others would rather hide under the table. Knowing which she is prevents at least one well-meant disaster.
When did you last open your mouth and hear one of your parents come out?
Why ask it
The trigger tends to be small: a phrase, a sigh, a particular way of saying 'we'll see'. Whether she tells it with a laugh or a wince says a lot about how she feels about the person she's echoing.
What do you do to look after yourself that really works, and what only pretends to?
Why ask it
The pretend one is usually scrolling. The real one might be a run or a call with her sister, and once you know it you can nudge her toward it on a rough day.
What memory do you go back to when you need comfort?
Why ask it
You're being shown where her sense of safety comes from, perhaps a kitchen or one particular summer, so treat the details as something to keep.
What's the hardest thing you've ever talked yourself into doing?
Why ask it
It comes with a built-in story of doubt, a decision and an outcome. You also learn the voice she uses on herself when she needs courage.
What were you praised for most as a child, and did it ever start to feel like a job?
Why ask it
The clever one, the helpful one, the easy one. Praise can harden into a role, and she may still be working shifts in it.
What are you tired of being the reliable one for?
Why ask it
Capable people get handed things until they sag. If she names something, the kind move is not sympathy but quietly taking one item off the pile.
What are you still figuring out how to say no to?
Why ask it
It shows you where her edges are soft, be it extra work or a friend who always needs a favor. Take it as a warning too: don't become one more thing she can't refuse.
What did you believe about yourself at sixteen that turned out to be wrong?
Why ask it
Usually something harsh: not clever, not likeable, not the pretty one. How she found out it was wrong is a story about who was good to her.
What's easier for you to give than to receive?
Why ask it
Someone generous in one direction can be awkward in the other. If she names help or praise, offer it slowly, without fuss, and without expecting a yes the first time.
What was the mood in your house when you came home from school, and who set it?
Why ask it
Every household has its own weather, and children learn to read it from the doorway. Whether she walked into noise, calm or tension, and who was in charge of it, explains a good deal about how she reads a room now, including yours.
What do you need to hear when something you tried hasn't worked?
Why ask it
Get the exact words if you can. 'You'll get the next one' comforts one person and enrages another, and she knows which sentence works on her.
What did you need more of as a kid that you've had to learn to give yourself?
Why ask it
It might be attention, calm, or someone saying well done. Whatever it was, it's likely to be what she values most from a partner and the last thing she'd ask you for.
What are you most afraid of losing, apart from the people you love?
Why ask it
Taking people off the table forces a more particular answer: her independence, her memory, her sense of humor, the work she's good at. Whatever she names is something she'll defend, so it helps to know it's there.
What would you copy from how the adults who raised you treated each other, and what would you do differently?
Why ask it
Everyone carries a first model of what a couple is, whether it was good, bad or missing. Leave the people in it unjudged. The useful part is which habits she's determined to keep and which she's on guard against in herself.
What did your first heartbreak teach you that still holds true?
Why ask it
Ask this out of interest in her, not in him. The lesson she kept, about pace, about honesty, about what she won't put up with twice, is one she's applying to you.
What's the loneliest you've ever been, and what got you out of it?
Why ask it
The way out matters as much as the low point. It's her own tested remedy, whether that was a friend who kept calling or a move back home, and one day you may be asked to help with it.
Where in your life would you like to be braver than you are?
Why ask it
She isn't asking to be pushed. Whether it's a raise, a stage or a hard conversation with a relative, find out if she wants company, a nudge, or just someone who knows.
Us
When you tell people how we met, what do you leave in and what do you leave out?
Why ask it
Everyone edits their origin story. Her cut tells you what she finds romantic about it and what she'd rather her aunt never heard.
What's been our best day so far?
Why ask it
Short, and harder than it looks. Compare answers: if you each pick a different day, you now have two templates for a good one.
Which of our inside jokes would be hardest to explain to an outsider?
Why ask it
Trying to explain it is the entertainment. A couple's private language is a real sign of closeness, and it's pleasant to take inventory.
Which photo of us do you think shows what we're really like?
Why ask it
Rarely the posed one. The picture she chooses, mid-laugh, badly lit, slightly chaotic, is her idea of the two of you at your most accurate.
What does a perfect lazy Sunday with me look like, and how is it different from a perfect one alone?
Why ask it
The gap between the two is not an insult. It tells you what she gets from solitude, and lets you give it to her without feeling shut out.
What's something I said offhand that you've held onto?
Why ask it
You will not remember saying it, which is the point. Words land harder than the speaker knows, and this shows you which kind land with her.
What do you think our friends say about us as a couple once we've left the room?
Why ask it
An outside view, borrowed. What she imagines them saying is what she thinks the two of you project, and you can ask whether she believes it matches the truth.
What do you think I'm like when you're not around?
Why ask it
Her guess shows how well she thinks she knows you, and whether she imagines you messier, sadder or more fun. Correct the record kindly.
What do we do now that we couldn't have managed in the early days?
Why ask it
The early days get all the nostalgia, so ask about the gains. Being ill in front of each other, sitting in silence, disagreeing without panic: her list shows what she counts as progress. Then ask what she misses from back then, and bring one thing back.
What part of your typical week do I know the least about?
Why ask it
Look for the invisible load: a draining commute, a difficult colleague, a relative who calls daily. It changes what you ask of her on a Thursday.
What does a bad day do to you that I might mistake for something else?
Why ask it
Going quiet can look like sulking, and snapping about the dishes can look like it's about the dishes. Her translation saves you from taking her worst days personally.
When you're having a rough time, do you want me to fix it, listen, or distract you?
Why ask it
Asking in advance spares you from guessing wrong in the moment. The answer can change by the day, so it's fair to ask again when it's happening.
How do you like to be apologized to?
Why ask it
Some want the words, some want changed behavior, some want a day and then a hug. If you've been apologizing in your own style, this explains a lot.
When did you last feel chosen by me, and what had I done?
Why ask it
Different from feeling loved. Chosen is about priority: being introduced, being planned around, being picked over an easier option. A specific occasion tells you what to repeat, and a long pause before she answers tells you something as well.
What's something you've learned about yourself from being with me?
Why ask it
Good relationships teach people things, flattering and not. She might say she's more patient than she knew, or less. Both are useful.
Which of my friends or family are you most at ease with, and who is still hard work?
Why ask it
She has opinions and has been polite about them. Don't defend the hard-work person. Ask what would make those occasions easier for her.
What role have you ended up playing between us, like planner, peacemaker or rememberer of birthdays, and do you want it?
Why ask it
Roles settle in without a vote. If she's tired of hers, this is the vote, and the fix is usually you taking something over without being reminded.
What's something small I do that you'd miss if I stopped?
Why ask it
It is rarely what you'd guess: the last bite saved for her, the message when you land. She may not have known it herself until asked, and now you have a short list of habits to protect.
When do I seem most distracted, and how does that land with you?
Why ask it
You're asking for criticism in a form that's easy to give. Expect the word phone, skip the explanation, and find out what she'd like you to do differently.
What should we stop saying yes to so we have more time for each other?
Why ask it
Time together rarely vanishes on purpose. It goes to the standing obligation, the extra shift, the third weekend away in a row. Agreeing on one commitment to decline is easier than promising to make more time, and it is a decision the two of you make as a team.
What subject do I get defensive about fastest, and how have you learned to work around it?
Why ask it
She already has a map of your sore spots and a set of detours, and the detours cost her something. Hearing the list without proving it right on the spot is the whole test. Ask which subject she'd most like to be able to raise directly.
Future
What trip do you want us to take before life gets more complicated?
Why ask it
The destination matters less than the phrase 'more complicated', which invites her to say what she thinks is coming. Then start pricing the trip.
If you were handed a paid year off, what would you do with the first month and with the last?
Why ask it
Month one is rest, and the final month is who she wants to be. Splitting it stops the answer from being nothing but sleep and a beach.
What do you need within walking distance to be happy living somewhere?
Why ask it
A bakery, a park, her best friend, nothing at all. It turns the vague question of where to live into a checklist the two of you can compare.
What have you watched happen to other long-term couples that you'd like us to steer clear of?
Why ask it
She'll have a couple in mind: the friends who stopped going out, or the pair who only talk logistics. The pattern she names is what she's watching for in the two of you, and a warning sign agreed on now is easier to catch than one you have to notice from the inside.
How do you want the big birthdays and milestones marked: a crowd, a trip, or a quiet dinner?
Why ask it
Ask well before one arrives. People feel strongly, rarely say so, and then sit through a party they didn't want, smiling at you.
What do you want your friendships to look like ten years from now?
Why ask it
Partners often forget to ask about this. If she wants friends dropping by on weeknights and you want a quiet house, better to find out early.
If you could redesign your working life from scratch, what's the first thing you'd change?
Why ask it
Whatever she changes first is the sore spot: the hours, the boss, the whole field. Whether it's small or total tells you how settled she feels.
What does success look like for you that has nothing to do with work?
Why ask it
Behind an impressive job there's often a quieter ambition: a garden, a long table of friends, being a good aunt. That's the one to back.
What do you want to have made, built or finished by the time you're old?
Why ask it
Not everyone has an answer, and that's fine. If she does, it's something you'll be living alongside, so ask what it needs from the next few years.
What are you saving for, literally or otherwise?
Why ask it
Literally gets you a goal. Otherwise gets you the thing she's holding energy back for, which can be more revealing than the bank answer.
What do you think we'll laugh about in ten years that feels serious now?
Why ask it
It shrinks a current worry by looking at it from a distance, and tells you which one is on her mind. A kind thing to ask in the middle of a stressful month.
What would you look forward to about living together, and what would worry you?
Why ask it
If you already share keys, ask it about the next home instead. The worries are usually about space and chores, which makes them fixable.
Which of your family's traditions would you want to carry on, and which would you happily drop?
Why ask it
Holidays are where two families' habits collide, so find out early which ones she'd fight for. What she wants to keep is often the feeling of a full house or a slow morning, not the exact menu.
When life gets busier, how should the work of running a home be split: by skill, by schedule or by turns?
Why ask it
Naming three systems makes it a design question instead of a grievance. Ask what she saw growing up, since that's the default she's arguing with.
When one of us hits a brutal stretch at work, what should the other reasonably expect?
Why ask it
Crunch periods strain couples because nobody set terms. Agreeing on a minimum, one proper evening a week, a daily call, keeps resentment from filling the gap.
How big does a purchase have to be before a couple should talk it over first?
Why ask it
A practical way into money that doesn't ask what she earns. The threshold she names tells you how much financial privacy she expects to keep.
What's your biggest fear about money?
Why ask it
The fear usually has a history. Running out, owing someone and depending on a partner are different fears, and knowing which is hers, and where it started, explains her spending and her saving.
If a proposal ever happens, how should it go: private or public, a surprise or talked through first?
Why ask it
Hypothetical on purpose, so nobody panics. Guessing wrong about this is a classic and avoidable mistake, and she almost certainly has views.
If we raised a child, what would you want them to say about their childhood when they're thirty?
Why ask it
It sidesteps the yes-or-no and goes to values. If she isn't sure about children at all, she'll say so here, and that's worth hearing plainly.
What would you never want to give up for a relationship or a family, however yours turns out?
Why ask it
Her work, her city, her Saturday mornings, her name. It's easier to honor a line when it's been drawn before anyone is standing on it.
Hard
What do you think I expect from you that I've never actually asked for?
Why ask it
She may be meeting standards you never set: always cheerful, always available, always fine. Hearing the list lets you cancel the ones you never wanted.
When things get tense with your family, what do you need from me, and what do I do instead?
Why ask it
Her family is hers to criticize, and the rules for you are different. She may want an ally, a quiet witness or a fast exit, and you may have been offering opinions. Find out the job before the next visit, not during it.
How do you feel about the way I talk about you in front of other people?
Why ask it
Teasing that feels affectionate to you can feel like exposure to her. She has probably never raised it, because it sounds petty until someone asks.
Is there a boundary with my family or friends that you'd like me to hold for you?
Why ask it
She can't easily police your people, and she knows it. If she names something, holding that line is your job, and doing it without fuss earns a lot of trust.
When have I made you feel small, even if I didn't mean to?
Why ask it
The closing clause gives her room to say it without calling you cruel. Don't argue with the memory. Your intent isn't the subject, the effect is.
What part of yourself do you turn down around me?
Why ask it
People dim whatever they suspect isn't welcome, and it could be her ambition as easily as her silliness. She may be wrong about what you can handle, so tell her if she is.
Is there an insecurity of yours that gets louder around me instead of quieter?
Why ask it
Uncomfortable, because the answer may involve you. If a comment or a comparison of yours feeds it, you'd want to know. Listen without defending.
What do you still brace for with me because of how someone treated you before?
Why ask it
Old injuries set off alarms in new relationships. Knowing what she's braced for lets you stop tripping it by accident, and explains reactions that seemed outsized.
When have you felt like you were carrying more of this relationship than I was?
Why ask it
There has almost certainly been a time. Ask what carrying looked like, from doing the planning to always being the one who reached out, so you can spot it next time.
When you picture telling me bad news, what reaction of mine do you expect?
Why ask it
Her prediction is a report on how safe you are to confide in. If she expects panic, blame or a lecture, the thing to work on is you, not her forecast.
Do you feel you can be properly angry with me without it costing you something?
Why ask it
If she manages her anger in order to manage your reaction, you have a problem that looks like peace. A slow or careful answer is an answer.
What have you forgiven me for that still stings now and then?
Why ask it
Forgiven is not the same as gone. Letting her say it still aches, without reopening the trial, is often what finally lets it fade.
What do you think I still don't understand about what it's like to be you?
Why ask it
The question is left wide so she can choose: her job, her family, or moving through the world as she does. Believe the answer even if it doesn't match your view.
How have you changed since we got together, and is there any of it you're not sure you like?
Why ask it
Relationships reshape people, not always toward who they wanted to be. If she has lost a habit, a friend or some nerve, help her get it back.
If I changed in a big way, say a new career, new beliefs or wanting to move cities, what could you bend on and what couldn't you?
Why ask it
We all change, and promising otherwise is how couples get blindsided. Knowing which parts of the deal are fixed for her is a kindness to both of you.
What scares you about committing for the long haul, even to someone you're sure of?
Why ask it
Being sure of a person and being afraid of forever can coexist. If she names boredom, losing herself or being left, you are hearing a fear, not a no.
If one of us developed a crush on someone else, would you want to be told?
Why ask it
It happens in long relationships, and couples differ sharply on the etiquette. Agreeing on the rule in the abstract is far easier than mid-crisis.
What hope do you have for us that feels risky to say out loud?
Why ask it
Hopes are scarier to admit than complaints, because they can be turned down. Whatever she says, don't negotiate it on the spot. Just hold it.
Is there anything about your health, body or mind, that you've been managing quietly on your own?
Why ask it
Bring no agenda and plenty of time. Many people handle things privately out of habit, and the offer of company can matter more than any advice.
If you hit a really dark stretch and started pushing me away, what would you want me to do?
Why ask it
Raise it while things are good, because she can't tell you when she's in it. You're collecting instructions from the well version of her for the unwell one.
Is there a grief you carry that I should understand better?
Why ask it
A person, a place, a version of her life that didn't happen. You don't need to fix it. Learn the dates that matter and the name to say.
Asking well, and what to do with the answers
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
Before you ask anything
Go first
Answer the question yourself before you ask her, out loud, at the depth you're hoping for. It shows you're not running an assessment, and it sets the level. If you wouldn't answer a question, you haven't earned the right to ask it.
Check your motive
Curiosity is a good reason to ask. Fishing for reassurance, building a case or testing her against a checklist are bad ones, and she'll sense the difference within a sentence. If a question has a correct answer in your head, leave it on the list.
Agree that either of you can pass
Say at the start that a question can be skipped with no explanation and no sulking. The freedom to pass is what makes honest answers possible on the ones she takes. A skipped question is not a clue to be decoded later.
Put the phone somewhere else
Reading questions off a screen is fine. Glancing at notifications between them is not. Silence the phone first, or copy a few questions onto paper and leave the phone in another room.
Formats that work
Slips on the table
- 1Each of you picks three questions from the list and writes them on slips of paper.
- 2Shuffle the slips face down. Take turns drawing one, and whoever draws it answers first.
- 3The other person answers the same question before the next slip is drawn.
- 4Leave any undrawn slips for next time. There's no prize for clearing the table.
The long-distance version
- 1Send one question in the morning as a voice note, along with your own answer.
- 2She replies whenever she likes, by voice, not text. Tone carries half the meaning.
- 3Keep the Hard section for a call or a visit. Heavy answers deserve a live listener.
- 4Save the good ones. A folder of voice notes ages better than a chat log.
The yearly review
- 1Around an anniversary, pick a few questions from Us and Future that you've both answered before.
- 2Answer them again without looking up what you said last time.
- 3Compare. Notice what moved and what held.
- 4Choose one thing from the conversation to act on before the next review.
Listening, and afterwards
Follow up before you reply
The best second question is usually 'what was that like?' or 'say more about that'. Ask at least one follow-up before you offer your own story. It's the difference between a conversation and two people taking turns to talk.
Don't fix what she tells you
If an answer reveals a problem, the urge to solve it on the spot is strong and usually unwelcome. Ask whether she wants ideas or wanted it heard. Most of the time it's the second, and she'll tell you when it's the first.
Never use an answer as ammunition
Whatever she tells you in one of these conversations stays out of future arguments. The first time a confidence comes back as a weapon is the last time she gives you one. The same goes for repeating her answers to your friends.
When an answer hurts
Say 'thank you for telling me', and mean it, before anything else. You're allowed to be stung, and you can say so, but don't ask her to take it back or soften it. Return to it in a day or two, when you can be curious instead of defensive.
Act on one thing
A good conversation that changes nothing becomes, over time, a reason not to have another. If she told you she misses something or needs something, do it within the week without announcing it. That's what makes the next question worth answering.