Questions to Ask a Forex Trader
For beginners and would-be clients talking to someone who trades currencies: a mentor, a course or signal seller, or a trader offering to manage your money. The questions follow the order of the decision: the track record, risk and leverage, the strategy, the broker and the rules, then fees and the signs of a scam, with a short last group for interviewing a trader about the work itself. Each has a note on what a solid or a worrying answer sounds like; licensing, leverage limits and account protections differ by country and broker, so ask how each works where you live.
Want questions from the whole vault instead? Try the random question generator.
The questions
Each question, and why to ask it
Track record
How long have you traded currencies with real money, and for how much of that time was it your full-time work?
Why ask it
Years on a practice account and years with money at stake are different things, so ask for the second number. Someone who traded evenings around a job for six years can be a better teacher than someone who went full time last spring. What should worry you is an answer that slides from 'studying the markets' to 'trading' without saying when real money came into it.
Can I see a verified record of your live account that reads straight from the broker, not screenshots?
Why ask it
A screenshot can be edited, cropped or taken from a demo account in a minute. A tracking page that reads the broker account directly, and marks both the trades and the balance as verified, is much harder to fake. If the record is 'private' while winning trades go up on social media every day, you have your answer.
How far has your account fallen from its highest point, and what did you do while it was down?
Why ask it
Every trader with a real history has this number and remembers the weeks around it. Set the figure against the returns they claim: very large gains beside a tiny fall deserve a second look at the verified page. Someone who cannot give the number has not been measuring it, and that tells you how the risk is run.
What does a losing month look like for you, and how many did you have in the last year?
Why ask it
You are listening for a plain number given without embarrassment, and a size that fits the risk per trade they quote. Write it down and check it against the monthly figures on the verified record. If the count is zero, ask how long the record is and whether losing trades are being left open so that they never count.
What is your win rate, and how large is your average win next to your average loss?
Why ask it
The win rate on its own tells you nothing: a method that wins four trades in ten can make money, and one that wins nine in ten can lose it on the tenth. Ask for both halves. A seller who quotes only the percentage of winners is counting on you not asking about the size of the losers.
Does the record you show cover every account you have run, including any you closed or emptied?
Why ask it
It is easy to run several accounts and show the one that survived. Ask about the ones that ended and why. A trader who tells you about the account they lost in their second year, and what they stopped doing afterwards, is more believable than one with a spotless history.
How much money is in the account behind those results, and how much of the growth came from deposits?
Why ask it
Doubling a few hundred dollars is a different feat from doubling a year's salary, and money paid in can make a balance chart climb without a single good trade. Verified tracking pages usually separate gain from deposits, so ask which line you are looking at.
Are the results you advertise from live trades, a demo account or a backtest?
Why ask it
Backtests and demo accounts leave out late fills, spreads that widen around news and the nerves of having money at stake. An honest seller labels each kind of result. Where the marketing just says 'results', assume it is the weakest of the three until shown otherwise.
How many of your students are still trading a year later, and how do you know how their accounts have done?
Why ask it
Not every seller keeps count, and an honest one says so and tells you what they have seen. Be wary of a round, flattering percentage: ask how it was counted and whether it includes the people who quit. A mentor who can say what the students who gave up had in common has been paying attention.
Could I talk to two students or clients who have been with you for over a year, and are they paid for referrals?
Why ask it
Testimonials on a sales page were chosen by the seller, and some of the people in them earn a commission on every sign-up. When you do speak to someone, ask what their own account has done since they joined. Whether they enjoyed the course is a different question.
Risk and leverage
How much of your account do you risk on a single trade?
Why ask it
This should come back at once, as a small fixed percentage, because a careful trader settles it before anything else. Be wary of 'it depends how confident I am', or of lot sizes quoted with no link to the size of the account. Then work out what that percentage is in dollars on the amount you plan to start with.
What leverage do you use, and what would you suggest for an account my size?
Why ask it
Leverage enlarges losses exactly as much as gains. The most a retail account may use depends on the regulator and the broker, so ask what the limit is where you would be trading. A trader who steers you to the highest setting on offer, or to an offshore broker to get around a limit, is telling you how they think about your money.
Do you put a stop loss on every trade, and have you ever moved one further away?
Why ask it
The sound version is a stop set when the trade opens and moved only in the direction of profit. Admitting to having widened one, and what it cost, is a point in their favor. 'The price always comes back' holds right up to the trade where it does not.
Do you ever add to a losing trade, or raise your size after a loss to win it back?
Why ask it
Methods built on this tend to draw a smooth line of small wins and then take one loss that removes most of the account. If the answer is yes, ask to see the worst run on the verified record; it shows up as trades held open deep in the red. For a beginner copying someone, this is the question most worth a straight answer.
What is the most you let yourself lose in a day or a week before you stop?
Why ask it
Listen for a set figure and a story about the last time it was reached. With no limit, the size of the worst day is decided by mood. If they will be trading your money, ask whether that limit could be written into your agreement.
How many trades do you have open at once, and how do you treat pairs that share a currency?
Why ask it
Three trades that all sell the dollar are close to one bet made three times. A careful trader adds up the risk across everything open before taking another. If the idea seems new to them, the percentage they gave you for risk per trade understates what is really at stake.
What do you do with open trades over a weekend or before a major news release?
Why ask it
Prices can jump straight past a stop when the market reopens or a figure surprises, so the loss is bigger than the one planned. Closing, reducing or sizing down in advance are all reasonable answers. Ask what the worst jump they have sat through cost them.
Which single trade cost you the most, and what rule came out of it?
Why ask it
The story matters less than the rule at the end of it. 'I stopped trading around central bank announcements' or 'I cut my size in half' shows someone who changes when the market teaches them something. If the loss was the broker's fault, the market's fault or bad luck, expect the same explanation for yours.
Could I end up owing more than I deposited, and how would I find out for certain?
Why ask it
This depends on the broker and on the rules where the account is held: some retail accounts cannot go below zero and others can. Have the trader answer, then confirm it with the broker in writing. Someone who says it cannot happen without having read the broker's terms is guessing with your money.
Strategy
Can you explain your method in a few plain sentences: what makes you enter and what makes you get out?
Why ask it
You are not asking for the settings, only the logic: whether they read charts, economic news or both, and whether they follow a trend or trade a range. If it cannot be said without jargon, either they do not understand it or would prefer that you did not. 'A proprietary algorithm' with nothing after it is not an explanation.
Which currency pairs do you trade, and why those?
Why ask it
The heavily traded pairs usually cost less per trade, while thinly traded ones carry wider spreads and jump more. A considered answer ties the pairs to the method and to the hours the trader is awake. If you plan to copy them, look up what your own broker charges on the same pairs first.
What time frame do you trade on, and how long is a typical trade open?
Why ask it
This decides whether you can follow them at all. Trades that last minutes need you at the screen the second an alert arrives; trades that last days can be managed around a job. Ask which hours in your time zone most of their trades are opened.
How many trades do you take in a week, and what do you do when nothing sets up?
Why ask it
'Nothing' is the answer you want to the second half. A service that promises a fixed number of signals every day has a quota to fill whether or not the market is offering anything, and the extra trades are usually the weak ones.
In what kind of market does your approach lose money, and how do you recognize it?
Why ask it
Trend methods tend to bleed while prices drift sideways, and range methods get run over when a trend starts. A trader who can name the weak spot understands the method. 'It works in every market' is a line from the sales page.
Do you place the trades yourself, or does software do it?
Why ask it
If a trading robot is for sale, ask for a live record of that exact version and ask who can change its settings once it is running on your account. A system tuned to fit past prices can look superb in a backtest and fail on the first live month, so the live record is the only one that counts.
How do you record and review your trades?
Why ask it
A journal with the reason for each trade, a chart and a note afterwards is what separates a method from a habit. With a mentor it is also the curriculum, so ask to see a page from a bad week. No records at all means nobody, including them, can say why the account is where it is.
Do you take every trade you send out in your own live account, with real money?
Why ask it
A signal seller who trades their own alerts loses when you lose. One who only publishes them earns the subscription either way, and can quietly leave the bad calls out of the history. Ask to see one recent week of alerts beside the verified account for the same days.
If I copy your trades, how close will my results be to yours?
Why ask it
By the time an alert reaches your phone the price has moved, and your fill will differ from theirs. An honest signal provider says so and can show what followers' accounts did, as opposed to their own. Ask which of the two the advertised results come from.
Broker and rules
Which broker do you use, and which regulator licenses it?
Why ask it
Look the broker up on the regulator's own register, by a search you start yourself, not through a link you are sent. Check the exact company name too: one brand can run a closely supervised firm in one country and a lightly supervised one offshore, and your protections follow the one your account sits under. Ask which entity someone living where you live would be given.
Do you earn a commission or rebate from the broker when I open an account through your link?
Why ask it
Many do, and it is not wrong in itself, but it means they are paid when you trade whatever happens to your balance. The good answer is a plain yes and how it is calculated. Where 'free' signals are only available after a deposit with one named broker, the commission is the business.
Are you licensed or registered to manage money or give trading advice where I live?
Why ask it
Many countries require this of anyone who trades other people's accounts or gives personal advice, and the rules differ from place to place, so ask which registration they hold and look it up. 'I only teach' is a fair reply from a course seller. It does not cover someone who wants a login to your account.
If you trade for me, whose name is the account in, and are you able to withdraw from it?
Why ask it
The arrangement to look for is an account in your own name at a regulated broker, with the trader given permission to place trades and nothing else. Brokers that allow this have a form for it; ask yours what it is called and what it permits. Sending money to the trader's own account, a crypto wallet or an informal 'pool' leaves you holding a promise and no account of your own, and that is the point to walk away.
How do withdrawals work at that broker, and how long did your last one take?
Why ask it
Have them describe a real withdrawal: the amount, the method, the days it took. Then run your own test with a small deposit and a small withdrawal before adding more. A platform that invents a new fee, a 'tax' or a trading target that must be met before it releases your money is behaving the way fraudulent ones do.
What spreads, commissions and overnight charges would I pay on the trades you take?
Why ask it
These costs land on every trade, win or lose. A method that aims for small gains can work on the trader's account and fail on yours if your spread is wider, and trades held for days collect an overnight charge as well. Compare what they say with the broker's published terms for the account type you would open.
Fees and red flags
What exactly would I pay you, and what do I get for it?
Why ask it
Ask for the full list: the course price, a monthly signal fee, a share of profits, any software. Write down what each one covers and for how long. Tiers where the 'real' strategy is always one level above the one you bought tend to have no top.
If you trade my account, how is your share of the profit worked out, and what happens after a losing month?
Why ask it
Ask whether they are paid only on gains above the account's previous high. Without that rule they can be paid a second time for winning back money they lost. A share of the profit with no share of the loss also rewards big swings, so ask what limits the risk they may take with your money.
What returns do you tell people to expect, and what do you say about losing money?
Why ask it
The right answer has no fixed figure in it and treats losses as likely, above all in the first year. A promised monthly return, or the words 'no risk', is the clearest warning a seller can give you. In some places brokers must publish the share of retail accounts that lose money; ask whether theirs does, and read the number.
Why sell this, when you could simply trade more of your own money?
Why ask it
A real trader will not be offended by it, and there are honest answers: teaching income is steadier, they like the work, or outside money lets them trade a larger sum. Often the truth is that the selling pays better than the trading, which is fine when it is said plainly. The trouble is marketing in which cars and beaches imply that trading paid for them.
Is there a trial or a refund, and how would I cancel if I wanted to stop?
Why ask it
Get the terms in writing before you pay and read the conditions attached. A refund that requires you to attend every session and show that you followed every rule is one nobody collects. Ask too whether a subscription renews on its own and, for a managed account, how much notice ends the arrangement.
How would I pay, and who exactly receives the money?
Why ask it
A registered business that sends an invoice and takes a card is one thing. A personal payment app, a crypto wallet or gift cards is another: money sent that way is very hard to get back if the person disappears. Match the name on the payment to the name of the company you checked.
Will I be asked to bring in other people, or paid when I do?
Why ask it
Some forex 'academies' are built around recruiting, with a commission for every new member signed up. Ask what share of members' earnings comes from trading and what share from referrals, and whether the monthly fee is waived for those who recruit. If the conversation keeps drifting from charts to building a team, the membership is the product.
What do people who complain about you say, and where would I find those complaints?
Why ask it
Anyone who has sold to the public for a few years has some unhappy customers, and can tell you what they were unhappy about. Search the name yourself with the words complaint, scam and refund, and check whether your country's financial regulator keeps a warning list. A flat 'there are none' deserves the search even more.
Can I take a week to check what you have told me before I pay anything?
Why ask it
The answer you want is 'of course', followed by the links you need. Use the week on three things: the regulator's register, the verified record and the test withdrawal. Countdown timers, 'only three places left' and a discount that ends tonight are there to stop you doing precisely that.
The job
How did you get into currency trading, and what did the first year cost you?
Why ask it
Most traders have a story about the money they lost while learning, and the ones worth listening to tell it without dressing it up. If you are thinking of starting, ask what they would do differently with that first account. Skip the second half if you are only making conversation; not everyone wants to say a number.
How long was it before you made more than you lost over a full year?
Why ask it
The answer is more often years than months, and it usually comes with an account or two that did not survive. Ask what finally changed: the method, the size of the trades or their patience. It is also the thing to ask a seller who says you will be profitable in weeks.
What does an ordinary trading day look like, hour by hour?
Why ask it
The real answer is usually duller than the ads: a lot of waiting, a few minutes of decisions, then notes. Ask which market sessions they trade and what that has done to their sleep and their evenings. It is a good opener for a class project or a career-day interview because it is easy to answer at length.
Do you trade your own money, a funded account from a trading firm, or a bank's book, and how does that change the work?
Why ask it
These are three different jobs with different rules, pay and pressure. If a funded-account program interests you, ask what the evaluation costs, which rules end an account and how payouts have gone for them personally. Terms vary from firm to firm, so read the firm's own rules instead of relying on a summary.
How do you keep your head after three losses in a row?
Why ask it
Listen for a routine instead of a slogan: cutting size, stopping for the day, going back through the journal. Traders who have lasted tend to describe something almost boring here. Whatever the routine is, a beginner can borrow it on the first day.
What would you tell someone who wants to start with a small account?
Why ask it
Sensible advice tends to sound unexciting: practice on a demo, then trade the smallest size the broker allows, expect to lose at first and keep the day job. See whether the reply is advice or a link to their course. Asked of a relative or a friend who trades, this is often the question most worth asking.
If you were starting again, would you still choose trading, and what would you change?
Why ask it
Ask it late, once they have relaxed. The thoughtful answers mention how many years it took, what it did to their time and the people around them, and whether the money was worth it. A pause before the answer is usually a sign that you are about to hear something true.
How to question a forex trader before you pay or copy them
Practical guidance for the conversation itself
Before you talk
Decide what you are being sold
A course, a signal subscription and a managed account are three different purchases with different risks. With a course you can lose the fee. With signals you can lose the fee and whatever you trade. With a managed account you can lose all of it without placing a trade yourself. Know which one is on the table before the call.
Ask for the record first
Request the link to a verified live record before you agree to a call. A seller who goes quiet at that request has answered most of this list already. If the link does arrive, read the monthly results and the deepest fall beforehand so that the conversation can be about how those numbers came about.
Fix your own limit
Settle on the largest sum you could lose entirely without it changing your month, and write it down. A persuasive conversation is a bad place to choose that number, and a seller will always have a reason why slightly more would work better.
Pick the questions that fit
For a mentor or a course, lean on Track record and Strategy. For signals, add the two copying questions that close Strategy and the cost question under Broker and rules. For anyone who wants to trade your money, ask everything under Broker and rules and under Fees and red flags, and get the answers by email. If you are only curious about the work, or interviewing a trader for a class or a podcast, start with The job.
During the conversation
Ask for numbers, then stay quiet
Risk per trade, the deepest fall, losing months in the last year: each has a one-line answer. Ask, and leave the silence alone. A long story where a number should be is worth noting.
Ask about losses before wins
Anyone can talk about a good trade. How a trader describes a bad month, a broken rule or an emptied account shows you how they will talk to you when your account is down.
Say out loud that you will check
Tell them you plan to look up the broker, the registration and the record yourself. A trader with nothing to hide will send the links before you ask twice. Irritation at being checked is information.
Do not decide on the call
Thank them, ask for the fee and the terms in writing, and end it there. Nothing a real trader offers gets worse if you take a week over it.
Checking the answers afterwards
The register
Go to the regulator's website by your own search and look up both the broker's legal name and the trader's, if they said they were registered. Compare the company name, the country and the web address with the ones you were given. Clone sites that borrow a real firm's name exist, so the details have to match exactly.
The record
On the verified page, confirm that it is a real-money account, that the record and the balance are both marked as verified, and that the history is longer than a few months. Then look for the three things from the conversation: the deepest fall, the losing months, and whether losing trades are closed or left open.
The costs on your own account
Open the broker's published terms for the account type you would hold and find the spread on the pairs the trader uses, the commission and the overnight charges. Set them beside the size of the trader's average win. If the costs take a large bite out of that figure, the method may not survive being copied.
The small test
If everything else holds up, start with the smallest amount the broker accepts and withdraw part of it within the first two weeks. A withdrawal that arrives as described is a better reference than any testimonial.
Signs to walk away
A promised return
Nobody who trades currencies can know next month's result. A fixed percentage a month, a 'risk-free' account or a promise to cover your losses describes something other than trading.
Money sent to a person
If the deposit goes to an individual's bank account, a payment app or a crypto wallet instead of an account in your own name at a broker you have checked, you have no account to watch or withdraw from, only that person's word.
An approach you did not invite
A stranger on a social or dating app who mentions, a few weeks in, a platform that has done well for them is following a known script. So is a 'recovery agent' who offers to get lost money back for a fee paid in advance.
Withdrawals that need another payment
A balance that grows on screen but can only be released after a tax, a fee or one more deposit is very unlikely ever to be released. Stop paying, keep every message and report it to your bank and to the financial regulator or fraud reporting service where you live.